Annual Register for 1870
Article from the Annual Register for 1870, 6th December 1870, Page: 136, Column: 1
Fatal Railway Accidents
The close of the year 1870 was
rendered memorable in England by a succession of alarming and
fatal railway accidents. On the 26th of November seven persons
lost their lives by a collision at Harrow Station, and for December
we have to recount three more very serious accidents.
The first of these occurred on the 6th, at Brockley Whins, where
the passenger traffic from Newcastle to Sunderland and Shields
separates, and whence also a large coal traffic is turned off from the
main line to Sunderland and to the Tyne Dock. The express train
which came into collision with a coal train at this place, left Sunderland
at half-past ten o'clock ; and this morning, in addition to
the ordinary passengers, there were several butchers proceeding by
it to Newcastle cattle-market, and millers and corn merchants who
were going to the corn-market. At the particular place where the
collision occurred the coal traffic is turned to the left for the Tyne
Dock, and the passenger traffic from Newcastle is brought across
from the left to the right, to enable the train from Sunderland to
discharge or take up passengers at the Brockley Whins, where one
platform is used for up and down traffic. The cause of the collision,
from which such fearful results followed, is very easily explained.
The switches were in charge of a pointsman named Hedley. As
the express train was coming from the east and was being "slowed"
to pass the Brockley Whins station, at which it had not to call,
however, a coal train for the Tyne Dock was coming from the west,
and when it reached the points to be turned down to the Tyne Dock,
Hedley had got into a fluster, lost his head, and had opened
the wrong points, which turned the coal train into the crossing
leading to the station platform. But the disastrous mistake did
not end here, for the same action opened the points at the other end,
and brought the express train, which consisted of a guard's van and
five carriages — a first class, a composite, and three seconds —
off the
up line on to the crossing, and dashed the two engines on to each
other, end on. The speed of the express at the time of striking was
estimated at about the rate of ten miles an hour, while that of the
coal train was about eight ; and the force of the collision was sufficient
to smash in the fronts of both engines, and to strew the whole
of the surrounding spot with shattered plates, loosened wheels, and
innumerable pieces of rubbish from the terribly shattered carriages
themselves. The van, indeed, was broken to fragments, one of the sides
flying out in a perfect piece ; while the adjoining first-class was
forced in at the bottom in such a way as to hurl the occupants high
into the air, and to cause several of them to fall upon the burning
boilers of the locomotives adjoining. The sides and roof of the
composite compartments disappeared in the same manner, and two
of the three carriages for second class passengers, being forced aloft
by the shock, were literally smashed to atoms by falling on to the
embankment and the travelling-way. The station-master and
porters at Brockley Whins at once hastened to render what assistance
they could to the unfortunate people who were entangled among the
ruins. When a sufficient clearance had been made to enable the
searchers to reach the people embedded in the rubbish, they came
upon the dead body of Mr. Frederick Younge, a gentleman well
known for his acting in Caste, Play, School, and several other plays
of Mr. T. W. Robertson. The blood was streaming from his head,
which appeared to be terribly fractured at the back ; but beyond
this there was no other sign of injury to the body or limbs. A lady,
also severely cut and bruised about the head, was lifted from a compartment
near Mr. Younge, and was carried away insensible. It
subsequently transpired that this was Miss Julia Martell, a member
of the Caste company. She eventually recovered very considerably,
though still deprived of the power of speech. The dead body of
Mr. H. Y. Richardson, a paper manufacturer at Bishopwearmouth,
was lifted from about the same spot, and was almost instantly joined
by that of Mr. C. Turnbull, a clerk and commission agent. Both
were sadly cut and mutilated. While people were making ready to
remove the dead, others had been successful in releasing
Mr. W. B. Ogden and Herbert Taplin from the wreck, but both were
so
frightfully smashed that even then but little hopes were entertained of
their recovery. Mr. Ogden's face and head were much battered,
and his left eye appeared to have been knocked completely from the
socket ; while Taplin, a porter at the central station, who had
been merely put on temporarily to act as guard to the express, had
the bones of both legs crushed almost to powder. They were at
once removed to the waiting-room, and promptly attended to ; but
Mr. Ogden succumbed to his injuries about one o'clock, and
Taplin,
who had been compelled to have one leg amputated, also died in
the course of the afternoon. A majority of the injured were taken
to the Queen's and the Palatine Hotels, in Sunderland. On the
arrival of the officials, among whom were Mr. Alderman Hartley,
Mr. Fletcher, Mr. Mitford, Mr. A. Harrison,
Mr. Smith,
Mr. Simkins, and Mr. Forsyth — a good staff of workmen were
set to
clear the line, and so rapidly did the work progress that the shattered
engines, tenders, and carriages were all removed from the line
before three o'clock, and the traffic was then resumed. On inquiries
being made for the pointsman, Hedley, he could not be found, and
accordingly rumours were at once circulated that he had either
absconded or committed suicide : but later in the evening he was apprehended
in his own house, and conveyed to the lock-up at Jarrow.
The man was originally a platelayer, and had only been at his
new duty for about three months.
The following is a list of the killed :—
Frederick Younge, manager of the Caste Dramatic Company ;
W. B. Ogden, chemical manufacturer, Deptford, unmarried ;
Henry Y. Richardson, Wearmouth, paper manufacturer, Deptford, aged
between 40 and 50 ;
R. C. Turnbull, commission agent, Sunderland, and agent to
Mrs. R. H. Tweddell and
Co., aged 24 or 25 ;
Herbert Taplin, guard of passenger train.
At the inquest the jury were of opinion that the accident was
caused by "Robert Hedley having omitted to place the points right,
and that it was an error in judgment on the part of the said Robert
Hedley." Robert Hedley was tried at the Durham Winter Assizes
for manslaughter, and acquitted
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Fletcher, — | | | |
| Forsyth, — | | | |
| Harrison, A. | | | |
| Hartley, —, Alderman | | | |
| Hedley, Robert | | | |
| Martell, Julia, Miss | | | |
| Mitford, — | | | |
| Ogden, W. B. | | Chemical Manufacturer | Deceased |
| Richardson, Henry Y. | | Paper Manufacturer | Deceased |
| Robertson, T. W. | | Author | |
| Simkins, — | | | |
| Smith, — | | | |
| Taplin, Herbert | | Guard | Deceased |
| Turnbull, R. C. | | Commission Agent | Deceased |
| Tweddell, R. H., Mrs. | | | |
| Younge, Frederick | | Manager | Deceased |