Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

28th October 1870, Page: 2, Column: 7

The Colliery Explosion At Abercwmboy, Aberdare

Close Of The Inquiry

The report of the evidence taken at the inquest on the five bodies killed at the explosion at the Abercwmboy Pit on the 8th instant, up to six o'clock was given in the Western Mail of Thursday. The following evidence was taken afterwards :—

Thomas Thomas, labourer, said: I was employed as timber man at the Abercwmboy Pit on the night of the explosion, and was with six others sitting down taking a spell when it happened. I heard a slight report, but it did not affect the part we were in. James Davies, the overman (one of the killed), came to me about twelve o'clock and asked if I would go with him to the south side of the pit. I asked what was there ? He replied that he had found some gas in the north return. We went into the old flue heading, but found no gas there. John Lloyd and the boy were there filling water. Davies told Lloyd to come back to the main level and remain there until he gave further orders. We went to No. 2 heading and found a good deal of gas coming out from the north return. He asked me to watch the gas there whilst he went up to the flue. We put a brick between each of the three doors which separated the in-take from the return air-course for the purpose of admitting a strong current of fresh air. I remained there until Davies returned. When he came back I asked how he found the heading leading to the flue. He said that the heading was nearly clear of gas, but that the flue was nearly out, and the fluemen fast asleep. I asked him what course he would take, and whether he would put out the fire altogether. He said that he would wait until Adams, the overman, and John Howells, the fireman, (one of the killed) came, that he had sent for them. In a short time afterwards Howells came and asked Davies what was the matter. Davies said that the fire was nearly out in the flue, and the flueman sleeping. Howells went up to the flue, and we remained watching the gas. In a short time he came back and said that the place was free from gas, but that the flue was very low. I asked Howells if he would take out the fire, and he said, "No ; as soon as the fire burns up it will be all right again." I then left them, and went back to my own place. In the course of a quarter of an hour they came to me again, and said that everything would be all right in half an hour. They remained with me from five to ten minutes, and talked of going down to the "six-foot," and I saw no more of them. In about a quarter of an hour afterwards I heard the explosion. When I examined the north return with Davies I noticed that the air was passing very slowly, and noticed the same thing in the part of the work where I was in. When Davies and Howells left me I believe they must have gone back to the No. 2 heading, and closed the doors we had partially opened, with the view of returning the air into its original course. The effect would be that the air in the old return would become more stagnant, and the gas accumulated in the workings. When the doors became closed the current would become stronger, and drive the gas through the return air course to the flue, and ignite it, thereby causing the explosion.

The Coroner complimented this witness on the clear and straightforward way he gave his evidence.

John Evans, sinker, was the next witness. He gave his evidence in such a nonchalant manner as to cause considerable amusement to the court. He said I and William Evans were engaged in the pit on the night of the explosion clearing out the rubbish from the out-cast shaft, the sides having fallen in. We had been at the work for a fortnight. I heard a slight noise in the shaft above our heads, and saw the red-hot coals falling down the pit. There was about three feet of water in the pit, and I ducked under the water and saved myself. My partner was burnt about the neck, and has not been out of the house since.

The manager (Mr. David Evans), in reply to the coroner and inspector, said that he did not know the condition of the old workings, as he had been only a month engaged. The thickness of the four-foot vein was about 5ft. 6in. Meredith, the viewer, had only been employed a year. The four-foot does not leave enough small to fill up. There are three workings at the pit, the 2ft. 9in., the 4ft., and 6ft. The furnace is now removed from the 4ft. to the 6ft.

Mr. Wales, the Government inspector, then gave the following evidence :— I have made an examination of the district in which the explosion occurred, from which, as well as from the evidence, I am clearly of opinion that the gas was ignited by the furnace. The ventilation of the colliery has always been effected by the furnace. Indeed, I might say that the furnace mode of ventilation is the one generally adopted, not only in this district, but throughout the kingdom. The total quantity of air passing into the colliery was about 90,000 feet per minute, and from 16,000 to 17,000 feet went into the district under consideration, where there were only some twelve men at work. Such a quantity of air was doubtless sufficient so far as the number of men were concerned. But the number of men employed is not what should alone determine the quantity of air required, but that should also be regulated by the quantity of gas given off from the coal or from the old works. In this case, although the air was sufficient for the number of men employed, it was not sufficient to dilute the gas before reaching the furnace, and hence the explosion. But as the circumstances, so far as the furnace was concerned, had been the same for some time past, one of two things must have occurred to bring about the explosion. Either the quantity of air passing must have been greatly reduced, the discharge of gas remaining the same, or the quantity of gas must have been greatly increased without any increase of air, or the air may have even been reduced. Indeed, from the evidence of Thomas Thomas the quantity of air had been greatly reduced, owing to the flue having been neglected. It is true the furnace had been removed from the 4ft. coal to the 2ft. 9in. coal some eight or nine months ago, but as that increased the distance between the old workings and the furnace, it is obvious that that would not affect the question prejudicially, but rather the reverse. When I made my examination there was not more than from 6,000 to 7,000 feet of air passing into the district, instead of 16,000 or 17,000. But even with that small quantity of air there were no signs of gas, either in the workings or in the return airways. From that fact it is, I think, clear that there must have been a large quantity of gas suddenly given off and the reduced quantity of air spoken to by Thomas Thomas would make the matter worse, which rendered the return air inflammable, and on reaching the furnace it was ignited. From what I saw during my examination, there appears to have been a custom of building rubbish walls in certain places to prevent the gas escaping from the old works. Now, in my opinion such a system is bad, and fraught with great danger, as it can only keep the gas back till it reaches a certain pressure, when it issues forth with great force, and not unfrequently when and where least expected. No attempt should be made to keep back or confine gas, but proper provision should be made for it to escape gradually and safely. I think it quite possible that the sudden discharge of gas which I believe to have taken place was mainly due to that cause. From the plan it will be seen that there are goafs or old works, all more or less liable to give off gas on almost all sides of the furnace, and within comparatively short distances of it, which makes it the more dangerous. Under such circumstances, with a view to prevent a similar occurrence, I beg to suggest that in the future working of the colliery the mode of ventilation by furnace should be abandoned, and a fan of proper size and power substituted. In reply to the Coroner, Mr. Wales said that 17,500 feet of air per minute was sufficient to ventilate that portion of the pit, unless there was a discharge of gas. The system of building up the mouths of the old workings is a bad one, but it is adopted throughout the district. There is always a risk of gas forcing itself out. The best way is to allow the gas to get out into the return airways. The letting out of the fire in the flue was not sufficient in itself to produce the explosion. It was a mistake to have closed the doors before going into the return airway and ascertaining if there were a body of gas in it. It was quite possible that although the flue was let out and doors closed there would be sufficient gas to ignite. There must have been a large body of gas, for the explosion was attended with great force. For 40 or 50 yards the damage done was considerable, and he had great trouble to get through. He had to creep along in some places. The gas must have travelled 600 yards before it reached the furnace.

The Coroner then summed up the evidence, which he said was quite sufficient to enable the jury to come to a conclusion as to the cause of the explosion. The four-foot vein in the pit was nearly worked out. There were only twelve men employed in that part of it, and they were working back the pillars so as ultimately to abandon it altogether. It appeared from the evidence of Thomas Thomas (who gave his evidence in a straightforward manner) that James Davies, the overman, came to him and said there was gas in No. 2 north return heading, and that they went and found gas there. They put bricks between the doors and the frames to hold them open so as to have a volume of fresh air direct on the gas. They did this with a good motive, for it was a means of carrying the gas away. It seemed, however, that it had not the desired effect. The two fluemen were asleep, and the fire gone down. This was negligence so gross as to constitute a criminal offence, but the poor fellows had paid the penalty of their neglect with their lives. Davies did the best he could, and was killed. The theory of Thomas was clearly the correct one — that the gas was carried over the return airway, and when it reached the flue it exploded. The next question for the consideration of the jury was where the gas came from. The old workings in the four-foot vein are not filled up, and gas therefore accumulates in them, and sometimes escapes, as it very probably did on the morning of the 8th. Shutting in the gas is dangerous. It ought to be allowed to escape. A sudden fall in the temperature might force the gas out. Whether it arose from this cause or the lessening of the ventilation by the neglect of the flue, or both it was for the jury to determine. There was no reason to assign blame to any of the officers of the pit. They seemed to have done the best under the circumstances.

The jury then consulted together, and in a quarter of an hour returned a verdict to the effect that the explosion was occasioned by the gas coming in contact with the flue, that the fluemen were very culpable in allowing the fire to go so low, and that it was a mistake to close the doors — which in effect amounted to "Accidental death."

It was nine o'clock when the proceedings were concluded.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Adams, —    Overman  
Davies, James   31 Overman  Deceased, Individual Page
Evans, David    Colliery Manager  
Evans, John    Sinker  
Evans, William    Sinker  
Howells, John   33   Deceased, Individual Page
Lloyd, John      
Meredith, —    Colliery Viewer  
Thomas, Thomas    Labourer  
Wales, Thomas Errington    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
15 Oct 1870  Aberdare Colliery Explosion (The Monmouthshire Merlin)
27 Oct 1870  The Colliery Explosion At Abercwmboy, Aberdare, Adjourned Inquest (Western Mail)
28 Oct 1870  The Explosion At Aberdare (The Monmouthshire Merlin)
28 Oct 1870  The Colliery Explosion At Abercwmboy, Aberdare, Close Of The Inquiry (Western Mail)

Links to related pages

 

Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page
Memorial Page  Memorial images gallery

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print