|
15th May 1873 The Committee on CoalEvidence Of Mr. ForsterMr. George Baker Forster has been examined as a witness by the Coal Committee. Mr. Forster, from his experience as a mining engineer, and from his connection with the extensive coalmines of the Earl of Lonsdale, must speak with authority on the question now under investigation. We give this evidence in extenso:— At the sitting of the committee on the 1st of May. Mr. Forster in answer to the Chairman, said he was connected with the Northumberland colliery district, and had three or four collieries under his personal charge as manager. By the chairman: Have you any accounts to show the working of the collieries in your district? — Yes there are thirty-seven collieries, and the number of hewers employed in them during the last three years is as follows:— 1871, 7,249; in 1872, 7,435; and in 1879, 7,784. What proportion do they bear to the whole number of men? The total number in 1871 was 15,592; in 1872 they were 16,282; and in 1873 they were 17,825. And what has been the output of coal? — In 1871, it was 5,744.834 statute tons; in 1872 it was 5,770,428 tons; and in 1873 (for the first three months) it was 1,326,627 tons. Then is that much below 1872? — That would give 7.1 per percent below, but I do not think that will be carried through the year. Will it be more or less? — It will be more, and will get up to last years output. How much does that output give per hewer each year? — In 1871, it was 796 tons; in 1872, 776 tons; in the first three months of 1873, 681 tons. Now, to what do you attribute that diminution in the first three mouths of this year? Entirely to the shortened hours. Have you worked out the number of tons per man? — Yes in 1871 it was 372; in 1872 it was 354; and in 1873 it was 297. Are the collieries worked during the whole week? — Only five days per week at present. You mean they are absolutely shut up on other days? Absolutely shut up on Saturdays and Sundays. In 1871 and 1872 we worked nominally eleven days per fortnight, there being only one holiday in a fortnight, but the real days of work were 10.3. At present we work actually 9.4 days per fortnight. Well then what was the average of work per man whilst the pits were open? — In 1871 it was 8.85 days per fortnight; in 1872, 8.93 per fortnight; and in 1873, 8.01 per fortnight. To what do you attribute this diminution of the time of the pits being opened, and the number of days per man? — The diminution arises from the operation of the Mines Act at the beginning of the year, and both men and masters consider it would be better to work five days of ten hours, than six days of nine hours. Yes, but it would seem you were working only the five days? — Rather more. It is not the absolute enactment of the Mines Regulation Act; but you have found it inconvenient to employ it? — Yes, owing to the system of working pursued in the north, where we work in shifts. We need two shifts of boys, as well as two shifts of men. Can you state what have been the wages earned during this period? — The wages for hewers in 1871 were 5s 5¾d per day; in 1872, 8s per day; and in 1873 they were 9s 1¾ d per day. Can you give us the increase per cent of wages over all? — Not altogether. I can only give you the increase upon the separate items. The normal increase has been 50 per cent., but the concessions have made the actual advance 66 per cent. as between 1871 and 1873. Do you know whether 1871 was to be regarded as a very low rate? — There had been reduction in Northumberland — in fact, it had been gradually increasing since I can recollect. Was not the rate of wages in Northumberland affected by the slack demand for coal in the previous three of four years? — No there was no reduction made. What was the percentage of increase for the other classes besides hewers, who appear to have 60 per cent? — About 50 per cent. — That is in addition to the reduction in the hours. How are the men paid in your district? — By the ton. By Mr. Mundella: Have you, by looking at your general pay-sheets, been able to ascertain what has been the increase or otherwise, of the earnings of the men during the fortnight? — Yes, by the money they draw. If you multiply these days by the average earnings, you have it at once. The average is £3 4s 6d. Can you tell us what are the higher and lower rates of which this is the average? — I have no idea. We work entirely on the average. What are the numbers of hours the men work per day? — in 1871 it was from six and a half to seven hours; in 1872 from six to six and a half hours; and in 1873 from five and a-half to six hours. That is the actual work in the pit. The men have Houses, gardens and firing free; through they have to pay for the loading of the coal. Do the men provide anything, or have they their wages clear? — They provide picks, prickers, steamers, candles, and gunpowder; but where safety lamps are used they only supply the oil. That does not amount to more than 1s per week. Then, with respect to the production of coal, has there been any difficulty in increasing the production during these three-year? Has the production been limited by the wish of the owners? — Not by the wish of the owners or any one. The question I wish you to answer is, whether if owners have wished to produce more coal during the last three years they have had any difficulty in doing so? — No, not except by reduction of hours. Have they not been able to get more men? — Yes, to a great extent. To the extent of your desire? — No they are still building houses, which means more men, in our district. But I want to know whether they have been hindered in any way? — No. I think the owners have done as much as they could to meet the exigencies of the occasion. When did the demand become difficult to meet? — Towards the latter end of 1871. From that time to this has the demand been in excess of your power to meet it — Yes. To what is that chiefly attributable? — To the increase of steam shipping generally, and the increased trade of the country, the iron trade amongst other branches. Is the coal used to a very large extent in your district for purposes of iron manufacture? — Not to a large extent. It is exported to other districts, and taken away in steamers. Are there any other works great consumers of coal in the district or neighbourhood? — No. There are alkali works, foundries, and engine and machine works, which use the small coal, but no large quantity of the best coal. What effects has that upon the price of coal in the district? — The price has risen from 12s to 20s, and in some cases, 25s per ton for best coal. What was the price in 1871? — 12s. Is that the average price of all kinds? — No, of the best coal only. The lowest price was no more than 5s, but I cannot give you the average, because I do not know. When you speak of best coal, do you mean picked coal for household purposes? — No, steam coal. That is screened coal-large coal? — Yes. Has the price been fixed at any meeting of owners? — There have been meetings of Coalowners. Can you give us the average of the rise in prices from 1871 to the present time? — No, not exactly. Do you know whether there is any combination of coal proprietors to increase the price? — There is an association. Are the results of its deliberations published in the newspapers? — Not generally. Do you know whether the rise in the rate of wages has followed the advance from time to time in the price of coal? — It did. Do you think the workmen were induced to make the demand in consequence of seeing the coals going up every day? — Quite so. Are any steps being taken to increase the supply of coal in your district? — Yes new pits are being sunk, old pits are being re-opened, and the plant has been increased to a very large extent. In your opinion will the production keep pace with the increased demand? — I think it will. Do you think it will bring prices back to their former rate? — Not to the old rate, but it will reduce prices greatly. Have you any reason to believe that the increased demand for coal has caused the lesssees of collieries to employ their men chiefly in winning the coal, and to neglect the dead, work? — On the contrary, the staff has been increased the proportion of men so employed being 1.14 in 1871, 1.19 in 1872, and 1.29 in 1873. Is that the purpose of safety? — Entirely for working the ordinary headings of the pit. Is all the coal got out? — At one time the hewers were allowad to throw back part of the small coal, but now that is removed; and formerly we had large heaps of small coal above ground, for which we had no market, and which was burned where it lay. Now you find a market? — Yes. It was manufactured into blocks, or sent away as small coal? — Some of it is sold for the purpose of being made into blocks but it is not so manufactured by us, and it is principally used as small coal. By the Chairman: Do you think the men profit by the high rate of wages? — I have no doubt they do. The are a very steady set of men in our district, and do not move much about. I believe they are saving money now. Certainly, in their personal appearance and in their houses they have improved, and they are very anxious for education. Then the effect of the new Act will be to advance education? — It will not be the effect of the Act. We do not want to employ boys under the age it mentions. They are not required? — We would rather they did not go down the pit below the age of twelve. Do you find any difficulty in getting boys at twelve? — Not any. Are the wages of pit boys of twelve higher than in other occupations in your district? — Yes. What proportion of coal is exported in that district? — I should say nearly all the "round" coal-the large coal — I cannot give you the percentage. Do you think that that and the large increase in steam shipping has really increased the price of coal? — I do. I suppose there are coalowners associations in the district? —There are several. What is the object of these associations? — Some are merely to watch parliamentary proceediage, some to negotiate with the men as to the wages, and some to consider prices. And the other is a general combination of all three? — No, they are separate. Do I understand these have all distinct objects? — One we call the United Coal Trade Association Includes both Durham and Northumberland, and that looks after parliamentary and general matters. And which association is it that discusses wages and prices? There is an association, which discusses wages called the Steam Coal Defence Association. And what association is it that dispenses prices? — The Northumberland Steam Coal Association. I may say the Steam Coal Association does not include anything like the number of colliers I have given you. By Mr. Corrance: You speak of a defence association, what do you defend yourselves against? — Against anybody that attacks us. We have been attacked by all parties. Can you mention one party? — We are attacked on questions of wages, and questions of rating and Parliamentary, and a variety of other matters. It is called the Steam Coal Defence Association, to show it was not an association to reduce the wages. If your assessment were raised in consequence of your great profits, you would defend yourselves against that? — If we thought it unfair. We also have railway dues and river charges to meet. Have you any defence against the unions? — We have against strikes. We have for some time met the union delegates, and have had a joint committee of coalmasters, and so many men to discuss arising between the two parties. Do you consider that a good plan? — I think it is a excellent plan, and has produced a much better feeling amongst masters and men than existed under the old system. By Mr. Pease: Is there any difference in the class of men employed in the steam coal colliers? — The labour on the staem.coal is much harder, and requires a stronger lot of men than employed in the other coal. How do you pay your men? — Fortnightly. Have the men asked to be paid weekly? — I am not sure. I think they did once but the matter had dropped. There is no combination amongst the men to reduce the output? — No, I think they work harder now than before, while they are employed. And there is no such combination amongst the masters? — No. Are you aware whether any steam coal is sent foreign? — It is used very largely by shipping, but I cannot give the proportion. The committee adjoined the further examination of Mr. Forster to Monday. On Monday Mr. Foster was recalled. Mr. Wharton: I think you told us that the coal in your district is chiefly used for steam shipping purposes? — Yes. For export to foreign ports? — Partly and partly for our own navy. And some, I suppose finds its way into the London market? — Yes some comes to the London market too. Have any new pits been opened lately? — Yes new pits have been opened within the past few years. Do you see much prospect of getting a sufficient supply of men? — Yes. Out of Northumberland? — Yes; and from other districts and other trades. Were do your men principally come from? — From the North — from Scotland, Lancaster, Yorkshire, and all the northern districts. You do not find many come from the South? — We have some but not a great many. I want to ask you a question about the colliers' houses in your district. Are they superior to the usual run of pit houses? — They are very much superior to the usual run — they are larger and the accommodation is better. Have you known cases of overcrowding of houses by the holders having to take lodgers? — No case of the kind has come to my personal knowledge. There has been nothing of the kind in your district? — No. What in your opinion is the best method of pay — weekly or fortnightly? — Fortnightly. Both for the sake of the men and the masters? — Yes. Is their any truck system still there? — There never was any in my district. Mr. Carter; The temperatures in your pits is not very high? — Not at all. Do the men usually work in almost a nude state? — Oh, no, they work in shirt; drawers and stockings. I think you said your coal required a stronger class of men than ordinary? — Yes, but there are some pits in the County of Durham where the coal seams are rather softer than in others. You give us as the price of coal from 12s to 20s. And stated that in some cases it was as high as 25s. Would the last figure be for a very superior quality of steam coal? — Yes; and for ready terms. Do you show any favour to the larger demands for ship loading? — In former times it was the practice to load them in turn. Now we usually guarantee to load them in a certain number of days. Mr. Hussey Vivian: Have you any experience of coal cutting machines? — Not personally. I have been to see them at work. But I have no personal experience of them. From what you have seen, do you believe they will here after enable coal to be produced at a cheaper rate? — I think they will enable it to be produced in better condition, but I do not know whether it will be much cheaper. Have you seen any in successful operations? — Oh yes, some in Northumberland and some in Yorkshire. In Yorkshire I saw Mr. Firth's rotatory machine. Why have you not adopted them yourselves? — We have not thought that they were sufficiently developed. Mr. Hussey Vivian: What are the average royalties? — About 6d a ton. They do not in Northumberland depend upon the price of coal at all, but in Cumberland they do. Have you way dues for coal passing over different properties? — We have to the extent about a penny a ton in each case. Then if you went over six or seven properties it would amount to a very serious charge? — Yes; but I do not know any case where it passes over so many as six. I wish to ask whether prior to the recent rise the collieries in your district have been profitable undertakings? — I should say a great many had not. The Chairman; You mean at some certain period before the rise. Mr. H. Vivian: I mean the time at which the very low prices prevailed — the time, for instance, when the price was 12s for a large, and they were not able to sell the slack at all? — The prices have been much lower than that. The lowest price was 5s 6d for the best coal. At that price could any collieries be carried on at a profit? — I do not know; that was before I was in the neighbourhood. I think you said that the men do not work full time. Can you form any estimate of the quantity of coal, which would be produced in excess of that which you are now producing if full time were worked? — I should say about 20 per cent. if they worked full time at pit work. You said they only work five days a week at pit work? — Yes. Of ten hours each? — Yes. The men during that time do as much work as they can? — Yes, those who do work. What proportion remains idle without being ill? — I cannot distinguish those who are idle from illness from those who are idle because they will not work. Mr. Liddell: With regard to coal-cutting machines, has there not been a good deal of difficulty experienced in adjusting the power of compressed air to the work to be done by the machine? — Yes. And it is from that cause that the main difficulty has arisen? — I believe so. But that is a difficulty, which, I presume experience will enable you to get over? — I have no doubt it will. It has been got over in some cases. Have you always a supply of timber by you? — Constantly; that is one of the first rules. I want to ask you a question with regards to small collieries — has a considerable stimulus been given within the last 18 months or two years to collieries of that kind which formerly only supplied the inland demand to bring their coal on to the main line, and so supplement the general market? — I know some small collieries, which have done so. And it has been a feature in those collieries? — Yes, several have been called in by the high price to assist in the general supply. In that case, of course, the necessity arises for the owners to increase their staff of workmen. Have they experienced much difficulty in doing that? — Not when they have built houses. But the building of houses is not done in a day, and you are liable to interruption from masons and carpenters strikes in providing additional accommodation? — We have not suffered much from that cause. The Act of last year limited the number of hours for boys to 54 a-week — Are there any negotiations going on among the men in your district, or any district with which you are acquainted, to reduce the working hours to 10 per day? — They are reduced to 10 per day. By the actual operation of the law? — Yes. Mr. Liddell: Not by Act of Parliament? — But the hours that the boys work influence the whole concern. For many years we have never allowed boys under twelve to go down the pits. Do you find any disposition on the part of parents after better education has been afforded to the children to send their sons to other employment than mining? Is there any greater indisposition to employ them in pits when they have the advantage of better education? — Oh, no. I think they like to get them in the pits where they work themselves. Then you have no fear of that which some have expressed — that the old race of pitmen is likely to die out? — No, not at all. I believe there are few, if any, manufactures in your neighbourhood competing with you for boys labour? — None in the mining district of Northumberland. There are no manufactures competing for boys in our immediate neighbourhood. Collieries on the banks of the Tyne may be liable to such competition with the factories there. You have been asked several questions about the possibility of increasing the number of men employed — have you ever refused employment? — Yes, to a great number. Was that because you did not think the men qualified for the work? — No, it was because we had no room for them. Then you had more applicants than you could employ? — Certainly. Men or boys? — The boys always go with the men. We refused them because we had neither houses nor work for them. Then the inference the committee should draw is that if you wished to increase your staff you could do so almost to any amount? — Practically, yes. Only limited by the house room? — Yes. Have prices fluctuated at all or to any considerable extent in the interval between 1871 and the first quarter of 1873, or has the rise been steady? — They fluctuated. At the end of last year the price went down considerably — from 25s to 18s per ton. And rose again when? — At the beginning of this year. Then prices remained probably stationary in the autumn? — Yes, in November and December. Then there was a sudden rise in January this year — to what extent? — 2s. Do you attribute the high price in any degree to the anticipated effect of recent legislation? — I still believe it is greatly attributable to that. Have you formed any estimate in your own mind of what you think the increased cost of production will be under the provisions of that Act? — No, not under the provision of the Act. The Chairman: How do you connect the rise in price with the operation of the Act? — The quantity produced was shortened at the beginning of the year. But how do you connect the shortening of the quantity with the operation of the Act? — We lost one eleventh of our power. We lost an hour a day, and in fact more. We lost a day in a fortnight. And you have not been able so to adjust the work as to make the quantity up again? — No, we shall never get full time again. You know that the high prices brought into the market an immense amount of coal that was formerly collected in heaps at the pits?—There were large heaps of inferior coal, and they have been taken away by degrees. Mr. Liddell: I believe I am correct in saying that on the whole the relations between masters and men in the Northumberland district have been very satisfactory? — I may say they have been very satisfactory. Strikes have been few and far between? — Very few of late years. And all differences have been adjusted by conciliatory steps on both sides? — Yes. By Mr. George Elliot: I believe some years ago you used to use a small quantity of small coal? — We did. And the quantity you used to send up was not all saleable? — Yes. What per cent would be unsaleable? About 10 per cent but the quantity varies with the state of trade. Sometimes we had a sale for the whole, sometimes for none. Take the average brought up and left underground, what would be saleable? — 15 or 20 per cent previous to 1869, but 1869 was the worst time. You give us on Thursday the advance of wages of the coal getter at 66 per cent., and other persons at 50 per cent. Is the 50-cent for the same length of time as the 66 per cent. or for a shorter amount of time? — Many of the men have had their hours shortened. Of course, all the boys have had their hours-shortened one-sixth. Then assuming that they work the same amount of time would the percentage be more than fifty? — I should estimate it about sixty. Then the advances are very much the same for off-hand people as for the coal getters? — Yes; but remember that the hewers have had their hours shortened as well. And you pay them by the ton? — Yes; but they make an increase of 66 per cent. Then, in addition to the 66 per cent increase received in cash every fortnight, you say that they work less time? — Yes. How much less? — An hour a day. How many per cent is that? — About 12 per cent. Then you give 66 per cent more wages for 12 per cent less time? — Yes, that is so. Taking fourteen of fifteen years previous to 1871, can you form any approximate idea of the percentage upon his capital the coalowner in Northumberland realised during that period? — I am hardly in a position to give an answer to that. But you have the materials to give the answer to very nearly a correct approximation? — No, I have no general materials. I merely ask you for your information as to what would be the advantage for fourteen years previous to 1871? — I cannot say, but I do not think it would be a very remunerative percentage. Some of the witnesses have said that which I have not heard till I heard it here that some of the working men have refused to work coal for stock or heaping. Have you any experience of that? — Oh, no. As to the coals sent on railways, do the owners find the rolling stock? — Yes and they have at this moment a large stock on the Blythe and Tyne railway, and some on the Northeastern for shipment. What do you mean by a large stock? — I should think 20,000 tons and it comes chiefly from four pits. I believe you have had in your district a coals owners association for many years? — We have. And the miners have had also an association for many years? — They have. Has that not been so in Durham? — No. And you have managed by these two associations to prevent what we may call small strikes? — Quite so. When any differences have arisen, you have managed to settle them better by negotiation between these two associations than you would have been able to do without them? — I think we have. Mr. E. Price: You provide houses for your workmen? — Yes. At what cost? — £75 apiece for three roomed houses, and we have some four-roomed. Mr. Corrance: I suppose the number of boys you can get will afford a pretty accurate index of the number of men to whom you can give employment? — We must have a certain proportion of boys. Do you find the employment restricted under the operation of the Act? — The work is reduced from eleven to ten days a fortnight. That, I suppose has had an indirect influence in reducing the profits of the collieries? — Yes, in reducing the quantity produced and therefore the profit. The Act of Parliament imposes certain restrictions, and a collier who has children must find that he cannot employ them as heretofore? — He can except for one day a fortnight. But under the restrictions their earnings are not so large? — Prices have advanced. If prices had not advanced they would have felt it? — Yes. And thus the operation of the act would have pressed upon the colliers themselves? — Yes, to some extent. As it is they make no objection to it? — No, on the contrary they approve of it. If bad times were to come, and there should be a great fall in prices, what would be the result? — I do not think they would press for any alteration. It is a very small diminution in the work. The Chairman: What is the distance that the boys draw the coal from the hewer? — If they draw it more than 130 yards, they get extra pay, and then they do not draw the load by hand, but by ponies. Then if the floor is cut down or the roof raised to enable a pony to pass a man might do the work? — Yes, but a boy does the work best, being more active, and better able to stow himself out of the way. The Chairman: Does a hewer keep a boy employed? — A boy can draw more coal than one man can hew. Mr. Pease: What are the wages of boys? — They were about 3s a day in 1871, and they rose to 4s in 1872, and 5s in 1873. That is, boys between twelve and sixteen? — Between fourteen and sixteen. Is that computed by the number of hours they work or the number of tons they assist in bringing up? — The tubs raised per diem. Mr. Liddell: What is the weight of the tub? — From 6 to 13 cwt. What would boys between twelve and fourteen earn? — Formerly, the lowest earnings was 1s a day, now it is 1s 6d. The witness then withdrew.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||