15th June 1871
A Miners' Wages Case
Mr. Joseph Henry Robinson and others, trading as the Eskett Iron Ore Company, were summoned by Joseph Farthing, Sylvester Davis, Peter Nolan, and Thomas Dymond for payment of the sum of £9 6s 8d, wages alleged to be due, and which the defendants
refused to pay. Mr. Webster appeared for the complainants, and Mr. Atter was for the defendants. Mr. Webster, in his opening statement, said that sometime in April last, or shortly previous to that time, his clients entered into an engagement with the
Eskett Company whereby they were to work in one of the pits at Eskett, and were to be paid 60s for each fathom, and a further sum of 7s per ton of ore got while excavating the drift. After working a week or two a new bargain was made; the men agreeing
to take 40s per fathom, and 10s per ton of ore. On the 27th of May they had done three fathoms and four feet, and had got a quantity of ore. When they went to the Company's office to get paid, instead of being paid for the fathoms as well as for the
ore, they were only paid for the ore they had taken out of the excavation. The allegation of the company was, he understood, that notice was given to the complainants that they were to be paid only for the quantity of ore per ton, and no fathom price.
He would show that on the 13th of May the complainants were paid at the rate of 40s per fathom, in addition to 10s per tone for the ore. They commenced work on Monday (May 15), worked all that day, and all Tuesday, and on the Wednesday something was
said by one of the overmen about working at a different rate. Mr. Webster, in answer to a question from the bench, said the complainants were drifting, and sometimes went through stones and sometimes through iron ore. He supposed the only question
would be as to whether or not on the Wednesday following the 13th of May a fresh bargain was made with his clients. He should show that it was not until the second or third day of another fortnight that any intimation was made to them that their pay was
too large, and that the price per fathom would be taken off. If the Eskett Company thought so, they should have said to the complainants, "We close this bargain, and we cannot allow you to work any longer." Instead of that, they allowed the
complainants to work to the end of the fortnight, and so this money was due. (It should be explained that of the £9 6s 8d alleged to be due to the complainants, £2 was for four tons of iron ore, and the defendants did not dispute their
liability to pay that sum; and, in ordinary course, complainants would have received it at next pay.) Witnesses were then called by Mr. Webster. As is usual in such cases, the evidence was of the most conflicting and confused character. Sylvester
Davis, Joseph Farthing, Peter Nolan and Thomas Dymond were examined as witnesses by Mr. Webster. The general effect of their evidence was this: — That no fresh bargain was made after Saturday, the 13th of May, although it was admitted that
Harrison Lowden, the assistant overman, made some remark to the complainants on the Tuesday or Wednesday following the 13th as to taking off the fathom price. According to Nolan, Lowden said to the complainants, "it could be worked without fathom
price," upon which Sylvester Davis said, "When you take off the fathom price tell me, and I will be off." No more was said then, but Lowden afterwards promised he would allow them for two fathoms. Eventually, however, in the presence of
the head-man, he denied that he had promised them pay for two fathoms. Mr. Atter, for the defence, gave particulars of the various bargains between the parties, until Wednesday, the 17th of May, at which date, he said, notice was given the complainants
that the fathom price would be taken off altogether. All the alterations in the contracts were made on a Wednesday; and the men came and left on a Wednesday. He should also prove that even suppose they were entitled to the fathom price, 1 fathom 2 feet
and 6 inches was all they were entitled to charge for. John Burns, manager for the company, corroborated Mr. Atter's statement as to the 1 fathom 2 feet and 6 inches being the correct measurement. Harrison Lowden said he gave the complainants the same
notice of the reduction that he gave to any other men in the Company's employ. It was not true that he offered to pay them for two fathoms. He corroborated previous witness as to 1 fathom 2 feet 6 inches being the correct measurement. William Tremble
also corroborated the measurement as spoken to by the two previous witnesses. Mr. Joseph Henry Robinson, jun., gave some evidence as to the way in which the pay-sheets of the company are made up. He stated that he went over to the pits every Tuesday
fortnight to make up the books. The men were paid on the Saturday for the work done up to the Tuesday; the following days in the week being paid for in the next fortnight's settlement. After a short consultation the bench ordered defendants to pay
£5, which included the £2 admitted to be due for tonnage, and costs.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Atter, — | | Solicitor | |
| Burns, John | | Manager | |
| Davis, Sylvester | | Miner | |
| Dymond, Thomas | | Miner | |
| Farthing, Joseph | | Miner | |
| Nolan, Peter | | Miner | |
| Robinson, Joseph Henry | | Mine Owner | |
| Tremble, William | | | |
| Webster, — | | Solicitor | |