|
1st February 1872 Important Local Mining CaseCourt Of Common Pleas. Westminster, Wednesday, January 24. (Before Justices Willes, Byles, Brett, And Grove.) Mackenzie V. Ainsworth This was an action of trover for the conversion of a quantity of iron ore, tried before Mr. Baron Martin, at Carlisle, when the quantity of the ore alleged to have been taken was found, the only remaining question, therefore, being upon what principle the damages should be assessed. Mr. Field, Q.C., and Mr. Herschell were counsel for the plaintiff's; Mr. Holker, Q.C., and Mr. Crompton representing the defendants. It seemed that the plaintiffs were the Crossfield Iron Mining Company, and the defendants the Cleator Iron Mining Company. The plaintiffs were the lessees of an iron ore and hematite mine under the estate from which the company derived their name. A former lessee was Mr. Anthony Hill, with whose consent the defendants in 1853 made a drift, and in doing so removed a quantity of iron ore belonging at the time to Hill. The defendants' mine adjoined that of the plaintiffs, and in 1867 they applied to the plaintiffs to be allowed to take out some ore from under Crossfield. That application was refused, and matters went on till May, 1869, when the plaintiffs were informed that the defendants had been working within their boundary ever since the early part of 1867, but one short interval. The defendants on being taxed admitted that they had taken out the ore along the drift which the late Captain Walker, with the consent of the lessee who preceded the plaintiffs, permitted them to make; and the reason assigned for doing so was that their old lease expired in the previous September, and not knowing whether it would be renewed, they set to work taking out all discovered ore they could see without injury to the pit, and some of the ore could not have been taken had not some of the defendants' been taken also. They thought they were doing the plaintiffs no damage. Further, they had kept an account of what had been taken from the Crossfield royalty, and what was found to be due should be paid. That account commenced on the 22nd May, 1867, and continued down to the 5th May, 1869, and it showed that the total quantity of ore taken amounted to 5,011 tons 18 cwt. A correspondence ensued upon the production of this account, and ultimately an agreement was arrived at that a joint survey should be made for the purpose of ascertaining whether any further trespass had been committed, and that the matters in dispute should be referred to the arbitration of Messrs. George Dixon and William Turner, with an umpire whom they must appoint. In the award made by those gentlemen on the 27th January, 1871, it was stated that 5,416 tons of iron ore or hematite had been taken out of the drift by the defendants, in addition to a quantity taken out during the currency of Hill's lease, and 152 tons taken out in making the drift. It was also found that the defendants had taken 4,758 tons from other workings, and that the plaintiffs had taken 13 tons out of the defendants' royalty, leaving the indebtedness of the latter at 10,161 tons. The remaining question, therefore, which was to be decided by the court, was upon what principle the damages were to be calculated. Mr. Field, Q.C., contended for the plaintiffs that the action being one of trover, the ore must be regarded as a chattel, and that the cost of hewing, severing, working, and carrying to the pit's mouth must be borne by the defendants, who, in addition should be charged for the ore at the highest market price between the period of getting and the trial, they being wrong doers. The Lord Chancellor had held in the recent case of Jegon v. Vivian, that where mineral was taken by mistake it was to be paid for on a different principal to a case where it was taken wilfully. The defendants on their own admission had worked the plaintiffs' royalty with a knowledge of the impropriety, therefore the only deduction in their favour must be the cost of carriage. Mr. Holker contended that the award of the arbitrators was not conclusive, they having merely been called upon under the reference to find the quantity of ore on the Crossfield estate, and not the quantities which had been taken from the company by the defendants. Mr. Justice Willes said that the case must go back to the arbitrators to determine the amount of ore which had been improperly got, leaving it for the Court when the facts were found upon the material points to say whether the damages should be assessed according to the amount of ore which had been taken simply, or including the cost of hewing and working. The duty of the arbitrators would be to ascertain as well the various market prices of the ore since the commencement of the trespass. Mr. Justice Byles remarked that the award had been made by competent authorities, and was good upon the face of it. In a matter within the knowledge of the arbitrators, the Court should be slow indeed to go against their findings. Mr. Justice Grove concurred, and the case was therefore referred back to the arbitrators. Mr. Holker asked whether under their Lordships' judgment there would be a right of appeal at once. Mr. Justice Willes replied in the affirmative, but added that the Exchequer Chamber would probably take the same view of the case as the Court had done, and send it back to the arbitrator.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||