




























































|
| Newspaper Articles |
|
Newspaper Articles |
 |
|
 |
1st August 1871
Crook V. Lord Leconfield
Henry Crook, miner, sued Lord Leconfield for £50, for work done, and damages alleged to have been sustained in consequence of breach of contract. Mr. McKelvie appeared for the complainant, and Mr. Webster for the
defendant's agent, Mr. Davidson. It appeared from the statement of Mr. McKelvie that Mr. Davidson was about to sink a pit shaft in the neighbourhood of Cleator Moor, and solicited tenders for doing the same. The plaintiff amongst others tendered,
and his offer was accepted. There was a scale by which the work was to be carried out. For hale, or "sill" as it is locally termed, the plaintiff was to have at the rate of £12 per fathom; "whirlstone" £18; limestone,
£25; and iron ore, £25. They got through the surface and sill measures all right, and were paid according to contract, but when they got to whirlstone Mr. Davidson refused to pay the plaintiff for "whirlstone," but offered to pay
them at sill price, and the plaintiff refused to take it, and took his men off, or, as it was contended by Mr. Webster, "jacked the job up," and hence the present action. — Plaintiff, on being called, said he had been a miner for many
years, and had sunk shafts in America, the Isle of Man, and Low Furness. Mr. Davidson's was the first he had in this district. In the month of May last he sent in a tender for this shaft, and it was accepted. Before he did so, however, he asked Mr.
Davidson what this "whirlstone" was, as he had never seen any of it before, and he told him that it was easy to work. He put in his tender to do it for £18 a fathom, and he put sill in at £12. The piece of stone produced was a
specimen of what they called "whirlstone," and he had taken it out of the shaft that he had taken from Mr. Davidson. The shaft was to be 10ft 6in by 5ft 5in. They were paid the money every fortnight, but after they got into the
"whirlstone" the defendant refused to pay them that price, but offered to pay them the same as sill. He (the plaintiff) refused to take it, and on the following Monday he took his men off. The losing of the job had been a £100 out of his
way. — In reply to Mr. Webster, plaintiff said that Mr. Davidson offered him £17 odd, but he refused to take it. He denied that the piece of stone he produced was sandstone; it was whirlstone," the same as some produced by Mr. Davidson.
Mr. Francis Manson, manager to the Maryport Hematite Iron Company, said he had superintended the sinking of more than a dozen iron ore pit shafts. He had been 13 years in the employ of the Eskett Iron Ore Company, 5 years with the Eskett Parks,
and 3½ years with Mr. Ainsworth. The stone produced by the plaintiff he believed to be "whirlstone," and he had paid for it himself as such. He had paid Thomas Gibson, Thos Jones, and Thomas Murray for exactly
the same stuff, at "whirlstone" price. £18 was too little for it, and if it was in a wet shaft, £30 a fathom was little enough. If it was a dry place, it would be worth £5 a fathom less, say £25. He would have no
hesitation in paying for it as "whirlstone" again. — In reply to Mr. Webster, witness said in consequence of a dispute with some of his miners some time ago, he submitted several samples of "whirlstone" to Mr. Davidson, the
father of the present agent to Lord Leconfield, and he decided that they were all of that description. They were similar to the sample produced by the plaintiff. — Mr. Webster: Do you recollect stating in the police court, in answer to a question
by me, that you would swear a bushel? — His Honour: What has that to do with the present case if he did? — Mr. Webster: We shall see. (Addressing witness.) How many situations have you been discharged from? — His Honour: That is a very
improper question if the man has not been discharged. — Mr. Webster: Do you (witness) recollect having a case in the police court some time ago, and were you not dismissed from your situation shortly after? Witness: I was never discharged from a
situation in my life. — His Honour: That is a very improper mode of examination. (This remark was immediately followed by applause in court, which was at once suppressed.) — Mr. McKelvie: Did you leave your previous situation to improve your
position? — Witness: Yes, I did. I have £130 a year more than what I had. — Mr. Thomas Gibson said he was a contractor, and had been engaged in sinking shafts for 13 years. He had contracted for five or six. The sample produced
by the plaintiff is known in the district as "whirlstone," and he had been paid as high as £35 a fathom for it. — Thomas Jones, a miner for the last 36 years, was of opinion that it was "whirlstone," and he had been
paid for sinking through the same sort of material as such. He had been employed both in coal pits and iron ore mines. — James Sharpless, a miner of 28 years' experience, had been employed sinking pits, and had, perhaps, sunk 18 or 19 in that time.
He had sunk scores of fathoms through "whirlstone," and the sample of stone produced was of that kind. — Mr. Webster, having stated his case, called Mr. Davidson, who stated that he was agent for Lord Leconfield, and had been so for six
or seven years. He was previously manager for Mr. Hill, and had been connected with the management of iron ore mines for 30 years. He had a pit shaft to let some time ago, and the plaintiff Crook tendered, as well as a great many others. The plaintiff's
tender was accepted, and he went on with the work till they came upon the stone of which they had samples. About the middle of the first week he saw the plaintiff about it, and told him that he was not to go on with the work till he contracted for it; as
sandstone, the stone that he contended it was, was not in the contract. The plaintiff did not do so, and on Saturday night he (plaintiff) went to his house, and there was some conversation about it. He (witness) told him that he would pay him at the rate
of £12 a fathom — the same price that he was to be paid for the sill. He said he would take £12 for what he had done, but he would have to be paid at the rate of £18 per fathom for what he had to get, or he would "jack the
job up." — In reply to his Honour, witness said there were several kinds of "whirlstone," but he could only enumerate one. He told the plaintiff to put freestone in the tender, but he did not do so. — His Honour, producing the
agreement, asked the witness if it was drawn up by him. He replied in the affirmative, and admitted that freestone had been omitted. — Mr. McKelvie produced the note given to the plaintiff stating what he was to tender for, and in that the
plaintiff admitted that there was no freestone, but he also stated that the document was written by his clerk without his authority. — Mr. George Grey, manager for Mr. Stirling, said he had been a miner for 40 years, and had been in
the employ of Mr. Stirling for 15 years. Previous to that, he had been employed in mining in the neighbourhood of Newcastle and in Scotland. He was well acquainted with the Cleator Moor district, and had superintended the sinking of many iron ore pits in
the neighbourhood. The specimen of stone produced by the plaintiff was not "whirlstone," he called it grey, bedded sandstone. He was at the present time sinking a shaft through the same material 14 feet 7 inches, which was a third larger than
the plaintiff's shaft, and he was only paying £13 a fathom for it. The piece produced by the plaintiff-contained sill. In reply to his Honour, witness said he only knew two kinds of "whirlstone" — a close-grained and an open one.
Mr. McKelvie: Should they have the same for this stone as for sill? Witness: They should have £3 or £4 more than for sill. — John Wilson, foreman for Mr. Davidson, said he superintended the pit in dispute. He considered the sample of
stone produced was sandstone, and not "whirlstone." He heard a conversation between Mr. Davidson and the plaintiff respecting the affair, and plaintiff said that he would take £12 a fathom for what he had done if he would pay him
£18 for the remainder. Mr. Davidson declined to do so. — Joseph Walker, clerk to Mr. Davidson, having corroborated the foreman's statement as to the conversation, John Irving, foreman for Messrs. Fletcher, Miller,
and Company, who had been a miner for 26 years, said the stone produced was sandstone, and not "whirlstone." — His Honour suggested that Mr. Davidson should give the plaintiff something and settle the matter. He thought that he was
entitled to something for the work, but he did not think that he had suffered any loss by having been deprived of the work. Mr. Webster observed that £18 3s 7d had been paid into court, and it was agreed that a verdict should be entered for
£5 more, with costs.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Ainsworth, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Crook, Henry | | Miner | |
| Davidson, — | | Agent | |
| Fletcher, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Gibson, Thomas | | Miner | |
| Grey, George | | Manager | |
| Irving, John | | Foreman | |
| Jones, Thomas | | Miner | |
| Leconfield, Lord | | Mine Owner | |
| Manson, Francis | | Manager | |
| McKelvie, — | | Solicitor | |
| Miller, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Murray, Thomas | | Miner | |
| Stirling, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Walker, Joseph | | Clerk | |
| Webster, — | | Solicitor | |
|
|