|
29th February 1872 The Flooding Of A MineSmith V The Parkside Mining Company.This was an action brought by Samuel Wagstaffe Smith against the Parkside Mining Company to recover damages for flooding the plaintiffs mine. Allegations were made by the plaintiff of trespass on his mines, of holes having been made in the surface, and water let down into the mines of the plaintiff whereby the plaintiff was injured, and of holes having been permitted to be opened, whereby the same effects were produced. In answer to this it was first pleaded that the defendants were not guilty, 2nd, traverse of the lands of the plaintiff, and 3rd, leave and licence. Damages were laid at £3,000. Mr. Herschell, Q.C., and Mr. Crompton instructed by Messrs. Brockbank and Helder, Whitehaven were for the plaintiff; and Mr. Holker, Q.C., and Mr. Kay Q.C., (instructed by Mr. Musgrave, Whitehaven), were for the defendants. In opening the case, Mr. Herschell said the plaintiff's mine, the Crossgill Mine, was situated immediately to the westward of the defendant's mine. The mines were both in the same strata of ore, but the Parkside mines were all in the rise of the strata and the Crossgill mine was in the dip, which was so very considerable from the Parkside to the Crossgill mine, that at a point nearly to the east of the Parkside mine the ore very nearly came to the surface, while at the Crossgill mine the ore was about 62½ fathoms beneath the surface. Both the mines had been worked for a considerable number of years, Mr. Smith holding the Crossgill mine under a lease of 21 years from the 2nd of December, 1855, to the same date in 1876. About 1863, at all events a considerable number of years ago, the defendants were working very extensively underneath a part of their mines, and owing to that working the surface in various parts subsided and formed considerable holes, which extended to the present time. But in addition to that, as the ore came so near the surface, the defendants thought it would be easier and cheaper, instead of working by an underground working to quarry it from the surface. A cut was accordingly made from the surface, and the ore was worked through the opening. This cut had been in a great measure the cause of the mischief to the plaintiff, and it was called Paddy Murray's cut, because he had been employed to make it, and most likely being a gentleman of some celebrity in such matters, it had acquired his name. His conduct, however, had been objected to, and he was now in Carlisle goal. (A laugh.) Shortly after this opening was made, and it still remained open though it had long ceased to be worked, the defendants came to the conclusion that it would be expedient for them to alter the course of an ancient brook which flowed across their ground. This they had done, and the plaintiff would have made no compliant about their having diverted the watercourse, if they had done it in a proper and efficient manner, and made a channel such as would convey and carry off the water, and not do the mischief that had been done. This one deviation, however, did not answer their purposes, and they made another channel, but they had made the channel inefficient, and at a time of strong rain or floods, it overflowed its bounds, and caused plaintiff a damage which he would not have suffered, but for these acts. As long as 1865 Mr. Smith had had cause to complain of the flooding of these mines. The fact was that the boundary line between the two mines was only imaginary, there was no real boundary nor barrier between them. Thus they formed one continuous mine, and anything in the shape of water that found its way into the Parkside mines, passed through into the Crossgill mines, through the former being on the rise, and the latter on the dip, and settled and lodged there, flooding out the miners. They did not complain of the mere natural drainage, they had suffered that for many years and the burden of it was slight, but what they objected to was the extraordinary burden of water flowing through the Parkside mines into the Crossgill. Mischief had undoubtedly been done in 1865 and in 1868. The place called Paddy Murray's Cut formed a sort of basin in which water accumulated from various causes. In that place there was at least one, through there must be several places which communicated with the mine underneath and into which the water found its way. The water that accumulated in the hole had been watched to subside very rapidly, and it could only by the law of gravitation find its way onto the Parkside mine and from there to the Crossgill mine. On the occasion of which the chief complaint was made the brook over-flowed its banks in three places, and finding its way at once into the cut, formed a great pond there, after which it subsided into the Crossgill mines. The plaintiff had offered to forego his claim if the defendants would pay the expenses of the second flooding, bank the brook properly, and give him a mining way that he required for a nominal rent. On a subsequent occasion the water rose so fast that some of the men were up to the waist in it before they could get out. It ultimately rose to a height of 27 feet, and had to be pumped out, and for seventeen clear working days the men were shut out. It was noticed that as the water subsided in Paddy's Cut, the flooding became greater in the pit. The learned counsel then glanced briefly at the pleas of the defendants, and when he had concluded, the Court adjourned for luncheon. On reassembling, Mr. Holker advanced several questions of fact, which he said he would have to discuss, and he saw there must also be many questions of law. He suggested that they should try the question of liability by leaving the facts to be found by some gentlemen, that the legal points should be settled by the court, and that they should leave the amount of damages to arbitration. Mr. Herschell said the question of damages was entirely distinct from that of liability, and no doubt considerable time might be occupied by Mr. Holker's questions, but he suggested that the question of liability might be tried within reasonable compass. His client had a well-grounded apprehension of arbitration from previous experience. His Lordship: You must not be under the impression that the question of right will be settled here. Mr. Holker said a great part of the water had flowed in through other openings and over property which the defendants could not control. There was also a question whether the plaintiffs, through having removed a great block of ore, which stood as a barrier between the mines, were not themselves answerable for the flooding. The first witness was called. Mr. John Dixon, mining engineer and surveyor, and surveyor for plaintiff's mines, proved a few of the facts in Mr. Herschell's address, and in cross-examination said that if the watercourse had not been changed it would have traversed the worst part of some broken ground around the pits. It was the usual practice to quarry the ore from the surface where it came near enough. There had been a shrinking in the plaintiff's pit through their having robbed the pillars, and it shrank so much as to force them to take down some buildings on it, and it cracked up the No. 9 shaft belonging to the defendants so much that they had to fill it up. The hollow there frequently held water for a long time, as the surface was still intact. As a rule, however, the surface broke. Encroachments by one miner upon another are common enough, and generally settled by arbitration. No. 9 shaft had afterwards been re-sunk. Some further evidence was given as to mining operations, and witness said that it was the custom to sink a shaft in the dip portion of the mine. They had not exhausted the Crossgill royalty yet, as there was still some ore in the dip, to get at which they had sunk their shaft deeper. The flood in November last was very heavy, and he knew of one and heard of several other mines being flooded. Re-examined, he said he did not direct the workings, being only surveyor. He had only held this position for three years, and knew nothing of the mines previous to that of his own knowledge. The surface might sink without leaving any fissure for the water to flow through. He had surveyed in an arbitration case in 1870, and there was an encroachment on the Crossgill mine by the Parkside Company. They had got a great portion of the ore out of the northern portion. Alfred Hodgets, mining engineer, and director of Mr. Smith's mine for eighteen years, said they worked the Crossgill mines from one shaft, the lowest portion of which is 62½ fathoms deep, and they were making another drift. The inclination of the seam is very rapid from east to west. At Paddy Murray's cut the ore was near the surface. In the direction in which they were going they had proved the ore in very large quantities. He remembered the cut being made in 1864. Sooner or later the whole of the water in the defendant's mine would run into the Crossgill. In 1865 he saw the general manager of the Parkside, and asked him if he had used an iron bar to let some water down into the old workings below, and he said it was true, and that it was better to let it down gradually than to allow it to accumulate and then come down with a rush. The natural quantity of water in the Crossgill mine they could easily manage with their machinery. He recollected the mines being flooded in 1868. He investigated the cause of the flood, and attributed it to the overflow of the brook into Paddy Murray's cut. They suffered more than once that winter. In November last year the mines were again flooded. The bottom drift was drowned out on the 14th November when the rain began. Next morning the flood was five feet high in the main workings, which would represent a very great deal of water. They were drowned out on the occasion to the 4th December. From the 30th of December also to the 4th of January they were flooded out, and again from the 17th to the 23rd of January this year. On the 20th December he went with Mr. Davidson and Mr. Smith, jun., to Paddy Murray's cut in which there was a great deal of water, though it had considerably subsided. There had been at least fifteen feet of water in it above its natural level of five or six feet. He examined the brook at the same time, and there were distinct traces of its having overflowed its boundary. Since that time the defendants have banked up the brook in such a manner that it won't overflow again, and laid drainage troughs from Paddy's Cut. If these precautions had been taken before, the flooding would have been avoided. There were no cracks near the plaintiff's mine that would account for the flooding. In cross-examination by Mr. Holker, witness denied that at the bend of the brook it was wider and deeper, and could carry more water, than at any other part. Edwin Roe, pit manager for the plaintiff, deposed to the various floodings about which the other witnesses had spoken, and said that on one occasion he investigated the cause, and found the water flowing like a beck into Paddy's Hole. It was also subsiding very rapidly into the pit. A few days afterwards they were again flooded, and the water was flowing into Paddy's Cut over the edge of a new cut across the broken ground round the pits. At this point the Court adjourned at a quarter-past five until a quarter to ten in the morning. Saturday, February 24. The Court resumed this morning at a quarter to ten o'clock. This case was immediately gone on with, and the learned Judge tried to suggest some points on which both parties should agree, the first being that Paddy Murray's cut was a natural reservoir for water, and that it percolated through into the plaintiff's mine. Mr. Holker denied that there was any appreciable quantity of water got into the plaintiff's mine during the last two floods of which they complained, though it might in the first one. The case was very complicated, and he had admitted all he could. Mr. Hodgets was re-called, and in answer to Mr. Holker said the cracks in the surface caused by the sinking of one of their mines extended over 2,160 square yards, or about half an acre. He had said that if all the rainfall on the 14th of November had got in through these cracks they could have pumped it out again in half-an-hour, but he had spoken rather hastily. The rainfall on that day was three inches, and their pumps would discharge about 150 gallons a minute, being a nine-inch with a four-foot stroke. He explained that the whole of the rain percolating gradually through would not have interrupted them in their working for half-an-hour. The brook did not now drain the same ground as previously, and Paddy's cut was not the natural drainage. They did not attribute the last two floods to the brook, but that of November they did. _ Re-examined by Mr. Herschell: He said all the rain that fell on the drainage area would not get down the cracks into the mine. Thomas Binks Cooper, clerk in the employment of the plaintiff, said that on the 14th November, 1871, he had seen the brook overflow its banks a little way from the turn in three places, about four feet in each place. It was all flowing into Paddy Murray's cut, where there was a large quantity of water. The cut was a hundred yards long and twenty wide, and the water was the whole length, and about fifteen feet deep. Next morning he saw the water subsiding, and running quickly into a hole large enough to admit the body of a man. On the 30th of December also he saw water running into Paddy's cut. Another small channel that ought to have taken a portion of this water away was blocked up and useless, but the defendants are now driving a drift towards it for the purpose of making a larger channel. In cross-examination he denied that on the 14th of November when he went up the stream it had overflowed it banks there. Before the flood there was no channel across the broken ground communicating with a ten-inch pipe to take the water to the old brook course. George Smith, also in the plaintiff's employment, corroborated last witness as to the water flowing into Paddy Murray's cut. George Davidson, mining engineer, Whitehaven, went on the 20th November to see Paddy Murray's cut and the brook. He saw where the brook had overflowed and where it had been diverted from its course. When he saw it there were about six feet of water in it, and there might be fifteen at its highest. In January of this year he went again to see the brook, and the brook had been diverted a second time when it had been boarded, spiled, and an embankment thrown up. This made a great improvement in the brook, and if it had been done on the 14th of November, it would not have overflowed. On the 8th of January he also saw the drain across the broken ground running parallel with the brook, and from its appearance it was choked up. Since the improvements, the brook would not overflow. The cracks in the surface of No. 9 pit would not account for the flooding that had been spoken about. Cross-examined by Mr. Holker, he said the cracks on the Crossgill surface would extend over about an acre, and if all the rain on that extent went down into a mine it would be of no consequence. Henry Woodcock, mining engineer, and manager for Messrs. Hannay and Co., Ulverston, inspected these mines in January last. He saw traces of an overflow into Paddy's cut. He saw the drain across the broken ground and it was not then in an efficient state, though improvements were being made. He did not believe that the cracks in the broken ground of the plaintiff had anything to do with the flooding of the mines, and in case of a heavy rainfall there would not have been the least difficulty in dealing with the water that percolated through the cracks. But nothing like all the rain on the area of the cracks would have found its way down, as the cracks were on the side of a hill and towards the top. The three-inch rainfall on the 14th November would give on the surface of the cracks, which is 2,160 square yards, 311,000 gallons, and the plaintiff's pumps would discharge 259,200 gallons in 24 hours. This completed the case for the plaintiff. Mr. Holker then addressed the jury for the defence. He admitted that the first flood had been caused by the water flowing over from the brook and thence into Paddy's Cut, through which it percolated into the mines, but he denied that the other two floods had been occasioned by the same means, and said that had been admitted by all the witnesses for the plaintiff. The plaintiff had therefore set up two distinct cases, altogether different in their features, and the jury would have to ascertain whether the defendants were liable for either the first flood or the last two. When two mines were in the same strata the one to the dip was subject to take the water that came from the rise, that is, the ordinary flow. Water was a common enemy which both the mines had to contend against, but the one on the rise got rid of it by allowing it to go down and leaving his neighbour to deal with it as best he could. To get rid of the disadvantage, however, the miner in the dip had only to leave a barrier of ore between his mine and the mine above which would stop the water. But if he would rather go to the expense of pumping instead of leaving a barrier of ore, which might be very valuable, he had a perfect right to do so, but then he must take his chance of all the water coming from the mine above him, and unless it was sent down wilfully or under such circumstances as made it an exceptional flow the mines above would not be liable. In all mines and on all occasions there was a considerable flow of water, all of which must first be rained down before it could find its way there. On the 14th November the rainfall was three inches in twenty-four hours, the largest that had occurred for fifty or sixty years, and the jury might judge of it, when he stated that in this district the average fall was only 40 inches in a year. Numbers of mines were flooded, every river overflowed its banks, every culvert was choked with the press of water in it, and all miners suffered seriously from the water getting into their mines. But Mr. Smith said he must be put on a different footing from his neighbours, he must escape damage, for he was in such a position that he could claim from the Parkside Company. He dealt first with the second allegations and the defendants were liable for the damage done in the mine by the water that flowed through Paddy Murray's hole into which it had drained from the drainage area around. This he denied, and said that if they were found to be liable when the plaintiff had taken no precautions, it seemed to him that it would be a most alarming thing for miners in this and every other district. Was it to be said that the owner of a mine who had done nothing more that he had a right to do, who had simply let down the surface of the land, was to be liable if the water from a drainage area found its way through the cracks into another mine? In speaking of the diversion of the course of the brook, he said that all the water that had got into the mine would have got in had the brook not been diverted; while on the other hand, the defendants had placed an embankment on the lower side, brought down a drain to Paddy's cut, and inserted in the bank a 10½ inch pipe to take the water from the drainage area into the brook. Small runners had also been placed to convey the water to the pipe, and these had been sufficient ever since they were put there. The water was a great trouble to the defendants as well as to the plaintiff, and they would be consulting their own interests in taking the best means they could to get rid of it. Therefore, if the culvert took the flow of water from the natural drainage area, he submitted that the defendants were not liable. The learned Judge: Is your proposition that they are only bound to provide for such floods as may be expected annually? Mr. Holker: Yes, my Lord His Lordship said he would hold that if persons made by artificial means a reservoir on their lands and thereby accumulated water that passed into their neighbours mines, they would be liable for it. Mr. Holker: It does not accumulate. His Lordship: Yes, it does. If that hole had not been there the water would not have accumulated, and if any person did accumulate water by artificial means, he was bound to provide that it did not injure his neighbours. Mr. Holker said he was trying to show that the defendants had made such provision. His Lordship: They tried to do so, but they did not. The flood was not unprecedented, and it might occur again; they are bound to prevent damage if they erect an artificial reservoir. In the conversation that ensued His Lordship added that if a miner undermined the earth and let in the surface he would be liable for any damage that was caused. Mr. Holker said he was in a position to prove that the culvert and the sluices were sufficient to take away the water from the drainage area and prevent it getting into Paddy's hole in an ordinary season, and that the water flowing from drainage area outside the culvert would not to any appreciable extent flood the mines of the plaintiff. His Lordship said he would still hold that if any water got into Paddy's hole, the defendants were responsible. Mr. Holker had better except now, or move for a new trial if His Lordship were wrong, though he felt no doubt about it at present. Mr. Holker submitted that the hole was not made by artificial means. His Lordship: You create the reservoir which held the water, and it is your part to prevent the water getting into your neighbour's mine. Mr. Holker said that position would apply to the brook. It seemed to be useless going any further if His Lordship took that view, as he could not displace it by evidence. His Lordship referred Mr. Holker to the case of Fletcher v. Rylands, decided in the House of Lords, and said the learned counsel might keep a tiger on his premises, but he must take care that it harmed nobody. Mr. Holker: But if I said, "My dear tiger, go on to my Lord's premises," I think I should not be liable. (Laughter.) His Lordship said he must provide against all things. Mr. Holker: Then I cannot keep up my case any longer. I must tender a bill of exception to your Lordship's ruling, unless you will reserve a point. Mr. Herschell expressed his readiness to agree to that. Mr. Holker stated the agreement, which was that if the Court should be satisfied that he was right in his contention, and that there was no evidence of neglect of duty on the part of the defendants, then the Court would enter a verdict for defendants; but if there should be evidence that the defendants view was wrong then it would be sent down. Mr. Herschell said he only wished to obtain in the simplest way the view of the Court upon the question. The Court might determine the abstract question of obligation to keep the water from getting in any way into the mine, the liability with respect to the surface drainage, and with respect to the brook. His Lordship: If there is evidence that I am wrong in objecting to Mr. Holker's position, then there will be a new trial. The learned Judge expressing his intention of taking down what it was proposed to do, Mr. Holker said he proposed to prove that when the brook was diverted it was made sufficient to carry off the water in all but seasons of extraordinary flood, and it was made more capacious than the old one. Mr. Herschell said it was at all events less convenient in consequence of the bend. A verdict was then entered by agreement for the plaintiff, damages to be assessed by an arbitrator upon a principle to be laid down by the Court; leave to be given to the defendants to enter a nonsuit if there should be no evidence of liability, and to move for a new trial on the ground of misdirection. His Lordship said he would certify costs. This concluded the business of the assizes, and the court rose shortly after noon.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||