Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

31st July 1873

Fatal Mining Accident at Micklam Pit

On Tuesday last, an inquest was held in the Magistrates Office, Whitehaven, before Thomas Howson, Esq, deputy-coroner, and a jury, of whom Mr. James Hind was chosen foreman, on view of a miner named Joseph Spence, who was killed whilst working in Micklam Pit, Harrington, on Monday last. The inquest was attended by Mr. G. W. Southern, Inspector of mines in this district, and Mr. G. Liddell, Assistant Inspector. Mr. Simpson, manager to Messrs. Bain and Paterson, was also present at the inquiry.

The jury having viewed the body, the Coroner proceeded to open the inquiry, previously introducing to the jury Mr. Southern, who, he said, would no doubt be able to give them some valuable assistance.

The Inspector said he was sorry to say that his assistance would be very much curtailed, from the fact that he was prevented from going down the pit — a thing, which had not happened to him before.

A Juror inquired whether the Inspector was refused permission to go down the pit.

The inspector said that a man at the pit threw objections in the way to prevent him going down. He was half undressed to go down when he was refused leave. He happened to hear of the accident when he was away from home at the railway station, and he went immediately, hoping to get a jacket and a pair of trousers to put over his own, but he was refused them by a man named Storey, who was a witness now present.

The Coroner had no doubt the Inspector would be able to deal with this part of the affair himself.

The first witness called was William Storey, who deposed that he lived at Parton, and was a pump wright at Micklam Pit, a pit in the occupation of Messrs. Bain and Paterson, of Harrington. Knew the deceased well. He was a driver in the eye, the first eye in the yard seam, which was about 30 fathoms from the surface, and about 54 fathoms from the bottom of the shaft. He was also hooker-on at the eye. Witness was at work from two o'clock in the afternoon to ten o'clock at night. On Monday he was at the pit at half past one. A boy told him that they could not find the driver. William Veitch, the deputy overman, was looking for him. The searchers went down the pit and came up again. As soon as they came up witness and a brother of his, together with another man named Thomas Lord, went down at about two o'clock. At a stage about seven fathoms from the bottom, and which was broken up, he found a piece of the deceased's trousers. He went further down and found the body of the deceased in the water at the bottom of the pit. He was quite dead. He was brought up to the top. Did not know how the deceased came to be at the bottom. There were proper signal handles, worked by a good strong wire, so the deceased might communicate with the top. The banksman let the men down in the morning. Did not know who was the on-setter.

By the Inspector: There was a signal hammer into the yard seam, and also to the engine-house, and from top to bottom and bottom to top. There was no scaffold at the yard seam. There were merely "keps."

By the Coroner: When the cage was down there was no fear of anything, it was a platform. The cage would be about three or four feet square. The shaft was eleven feet wide, but there was no space at the side of the cage, it was railed off and covered over. When the man put the tub on, he rapped one, and then the engineman drew up the tub. Deceased had a good light. Examined the front of the eye. Did not go in.

By the inspector: Witness had no authority to let anyone down the pit. There was no one allowed down the pit unless the manager was with him.

The Inspector: You were told twice who I was.

The witness said he thought it would have been better for the Inspector to have seen Mr. Glaister (the colliery manager).

The Inspector said he could not stay for Mr. Glaister, His time was valuable, and the witness ought to have been satisfied.

The witness said he had no authority to let any one go down the pit.

A Juror inquired if there was any one present when the Inspector went to the pit who had authority to let him go down.

The witness: If there were any one they're this afternoon, I would not let him down.

The Inspector: Would you let me down? If I had had my pit clothes with me yesterday, it would have been at your peril to make any objections. I simply went in my own dress. I know very well how it is — I have had to do with your owners before this.

By the Coroner: If any one comes to see the mine, they have got to see the manager.

The Inspector: I sent a messenger to Mr. Paterson and to Mr. Glaister. Have you no different orders now?

The witness: No sir, I have no different orders. I would not let any one down while I was there.

The Inspector: Then they had better send you off as soon as possible.

William Veitch deposed that he was deputy overman of Micklam Pit. Was on duty there on Monday. Went about five or six in the morning. The deceased was there. He drove for four haggers on Monday. He had been a driver for about four months. He put the laden trucks on the cage and took the empties off. When the cage was in the proper place there was no possibility of a man falling down. The cage had no roof. Four iron bars met at the hook on the chain. If the cage was stopped too high the deceased might get under it. The cage could be seen when on the "keps." About a quarter to one o'clock on Monday witness was standing in the yard about 15 yards from the shaft, and he heard an unusual noise, and ran to the shaft and shouted "Joe". The noise was like something rattling down the shaft. Witness was one of those employed in filling the tubs. Joseph Spence took the tub away from where they filled it in the direction of the shaft. There were two closed airtight doors between witness and deceased. Deceased would have to go six yards past these to the cage. Witness ran through the doors and shouted. Got no answer — deceased was gone. The cage was there, level with the "flat sheets." Did not hear the cage come down to the "keps" but the deceased had taken the empty tub of it. The tub was on the empty side. Knew the empty tub was there, because it had a particular thing in it. It had the horse's corn and hay and water in it.

By the Inspector: It had not been the system, so far as witness knew, for the banksman to run the cage up and down without signals.

The Inspector: Has he not sent the cage from the top without a signal from the bottom, or from the yard seam?

The witness: I do not know. There are two good signals.

The Inspector: I know, but the question is, have they been used?

The witness: That is another thing. I do not know that the brakesman has sent the cage down without a signal.

By the Coroner: There were eleven tubs in use, and there was one missing now. It was impossible for the tub to go to the bottom if the cage had been at the "keps".

The Coroner referred to the rules of the colliery, by which it was directed that the engineman should not start his engine without a signal being given.

By the Coroner: Supposing the tub went over down the shaft when the cage was not there, it might pull the deceased after it. The cage always came to the right place and rattled down on the "keps"

William Hodge deposed that he was an engineman at Micklam Pit. Went on duty on Monday about seven o'clock in the morning, and left off at five at night. Was on duty all that time. Let no men down on Monday. Drew men up when they came up. From seven o'clock in the morning was engaged in winding up the metal and minding the pumping engine. That engine was below the other, and did not require much attention. Had two firemen to each engine, and they were there all day on Monday. Attended to the signals of the "hanger-on," and to any signal he got from below. Witness could reply to the signals below. When the cage rested upon the "keps" it took the weight off the rope, and the rope appeared to slack, and there was also an indicator, which showed by a pointer when the cage had got to the "keps". Witness always had his eye upon that when he was lowering. Never knew the cage stick. The sides had never wanted repair since witness came to the pit. On Monday witness got a signal that some one wanted to come up. It was a signal of three raps. Witness was not expecting a signal of three raps at that time. He had had a signal of one shortly before, and drew up a full tub and sent down an empty one. An empty tub was sent down, and witness got a signal from deceased to heave away. When he lifted he found the cage was light. Witness brought the cage to within half a turn of the top, and then he heard two distant raps. That was for the cage to be lowered back. Witness lowered it till it rested on the "keps." That was the meaning of it being there when the deputy came to it. There was about seven minutes between the two raps and the three.

By the Inspector: The deceased must have given the two raps before he went down the shaft. The men never signalled from the bottom for the cage to come down.

By the Coroner: The handles of the signals were close to the cage and could be reached by the deceased accidentally. It was the practice at the pit, and it had been done every day since the deceased came, to lower the cage without a signal from the bottom. The cage at the top was never moved until the banksman gave the signal.

John McCracken deposed that he lived at Lowca Brow, and was a boiler-cleaner at the pit. Was acting as banksman on Monday? The deceased sent up a tub, and when it came up witness took it off and put an empty one on. Sent down an empty tub about a quarter to nine. Sent down some hay, corn and water between twelve and one o'clock. Got a tub of metal back in exchange for that. Emptied the full tub, and when he got back the cage was coming up. Heard the two knocks. The engineman stopped the engine, and reversed and lowered right away again. Heard the deputy rap three.

Thomas Glaister deposed that he was manager of the Harrington collieries. He had charge of Micklam Pit. The average out-put was not more than from twelve to ten tons per day, and they were only working the one seam. One engineman attended to both engines. When the onsetter brought a tub of coal out he put it on the cage, and it was drawn up, the tub taken off, and the cage was always kept at the bottom. The banksman signalled the engineman to lower away, and the onsetter knew that he had only to wait for the cage coming. The cage was used as a scaffold and protection at the eye, so that nothing could go down the shaft. In the seven minutes between the two raps and the three the cage might have got to the bottom.

By the Inspector: The plan of the pit was kept at the office at Harrington.

The Inspector pointed out that by the Act of Parliament a plan was directed to be kept at the pit.

By the Inspector: A loose scaffold might be put over the shaft at the eye, but it would be inconvenient.

George Cunningham deposed that he was an engineer, and was in charge of the machinery at Micklam Pit. The indicator could make no mistake whatever if the engine moved it was bound to turn. It was not the rule in a single shaft working to have a signal to send down an empty cage. If the deceased had been looking at all, he would see whether the cage was in its place or not.

The Coroner pointed out that the rules said that the engine must not be started without a signal.

The Foreman said that the engineman got a signal from the banksman to start.

The Inspector said the banksman had no right to signal for the bottom. The engineman had no right to take the signal from the banksman to let the cage down — he must have a signal from below.

The witness said that his experience was that such a signal would not be practicable.

Edward Duffy, a brother-in-law of the deceased, deposed to his age. Deceased was in his 26th year.

The Coroner then summed up the evidence.

A Juror requested the views of the Inspector as to the evidence.

The Inspector said the Coroner had stated the case very clearly. He (the Inspector) thought there was no evidence to show neglect. Certainly an improvement should be made with regard to signalling, and it would be a great deal safer if gates were put on. With regard to his being prevented going down the pit he might say he went immediately he heard of the accident, and he asked for the principle in charge. Storey came forward, and he (the Inspector) asked Storey if he could find him a jacket and trousers to go down, and he said he could. He went down to a cabin below, and he came back with another man and said that he could not.

A Juror asked if it would assist the jury in any way if the inquiry was adjourned till the Government Inspector had been down the pit.

The Inspector said he might give the jury his opinion on that, and that was that he thought it hardly would, because they had not two men together at the accident.

The Coroner said that it seemed that the parties employed had been following out the usual system, and if they were all doing that there could be no charge of manslaughter. The jury might make any representation respecting improvements to the Coroner, who would set in motion the Inspector, who would use his discretion about putting them in force at the colliery.

The Inspector said if he had the opinion of the jury through the Coroner it should be attended to.

The Jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death."

Mr. Simpson, with the permission of the Coroner, said that he was certain that if he had been at the pit no one would have been more glad to have seen the Inspector, and to allow him to see the whole of the pit. Messrs. Bain and Paterson would have been glad to give every facility, and whatever hindrance the Inspector received had been a result of inadvertence. A short time ago some persons were admitted into the shaft, and a serious accident happened, and after that an order was issued that no one should be admitted. If the man had known that Mr. Southern was the Inspector, he would, he (Mr. Simpson) thought, would have admitted him. The man had done a thing that he (Mr. Simpson) would not have done, and he hoped the Inspector would excuse the man for it.

The Inspector said it would require some further consideration.

Mr. Simpson said that the firm would be glad at any time listen to the Inspectors opinion on everything.

The Inspector said he had no doubt the man had acted from instructions, but when he was told twice by Mr. Harper, whom he knew, who he (the Inspector) was, he ought to have let him go down.

Mr. Simpson: I quite agree with you; he ought.

The Inspector; I will have him committed if he goes that way again.

The inquiry then terminated.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bain, —    Mine Owner  
Cunningham, George    Engineer  
Duffy, Edward      
Glaister, Thomas    Manager  
Hind, James    Jury Foreman  
Hodge, William    Engineman  
Howson, Thomas    Deputy Coroner  
Liddell, Gerard Henry    H.M. Assistant Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Lord, Thomas    Miner  
McCracken, John    Boiler Cleaner  
Patterson, —    Mine Owner  
Simpson, —    Manager  
Southern, George William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Spence, Joseph    Miner  
Spence, Joseph   25 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Storey, William    Pump Wright  
Veitch, William    Deputy Overman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Micklam Colliery  Micklam Colliery
Micklam No. 5  Micklam No. 5


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print