27th June 1871
Mackenzie V Ainsworth
This was an action to recover damages for trespass on an iron-ore royalty at Crossfield, near Whitehaven. The plaintiffs were John Munro Mackenzie, Daniel Bird Robinson, and Hugh Munro Mackenzie, and the defendant was Mr. Thomas
Ainsworth, of the Flosh, near Whitehaven. — Mr. Quain, Q.C, Mr. Kemplay, and Mr. Herschell were for the plaintiffs; and Mr. Holker, Q.C, with whom was Mr. Crompton, for the defendant. The defendant paid
£3,150 into court but the plaintiffs sought to recover about £6,000 for the ore taken from the royalty at Crossfield. It appeared from the opening statement by Mr. Quain that Mr. Ainsworth's iron-ore royalty adjoined that of the plaintiffs
and the defendant had trespassed upon the royalty of the plaintiffs, according to their showing to the extent of 13,560 tons. The defendant denied the quantity of iron-ore and the amount claimed, and had paid £3,150 into court.
Mr. George Dixon, mining engineer, Whitehaven was the first witness examined, and he said the trespass was referred to himself and Mr. Turner a mining engineer of some note in the country. He (Mr. Dixon) was arbitrator on behalf of the
plaintiffs, and an umpire was agreed upon. The gross amount that he found had been taken out of the plaintiffs royalty was 13,560 tons altogether. Having ascertained that the next thing they had to do was to ascertain how much of that had been paid for.
He found that 3,234 tons had been paid for by Mr. Hill, a former lessee of the defendant's royalty. These figures were furnished by the defendant himself, and they agreed with the late Mr. Hill's books. Then there was 352 tons which had not been
paid for Mr. Hill, and these added together and deducted from the 13,560 tons, left 10,174 still unpaid for, and that was the quantity awarded. It was also found by the arbitrators that the Crossfield Company had taken 13 tons of ore belonging to the
plaintiffs, and they had allowed for that. On the reference there was no suggestion that more ore had been taken in Hill's time. The figures he had given were only figures before them.
In cross-examination by Mr. Holker, witness admitted that it was referred to Mr. Brockbank to fix the boundaries of the Cleator and Crossfield royalties to guide the arbitrators in ascertaining the quantities. He never ascertained when the
plaintiff's lease began.
Mr. Holker submitted that the ore was taken out of the royalty by the defendant, under the impression that he had a right to it.
Mr. John Monroe Mackenzie, one of the plaintiffs, deposed that in the year 1867 he had some correspondence with the defendant with reference to the working in this drift way. He did not assent to the defendant working the ore. Subsequently he had a long
interview with Mr. Ainsworth and discussed the question of quantity. Mr. Ainsworth said something about what had been taken out in Mr. Hill's time, and they agreed to allow for it. He also said that there were 152 tons that had not been paid for to Mr.
Hill, which he wished to be included in the deduction.
Cross-examined by Mr. Holker: Their lease commenced at Midsummer, 1860, and extended for 21 years. The price of iron ore had gone up from 14s to nearly 20s per ton since the 1st of January.
His Lordship here suggested to Mr. Holker that if he had any evidence which would enable the Court of Common Pleas to come to a decision whether the award made was final or not, he would take it. Then if the award is final, there would be an end of the
matter; all the rest would be clear. If the award was not final, then it was a matter to be settled by the arbitrator.
Mr. Holker; But various trespasses may have to be dealt with on a different footing.
After a short consultation with his client's solicitors, Mr. Holker said the difficulty was that he was in a position to prove that the trespass on the part marked "J" on the plan was an entirely unwitting trespass. He was also in a position to
prove that all the other trespasses except the big one marked "A" were committed in Mr. Hills time. Finally the quantities had been largely increased in consequence of the definition of boundary. If the other side were willing, it might be
ascertained what Mr. Ainsworth received from this ore, which belonged to the Crossfield Company. This reasonably ascertained, Mr. Ainsworth would be willing to pay, and £500 in addition.
His Lordship: It seems to me you must submit to the Court of Common Pleas whether you are bound by this award. If you are not, then I agree with you the whole question is open.
Mr. Quain: First, whether the award is final: and secondly, on what principle damages are to be assessed.
Mr. Holker said unfortunately Mr. Ainsworth had been taken ill, and he should not like to take any course without consulting him. If his Lordship would adjourn the case until the morning he might consult his client.
The case was therefore allowed to stand over until the following morning.
The Trespass On An Iron Ore Royality
Mackenzie V Ainsworth
This cause was resumed.
Mr. Holker said there was considerable difficulty in the case. His impression was that he could not appeal unless the award was final. Supposing that were so, how could the damages be dealt with?
His Lordship: By the arbitrator. I apprehended that the most sensible way of dealing with the cause in that event would be to find for plaintiff, with leave for you to move on the ground that the award is not correct.
Mr. Holker: If the Court of Common Pleas would do that.
His Lordship: I don't think the court would have objection.
Mr. Quain: It is done every day.
After some discussion the matter was settled for the present as under: — Verdict for the plaintiff, with leave to move. In the event of the court being of opinion that the quantity of ore is conclusive as settled by the award, the amount of damages
to be referred to an arbitrator to be assessed upon the principle directed by the court. If the court be of opinion that the award is not conclusive, then the whole matter in dispute between the parties to be referred. Should the parties not agree upon
an arbitrator, the court to settle the matter, plaintiff to be allowed to examine a witness who is leaving the country before some gentlemen to be agreed upon.
Cases Settled Out Of Court
The cases of Skelton V London and North Western Railway, and Robinson V the Cockermouth, Keswick, out of Court, damages being given in each case of £500 for personal injuries.
This concluded the business, and his Lordship proceeded to hear the following.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Ainsworth, Thomas | | | |
| Brockbank, — | | | |
| Crompton, — | | | |
| Dixon, George | | | |
| Herschell, — | | | |
| Hill, — | | | |
| Holker, — | | | |
| Kemplay, — | | | |
| Mackenzie, Hugh Munro | | | |
| Mackenzie, John Munro | | | |
| Quain, — | | | |
| Robinson, Daniel Bird | | | |
| Turner, — | | | |