|
17th February 1873, Page: 3, Column: 5 A Colliery Agent Fined For Contravention Of The Mines Inspection ActAt the Castle Eden Petty Sessions, on Saturday last, before R. Burdon, Esq, (chairman), the Rev. W. Mayor, and Capt. Nott, R.N., Mr. Philip Cooper, head viewer of Thornley Colliery, appeared to answer the charge of neglecting to fence in the fly-wheel of the "Lady engine" at Thornley Colliery. — Mr. James Willis, Government Inspector, said that he was at the above colliery on the 2nd ult., and found the fly-wheel of the pumping engine uncovered. He wrote to Mr. Cooper on the subject on the following day. He again visited the colliery on the 10th ult., and found it uncovered. He afterwards visited it and found it covered, and he knew from his own knowledge that Mr. Cooper was the manager. — Cross-examined by Mr. Brignall: Witness had been a Government Inspector for two years. His predecessor (Mr. Atkinson) had been in the office 18 years, and would periodically visit the colliery. Witness had visited it several times, and could not recollect seeing the engine until the day mentioned. It was not his duty to make himself acquainted with the engines. The defendant could have been summoned under the old Act. On the 2nd ult. he was called to the colliery in consequence of an innkeeper having been killed in the fly-wheel. He would in all probability not have been at the colliery on the day mentioned had it not been for that circumstance. The bed of the engine would be about nine feet from the level of the ground. — Mr. Brignall, in defence, said that no person could doubt the abilities of the late Government Inspector (Mr. Atkinson), who had been in office upwards of twenty years, and had not noticed this alleged contravention of the law, which had been in the same condition for the lengthened period of thirty years ; and had it not been the cause of the death of an innkeeper, who was alleged to have been drunk, in all probability it would have continued unnoticed. Not less than five hundred men were passing and re-passing daily, and, by his own calculation, for the period of thirty years, there would be eighteen million people pass this place, and there had only been one accident. Notice had been given to his client prior to the accident of the new Act coming into operation, and men were actually engaged in covering the fly-wheel before the accident occurred ; but they were impeded by the accident, Mr. Cooper being desirous that the coroner and jury should visit the place, which was done ; and that was the cause why the work had not been done prior to the Act coming into operation. He (Mr. Brignall) could not see the slightest ground for Mr. Willis taking the present proceedings. It was not, in his opinion, a case for the magistrates to inflict a penalty. — Mr. Wm. Liddle, engineer, Trimdon Colliery, was called. He stated that he had known the engine for 28 years ; and it had, during that time, been in the condition described by Mr. Willis ; and he never knew an accident, except the one already mentioned. — Mr. Wm. Charlton, engineer of Thornley Colliery, said that on the 12th December of last year he was directed by Mr. Cooper to cover the fly-wheel, and on that day commenced work, but was stopped when the accident occurred. It was completed on the 14th inst. — Witness, in answer to Mr. Maynard, said that he had not been summoned by Mr. Cooper before the magistrates for disobeying the orders of Mr. Cooper. He could not see why he should when he was complying with the order. — The Chairman, after consulting with the magistrates, that there was not the slightest doubt but Mr. Cooper had contravened the Act ; but it was not, they considered, a grave offence, from the fact of it being unnoticed for such a lengthened time ; consequently, the penalty would be mitigated to £5 and costs. — The case was eagerly listened to by a large number of viewers from the Castle Eden and other districts, and by a large number of pitmen.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||