4th April 1872
Letters to the Editor
Mines Regulation Bill
Sir,
You have published two anonymous letters on this subject. Will you find space for a colliery manager to make some remarks upon it ? I am the more anxious that you should do so because if the views of "A Mining Engineer" go forth uncanvassed, he
might reasonably be supposed by the public to represent the opinion of those who are responsible for the practical working of collieries.
I have held that position for ten years at the deepest pits in the Midland coal field, and I am confident that, if his views on timbering working places, where the long wall system is in force, are carried out the accidents from falls of roof would be
seriously increased ; and if the use of gunpowder is abolished where safety-lamps are used, many collieries, and especially those working thin seams at a great depth, must be abandoned.
Allow me to explain that by the long wall system, which is the least wasteful of all systems working, no pillars of coal are left to support the roof, so that the working places are kept open by props or packs.
These props are placed usually one yard apart, so that in a working face of 4,500 yards there will be 450, and of these one-half will be moved and re-set every day. If, again, the roof breaks, and the weight comes suddenly on a working place — an
every day occurrence in the Midland collieries — it requires the instant attention of every man on the spot, that is, of 10 men in each 100 yards to keep it up.
No practical number of special timber men could save the place from coming in.
"A Mining Engineer" is also mistaken in supposing that the use of gunpowder can be avoided where the long wall system is in use.
The coal, no doubt, may be generally worked by other means — it is only a question of expense, and that we may assume the public is willing to bear — but in thin seams the roof must be got down for horse roads and ventilation, and there is no
known way of doing this where the stone is strong but by explosive substances.
All mining engineers holding responsible positions will approve stringent regulations as to its use, such as are in force in Belgium, for, to take the lowest view, the expense entailed by an explosion is, according to a "Mining Engineer," from
£2,000. to £20,000 ; but if it is to be absolutely prohibited, some of the largest collieries in the kingdom must inevitably be closed.
Experience has proved that the stone above and below the principal seam in this district becomes harder as the depth increases.
We may assume, therefore, that instead of working coal to a depth of 4,000ft., as is supposed possible by the Coal Commission, the limits have already been reached, where the seam is less than 5ft. thick, if gunpowder is abolished.
It is unnecessary to point out the loss to the nation which this represents.
So strongly do the workmen at the colliery feel on these two points that 400 of them have forwarded a petition praying that they may continue to set their own timber, and to use gunpowder under proper restrictions.
I will not trespass on your space in reviewing other parts of this Bill further than to say that if the clause limiting the hours of labour is passed no one under the age of 15 will, in an extensive colliery, be able under any circumstances to work more
than seven and a half hours in the 24 — that is, two hours and a half less per day than is fixed by the Factory Act.
Were any required number of youths to be found, this restriction would only weigh on them, but, unfortunately, such is not the case ; both the owners and the public will suffer from reduced production.
I am, Sir, yours faithfully,
C. Tylden Wright.
Shire Oaks Colliery, Worksop. April 3.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Wright, C. Tylden | | | |