Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

8th March 1873, Page: 3, Column: 2

Fatal Iron-Stone Accident

On Tuesday afternoon, Mr. S. Spry, deputy-coroner, resumed his adjourned inquest, at the Ship Inn, Guisborough, on the body of William Filmer, aged 16 years, whose death occurred on the 15th February last. According to the Coroner's information, it seems that on the 15th February, deceased was engaged driving a horse attached to three waggons, at the shaft bottom of the Chaloner iron-stone pit, Guisborough, and that in going down a slight incline the waggons got too much way. Deceased ran with them to put a sprag in one of the wheels, but his foot caught in something and he fell across the line, the waggons passing over his legs and arms, He was removed to his home at Guisborough, and died after 5½ hours expired, having been attended by Dr. Merryweather. — Mr. James Willis, of Durham, Her Majesty's Inspector of Mines, attended on behalf of the Secretary of State for Home Affairs, and Mr. Addenbrooke, solicitor, of Middlesborough, with Mr. Sheppeard, secretary, attended on behalf of the Cleveland Iron-stone Miners' Association. A juryman named John Dickenson did not answer to his name, and has thereby rendered himself liable to a fine. — At the preliminary inquiry William Benson gave evidence of the identity of deceased's body.

The first witness called was

George Hillery, deputy at the Chaloner Pit. He said : On the 15th February, I saw deceased driving a horse and three waggons along the west drift, about at the bottom of the pit. He was running to get up to his horse. I cannot tell whether he was behind the waggons at first. He was running opposite the first waggon when I saw him, at a distance of 10 or 12 yards from me. He was running forward to get to his horse, which, with the waggons, were going very swift, and much faster than the ordinary rate. I saw deceased catch his foot, then he ran about two paces and fell. The front waggon went over his right arm and his left hand. He was much injured, and was brought home. When deceased was running, the horse was going a nice trot. They were going down an incline at the time, and this was the cause of them going so swiftly. I should think the incline was more than two inches to the yard. I saw the deceased trip his foot in the metals of a crossing at a board 11 or 12 feet wide. I think there will be 4 or 5 feet between the waggon and the side of the drift where deceased fell. He was on the contrary side to where he fell. He had a width of 5 or 6 feet to run in.

The Inspector here remarked that he had never before been at an inquest where the mine owners were not represented, and he trusted that he would never be at another.

Witness continued. — The place had been intended for a siding, but it was found that there was not room enough. There was 5 or 6 feet between the side of the metals and the upright timbers. Deceased had plenty of room in which to run. I have heard that deceased had been working in the mine for two shifts, but I don't know of my own knowledge. He was 16 years old. He had not any sprags in the wheels of the waggons. Some of the drivers sprag the waggons and some do not at that incline. I do not know whether there is any rule as to the spragging. I do think that the drivers ought to sprag their waggons at this incline, for the safety of the horse. I don't know whether it is dangerous or not. The incline is 15 or 18 yards long, and then it (the road) is level again. — By the Inspector: When I have seen the waggons go steadily down, there has been one sprag in. Deceased was in front of the waggon, and close to the horse when he fell down. There are a few baulks of timber lying beside the road at the place where deceased fell. When we picked him up, his head was within a foot of a piece of timber. That timber was about one foot from the metal. Supposing deceased had control over falling, he must have fallen on the rail, but he did not get to the timber. At the second place there was a timber bogie at the in-bye end of the timber. I think the bogie would have hindered deceased from falling on the clear side of the rail, but he had no control of himself, in consequence of the force with which he fell. He tried to avoid falling, but could not help it. I have not charge of the "road," which is in the hands of the platelayers. The road is wet, and is not ballasted on the side where deceased was running. The sleeper ends are exposed. I don't think he would touch the sleepers. The crossing has flanges above the rails. — By Mr. Addenbrooke : It was two or three yards from the pit bottom where deceased fell. This part of the road where deceased fell has been ballasted up since the accident, on the same morning. If the road had been ballasted up, he might have fell just the same. I can't say the want of ballast had not anything to do with the accident. The want of ballast was in part the cause of the deceased stumbling. The accident happened about three o'clock in the morning. The light was sufficient to enable me to see deceased fall. We were underground. — By the Inspector: There are not any man hole dug out of the sides of the rock for men to take refuge in. The drift containing the incline is not more than 8 feet wide. — The Inspector: These people ought to send some one here with plans to explain these roads. I declare to be a glaring shame ; that is all I have to say about it. — Witness: Deceased had passed the shaft bottom when he fell, exactly opposite the timber bogie. There are not cages to that shaft. — By the Inspector: Up the incline I have mentioned, the waggons sometimes touch one side and then another side in coming down or going up. I don't think there is above two feet clear at other points. There is a bad roof in the drift. I have worked there 10 weeks. — The Inspector here remarked that they should remember that this was a comparatively new mine, and that the Act of Parliament only came into force on the 1st January. If he found this was a breach of law, he might not, under the circumstances take proceedings, but this would not prevent others doing so. — Witness (by Inspector): I have nothing to do with the width of the drift. My duty is to see that the timbers are all right. I am not able to inspect the mine every morning, because we work night and day. The place where the baulks were laid used to be the place for keeping the timber. We have not now a special place for bogie or timber. We place it anywhere by the side of the road. I don't know who put the timber there. By the Coroner : I was standing at the end of the timber when I saw deceased coming. — The metals of the crossing stuck 6 or 8 inches above the level of the road at the time of the accident. It stands up three or four inches now. I don't think deceased had been trying to put a sprag in the waggons. — By Mr. Shepherd, I don't know whether any of the boys have been ordered not to put sprags in waggons. The mine has been working six or eight months. The stone is not taken up at that shaft. The main road goes past the shaft bottom.

James Kirk deposed : I saw the deceased fall down on the 15th February I was standing near the last witness at the time. I could see part of the incline from where I was standing. I could not see distinctly whether deceased was before or alongside the waggons when coming down the incline. Deceased tripped against the crossing attached to the main line. It was perhaps about ten yards from where I stood. He took one or two steps and fell under the waggons. When he fell, he had not exactly come to the part where the timber and bogie were placed. His head fell nearly touching the timber, so that the timber had nothing to do with his tripping, or falling, or running. I believe deceased was working his second shift in the mine. The road was very rough where he was running. There were small pieces of stone lying about : the sleepers were exposed as well. There was a space of about two feet between the metals and the uprights at the place where deceased fell. Where he tripped there was about three feet between the metals and the side of the drift, and it narrows in, so that at the place where he fell there is about two feet to run in. Deceased might have spragged the waggons if he had chosen. I have seen deceased come down previously, with the waggons spragged. There is not a doubt that if the road had been ballasted, the deceased would not have met with his accident; and at the rate he was going, it was impossible for him to get out of the way of them. Supposing he had strength and time, there was room for him to roll himself out of the way to the space of two or three feet between the metals and the timber. To go for 100 yards back along the drift, there are several spaces where the tubs catch the side of the drift. The inspector here remarked that from what he had heard, it would be his duty to go and see the mine, and then use his own judgment as to ulterior proceedings. He did not think it would interfere with the verdict of the jury. Witness (by Mr. Addenbrooke) : The road has been ballasted since, but it is in as bad a predicament as before, most of ballast being washed away. The horse had a shorter tail chain on than usual. I can't give the reason. I believe the company finds these chains. It is not my duty aa deputy to see to the length of them. There was four baulks of timber and a bogie beside the rails, and there would be 12 to 14 inches between them and the rails. The waggon ran off the rails, by crossing deceased's leg. I did not give any orders to a boy named Winter, to pull the waggons on the rails again. I did not hear any one tell him to do so. Deceased told me, after he was hurt, that some one had told him not to sprag the waggons. i

Joseph Winter said : I am one of the drivers in the Chaloner Mines. I did not see the accident. I have frequently brought waggons down the incline at the foot of which is the shaft bottom. When I come down I generally spragg one waggon wheel, I was never told not to spragg them, and I never heard of anyone else being told not to do so. There are sprags at the top of the incline to sprag them with. I was never told to sprag the waggons, but generally did so. — By Mr. Addenbrooke : I was told to pull the waggons on after the accident happened. The road is very narrow some times. In some parts of the incline you cannot stand up without the waggons touching you. The road was ballasted after the accident happened. I have worked for the same company at Eston. This road is better in some parts than the roads at Eston. The ballast is in some places level with the sleepers.

The Inspector here remarked that an inspector would not be satisfied with a road of the width described.

This was the evidence.

The Foreman : It is a very improper place for timber, to leave it laid on the main road.

The Inspector : I am afraid there is a breach of law involved in this case.

Mr. Addenbrooke read sub-section 1 of the general rules applicable to mines, from which it appears to be compulsory that manholes should he hewn in the walls of drift at intervals of not more than 50 yards apart and that such manholes shall be kept clean. He also wished to call the attention of the jury to the dangerous state of the road, as described by two of the witnesses.

The Deputy Coroner, in reviewing the evidence said that they must not think this was a coroner's inquiry as to the death of the deceased and a Government inspectors inquiry into the arrangements of the mine as well; the inspector would hold his inquiry quite, distinct from the present one. It seemed that the duty of deceased was to sprag the waggons before running them down the incline, and this narrowed their view of the case very considerably, for although the act of Parliament required certain things should be done, and did not do away with the responsibility of each individual to protect himself. It had been shown that sprags were placed at the top of the incline, and that another driver had spragged his waggons, so that this was more a matter of recommendation for the jury, and a subject which Mr. Willis would take into consideration and deal with.

Mr. Willis : It is a matter in which I can start a prosecution, if I consider it desirable; but we must remember that this is a new mine, having been only opened eight or ten months. Still I think it is very probable I shall prosecute.

The Corner : There is nothing which would lead the jury to think gross negligence existed on the part of the company, with its consequential verdict of manslaughter, therefore the duty of the jury is very simple.

A verdict of "Accidental Death" was then returned, and the proceedings terminated.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Addenbrooke, —      
Benson, William      
Dickenson, John      
Filmer, William      
Hillery, George      
Kirk, James      
Merryweather, —, Dr.      
Sheppeard, —      
Spry, S.      
Willis, James      
Winter, Joseph      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Chaloner (Ironstone)  Chaloner (Ironstone)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 18 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print