14th March 1872
Death From Exposure
An inquest was held at the Infirmary, Howgill-street, on Monday afternoon last, on view of the body of John Lister, aged 42 years, an overman in an iron ore mine, belonging to Frizington, before Mr. Thomas Howson, deputy-coroner, and a jury. The
circumstances of the case will be best under-stood from the following evidence :— Ann Lister, the widow of the deceased, said that he was 42 years of age, and foreman at Mr. Joseph Fearon's iron ore mine, and resided in a cottage adjacent to the
mine, at Frizington. Between five and six o'clock on Monday, the 4th inst., he left home, and they saw him go down the road as far as the Frizington Hotel, near the railway station. She did not see him again until Tuesday, when he was at a
lodging-house in Nicholson-lane, Whitehaven. He was ill, and Dr. Dickson had been seeing him. On Thursday he told her that he had fallen into the harbour from the North Wall. Mr. John Shaw, deputy harbour master, said that a little before six o'clock
on the morning of Tuesday, the 5th inst., just at daybreak, he found the deceased, laid on his face, upon the steps outside the North Wall, very nearly at the bottom, his feet almost touching the water. The man's calling out attracted his attention, and
he went to him immediately. The deceased could not move leg nor arm. With the assistance of David Ellans the man was got to the top of the steps; but it took then twenty minutes to do so. Deceased appeared to be unconscious when he had to leave him
and go on duty.
David Ellans, coal shipper on the North Wall, corroborated Mr. Shaw, and said that the man's clothes were wet, as though he had been in the water some time before, and seemed benumbed by cold. It was a fine but cold morning. Deceased appeared to be
very much under the influence of drink, and quite stupefied. He had only one boot on; his hat was in the surf on the beach, and his other boot, unlaced, was nearly up to the high water-mark. David Harper Graham, a youth living in Ribton-lane, said that
about half-past nine o'clock on the Monday evening the deceased cane up the back way from the North Wall to the engine-shed at the railway station, where he sat down on a ledge. He was very drunk, and was asked what he wanted. He wished them to give
him a run up to Frizington, and was told that there were no trains or engines going. He stayed between five and ten minutes, and fell forward with his head on some bricks. On being assisted up, he said he would walk to Frizington, and on leaving the
place he went up the line towards Parton. Witness told him that it was the wrong way to Frizington. He replied that he would go his own way, and would not take a child's advice. In ten minutes or a quarter of an hour the man came back again, and fell
over the points with a great clash. When picked up he went in the direction of the North Wall, staggering against the iron ore waggons, on to the road leading to the beach, near which there was an auction van and a great crowd.
Sergeant Hetherington said he got information about this man at five o'clock on Tuesday morning, and went immediately to the North Wall. The man did not appear to have any use of his limbs, and was unconscious. He appeared to have had a great deal of
drink. He was taken to the Infirmary, but Dr. Shannon did not admit him, concluding that he was only suffering from drink, and that he required warmth. They took the man to McVitie's lodging-house, in Nicholson-lane. On being searched, there was found
on him a knife, a pipe, and 4½d in copper. When his clothes were taken off he called out, as if he had been hurt in the back. He appeared to be suffering a great deal from cold. He was put to bed, and given a glass of hot whiskey. Dr. Shannon,
the resident surgeon at the Infirmary, deposed that when the deceased was brought to that institution in the morning nothing was said about him having lain on the sands all night or hurt his back; that he was admitted on Tuesday afternoon, after Dr.
Dickson, his club doctor, had attended him; that he had received a blow on the back, from which paralysis supervened on Saturday; and that he died on Sunday, of congestion of the lungs, caused by exposure to the cold. It was on his recommendation that
the man was put into a warm bed and given a glass of hot whiskey. The Deputy Coroner remarked that the probabilities were that the man had got down upon the shore by the old road next to the ship-yard; that the advancing tide found him on the sands, and
that he just managed to get as far as the steps so as to save himself from being drowned. The jury could not attribute any blame whatever to Dr. Shannon, for if he were to take in cases of this kind he would have to admit all drunkenness cases. There
was no doubt that from exposure to the weather that night the man got congestion of the lungs, and of that congestion died. The jury returned a verdict of "Died from congestion of the lungs, brought on by exposure to the weather."
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Dickson, —, Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Ellans, Daniel | | Coal Shipper | |
| Graham, David Harper | | | |
| Hertherington, — | | Police Sergeant | |
| Howson, Thomas | | Deputy Coroner | |
| Lister, Ann | | | |
| Lister, John | 42 | Overman | |
| McVitie, — | | Lodging House Keeper | |
| Shannon, —, Dr. | | Resident Surgeon | |
| Shaw, John | | Deputy Harbour Master | |