|
14th September 1871 Another Case Of Wanton Cruelty In the CollieryFrank Graham, a boy of 14, was charged with wounding a horse, the property of the Earl of Lonsdale, in the William Pit, on the previous Thursday. — Mr. Howson, who appeared to conduct the prosecution, told the bench that he was sorry to say this was another of those cases of cruelty to a horse in the Whitehaven Colliery. The boy, who had been working in the pit for the last two years, was charged by Mr. Matthew Harper, the resident viewer of the Whitehaven Colliery, with cruelty to a horse in the pit bottom, by striking a pick into one of its feet, and placing a large nail in the tender part of the hoof. As usual in these cases, the evidence very much rested upon the defendant's own admission when charged with the offence; but that would be most clearly proved, and he submitted that was sufficient to convict him of the offence. — John McGuiness, a stableman in William Pit, said that the horse that was injured was wounded in the foot between the leg and the hoof. The horse was well and perfect on the Wednesday night; on the Thursday morning he saw that it was wounded. — William Mansford, another stableman in the pit, said that on the Thursday morning, he observed about a pint of blood in the siding of the row where the defendant usually stands his horse. — Mr. William Harker said his attention was called to the horse on Thursday morning, August 31st, and in consequence he made inquiries. The boy had possession of the horse between Wednesday night and Thursday morning. He asked the boy who had put the pick into the horse. The boy did not speak for a bit, and then he said he had done it. He did not make the boy any promise, or use any threat to induce him to say this. James Moore was present. On being asked why he did it, the boy said he was taking a rod out of a basket, to beat his horse with, and the pick fell out of his hands. He would have no business to use a pick at all; he was a driver. He saw the boy again about it on September 2nd, at the Colliery Office, while Mr. Harper and Mr. Kendall were present. The boy was charged with having injured the horse, and he said that he put the pick into the horse because it was tetchy. There had been a previous complaint against the defendant. — Mr. Kendall, veterinary surgeon, said he examined the horse on the Thursday morning, August 31st. There was a wound on the near fore foot, a little above the hoof; such a wound as might have been done by a pick, or some other sharp-pointed instrument. It was an angular wound, three-quarters of an inch deep, close to the joint. It lamed the horse, and would cause it considerable pain. He did not see the nail in the horse's hoof; there was a wound in the soft part of the hoof of the near hind foot, such as would be occasioned by a nail being driven in; it was between the frog and the sole, and was calculated to cause the horse pain. — James Moore, a horse-keeper in William Pit, said the defendant brought the horse back on Thursday morning, and he examined it. There was a wound in one of the fore feet, and a nail in one of the hind feet, going half an inch into the soft part of the hoof. — In reply to the Rev. J. Rimmer, the witness said the nail might have got in by accident. It was rusty horseshoe nail, and had been driven. He heard Graham taxed with it, and he said that he put the pick into it; he did not admit having put the nail in. — Mr. Harper said he was the resident viewer of the colliery. On September 2nd the boy was called into his office, and he asked him why he had put the pick into the horse. The boy said it was because it was tetched. He had had no complaint of the horse being tetched before. On the 29th December last the defendant, together with William Miller, was convicted here of a previous offence, and sent to Carlisle Gaol for fourteen days. — Defendant denied having put the nail into the horse's foot. He struck it with the pick because it was tetchy and would not start the rolly, and if he were long incoming up he would be "welted" by the stagewhipper. — Mr. Harper expressed his disbelief of the latter statement. Mr. Watson suggested that there ought to be some inquiry into the allegation. — The magistrates convicted the defendant, and sentenced him to three months imprisonment with hard labour in Carlisle Gaol.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||