|
17th June 1871 The Late Explosion In Frizington CollieryThe adjourned inquest upon the body of John Latchford, a coalminer, 35 years of age, who was killed by the explosion of fire-damp, in the Frizington Colliery, was resumed on Tuesday afternoon, at the Golden Ball, Irish street, Whitehaven, before Thomas Howson, Esq., deputy-coroner for West Cumberland. The adjournment had been necessary to allow of communication with the Government Inspector of Mines, but he was not present. Mr. Gredon, manager of Frizington Colliery, was in attendance, and produced a plan of the colliery, as well as the rules of working. Samuel Robertson, a deputy-overman in Frizington Colliery, said the deceased was also a deputy-overman in the same pit. About half-past six on the morning of the 3rd of June he saw deceased coming up from the dibbing near the shaft. This was after the men had gone down to work. It was the duty of the overman to go down and examine the pit, and that he had done. The pit was in one seam, and they were all dip workings. About three minutes before deceased came up there was a great "waft" of wind from the dibbing which put witness's light out. The deceased also had no light. Witness thought there must have been an explosion, and he asked the deceased if there had been, and he said, "Yes, it was me," and explained that the explosion took place in an old working which had been standing some time. The deceased was not the man who had examined that part of the pit that morning — it was Thomas Williamson. Neither witness nor deceased had any examination to make that morning of that part of the pit where the explosion took place. When the deceased came up he was in his shirt and trousers, and without his cap; he was burnt about his arms, legs, and head. The working in which the explosion took place had not been worked since May 25th; it was between 30 and 40 yards of the main air course. The Coroner: Is there any bratticing near it? Witness: No, and there never was any in it; when it was in working it was ventilated by this air course; it was 12 feet wide, and 3 feet 9 inches in depth; it rose for 25 yards towards the forehead — about 1 in 4 or 5. It stopped at a "trouble." Witness used sometimes to examine the working since it had been stopped, but not regularly. He had tried it for gas, but never found any in it. The deceased had a naked lamp when he went into the working. The Coroner: Then Davey lamps are not used in this pit? No, except in a place where there is likely to be danger; this working had not been worked by Davey lamps; if gas had been found in it, the place, of course, would have been stopped; they had two shafts at the pit — one the air shaft; there were furnaces for ventilating purposes; the deceased went into the working for a necessary purpose; witness had examined the working on Tuesday or Wednesday before the accident; there was no fence or rail placed before the working; there was a working close to it, but not into this one. The Coroner: Don't you think such places should be bratticed? Witness said it would not be necessary to brattice unless there was some cause for it. He had seen places in the pit where there was gas, but it was very little. The depth of the pit was 50 fathoms; this working would be about 100 yards from the bottom of the shaft. The deceased was first taken to the Colliery Offices, and oiled cloths were applied to him; he was afterwards taken to the Whitehaven Infirmary. In answer to a juryman, the witness said it was no neglect of Williamson's duty not to examine this working. To the Coroner: If it had been in working, it would have been his duty to examine it. The Coroner examined the rules closely in order to see if there was any compulsion to fence off, or mark old workings, but no such rule could be found. The witness was further examined at considerable length, and said he had never seen any gas in this particular working. It was a nice clear morning when the explosion occurred. The deceased said he had got five or six yards into the working when the explosion took place. Witness the same day found his cap three or four yards further on, and he imagined it had been blown there. Thomas Williamson, the other deputy-overman, was also examined at great length, but his evidence was mostly corroborative of the other witness. He was the one, he said, who examined this part of the pit that morning; it was customary to examine only the places in actual working. He was asked whether it would not be well to place some mark at the entrance to prevent men going into the old workings, and he said that it would be done if there was any danger. The Coroner: But supposing you do not examine it for danger, how can you tell whether there is none? The witness replied that when there was gas they put up a mark at the end of the supports, to prevent men going in, and no other reply could be got from him, except that in this working they had never seen any gas, although he had examined it a few days before the explosion. It was suggested to him that a mark should be placed at the entrances of such workings as had not been examined, to show that they had not been, but he gave much the same replies as to the previous question. The working was stopped because it was up to a "trouble." The deceased's lamp was found about three yards in the working. He should, he said, have himself gone into the working, if he had had occasion, with a naked light. Had been a deputy two years. The Coroner: And have you never found out that gas is a very uncertain thing, and that a slight change in the weather might make the gas come out? Witness: I cannot say; it might make some little difference in the air, but in this place there was never anything seen; in this case the gas must have come out of the "trouble." In answer to a juryman, the witness said he had seen gas in the pit — but not in this district; the furnaces were kept going night and day; he could no tell whether the furnace man was at his place the previous night, but on the Saturday morning there was good air in the course. A Juryman asked the Coroner if there was not a law enforcing the use of safety lamps? The Coroner said it was a matter left to the option of the Government inspector; if he had thought it necessary in this instance, he would have imposed the use of Davey lamps on this colliery. Mr. John Shannon, house surgeon to the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary, proved that the deceased died in that institution after lingering a week from the injuries he had received, the burns producing inflammatory fever. The Coroner, in summing up, said the question for the jury to decide was whether the deceased met with his death through the culpable fault or negligence of ant person. Williamson's explanation was that he had not examined the working because he had no reason to suspect there was gas in it, and there certainly seemed no rule to enforce anything beyond that. He (the coroner) could not but think it a great pity either that there should not be an examination of the old workings every morning, or that they should be fenced off, so as to certify that there was no proof of their being safe. If the jury thought that the deceased himself did not exercise due and ordinary caution, then there would be an end of the case as against any one else, and their verdict would be one of "accidental death;" but if the considered Williamson guilty of gross negligence, then there must be a verdict of manslaughter. He thought, however, there was no evidence to justify that, they're being no explicit rule to guide him in the matter. The jury (of whom Mr. Harrison was foreman) returned a verdict of "Accidental death;" but all seemed to be of the opinion with the Coroner, that a more stringent rule was required with reference to the old workings.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||