|
27th September 1870 The Social Science CongressNewcastle-Upon-Tyne, Sept. 26. On Saturday the members of the Association assembled in the morning to hear an address by Dr. Lyon Playfair, C.B., M.P., President of the Education Department, who said that for 30 years past efforts have been made to bring the state into relation with the education of the people, but these efforts have been rendered unsuccessful by the conflicting interests and the jealousies of religious bodies. Hence, while other nations in Europe have spread primary and secondary education throughout their lands, England has not even laid the foundation of a national system until the present year, and had the worst educated people of any country that professes a high civilization. At last, however, Parliament has passed a measure of national education for England and Wales ; and, whatever are its shortcomings, it has the great merit that the State has at last been brought into national relations with education. Government has been intrusted with powers both of initiation and control, and localities have been made responsible for the education of their inhabitants. Three leading principles in the Act give it a national character, — first, that it is the duty of localities to bring education within the reach of every child in England ; secondly, that it is the duty of parents to make their children attend the schools thus provided ; and thirdly, that it is the duty of the Government to see that the objects of the Legislature are fulfilled. With all its defects, the Act is an enormous stride in advance of the old system of mere contributory help ; under which schools, indeed, multiplied, but education slipped backward. The Revised Code rather accelerated the decadence, since it led to mechanical teaching in the lower standards only, and to results that were not worth paying for. The Act which passed last Session deals with the quantity of education only, but not with its quality. Perhaps the first was a sufficiently great question to deal with on one occasion. Still the number of schools is of small consequence as compared with the education given in them. The elementary schools which we have are the growth of modern times, and have been raised by churches, which thought that the chief preparation of man ought to be for the future, and that the school was intended for his eternal and not for his temporal condition. Some duties, with regard to the latter, it was important to inculcate, — humility, obedience ; give unto Ceasar the things that are Ceasar's ; pay your taxes and, above all things, your tithes ; touch your hat to the parson, the squire, and his lady ; these, in a temporal sense, form the chief end of man. An so village schools became things of small temporal use, but well fitted, as the old phrase went, to keep men satisfied with the sphere in which they were born, Gradually the Church was emancipating herself from these narrow views, and was developing the village schools into greater usefulness, but the State had thrown them back again, and had made them mechanical manufactories, turning out no end of yards of the three R's, in standards one, two, and three, but very few in standards four, five, and six, because the latter do not pay. The original idea of the Church, if it could have given a fair amount of consideration to the temporal condition of man as compared with his eternal state, was to educate him in correlation to his work and condition in life. The same idea was manifested wherever the State in ancient times interested itself in education, and in the observance of such a relation you will find the secret of the prosperity of Prussia, a State which only got its civilization long after the Christian communities of Europe had organized themselves. She has lately shown what education can achieve in the union and advancement of people. Even in the least productive of arts — that of war, see how she is served by the universal education of her soldiers. The educational principle of continental nations is to link on primary schools to secondary improvement schools. The links are always composed of higher subjects ; the three R's being in all cases the mere basis. Elementary science, and even some of its applications are encouraged or enforced. Our primary schools do not teach higher instruction that a child eight years of age may learn. No armour-plate of knowledge is given to our future artisan, but a mere thin veneer of the three R's, so thin as to rub off completely in three or four years of the wear and tear of life. So, under our present system, no knowledge bearing on the work in life of the people reaches them as a result of State education. And yet we are surprised at the consequences of their ignorance. A thousand men perish yearly in our coal mines, but no schoolmaster tells the poor miner the nature of the gas which scorches him, or of the after-damp which chokes him. Boilers of steam engines blow up so constantly that a Committee of the House of Commons has been engaged in trying to diminish the frequency of such explosions, but the stokers who are scalded to death or blown to pieces were never instructed in the nature and properties of steam. In Great Britain alone more than 100,000 people perish annually, and at least five times as many sicken grievously, out of pure ignorance of the laws of health, which are never imparted to them at school, and which, as they pass into no secondary schools, they have no chance of learning afterwards. Our pauperism, our crime, and the misery they produce, increase terribly ; and our panacea for their cure is teaching the three R's up to standard 3. Our large faith in our little doings will not remove mountains. Our low quality of education is impoverishing the land. It is disgracefully behind the age in which we live and the civilization of which we boast. In the schools prior to the Revised Code words instead of ideas were worshipped. The teaching of science is the reverse of all this, and will go far to remedy its defects. The whole yearnings of a child are for the natural phenomena around until they are smothered by the ignorance of the parent. Do not suppose that I wish the primary school to be a lecture theatre for all or any of the "ologies." While I advocate the introduction of higher subjects into our schools I wish them to be of immediate interest and applicability to the working classes. Six months spent in teaching future labourers the wanderings of the children of Israel is sheer waste of time, as regards either their temporal or their eternal interests. If you bring up a ploughman in utter ignorance of everything relating to the food of plants, of every mechanical principle, of farm implements, of the weather to which he is exposed, of the sun that shines upon him and makes the plants to grow, of the rain which, while it drenches him, refreshes the crops around, is that ignorance conducive to his functions as an intelligent being made after the image of Him who has done all things wisely ? In all the operations of the field, from the breaking up and manuring of the soil to the harvesting of the grain, which of the two men would feel that he had the most noble education — the ignorant clodhopper knowing nothing that he is doing, the mere tool or slave of his master, or the worker, intelligent, and knowing his occupation, aiding nature to fulfil her wise laws, and by doing so feeling like St. Paul, and with his humility also, to be "a fellow-worker with God ?" I have selected for illustration the occupation in which the working man is now the least cultured and intelligent, but there is not a single craft which could not be dignified in a similar way. Let me, then, refer you to an example, scarcely known, as it is separated from us by stormy seas, but singularly instructive and significant. You will find it fully described in Mr. Tuffnell‘s "Report on the Employment of Men and Women in Agriculture." Those of us who have passed middle life recollect the chronic state of misery and poverty in the Scilly Islands, off the coast of Cornwall. In such a wretched condition were they that the inhabitants were only preserved from starvation during the winter months by constant contributions from the mainland. Now we never hear cries of distress from these islands, and for what reason ? In 1834, Mr. Smith, who became their proprietor, undertook their improvement. He abolished the cottar system, consolidated holdings, founded good schools under a compulsory system of his own, and kept them up to the mark by constant inspection. He did not content himself with the three R's, but directed the instruction towards the occupations of an insular people. History, geography, the rudiments of mathematics, and navigation were taught to the children. And with what result ? So much esteemed are the youths of the Scilly Islands as sailors that vessels sometimes stop there to procure them, and very frequently they rise to be mates and masters. Pauperism has vanished from the islands, so that it is difficult to find any of its population poor enough to accept the alms offered in the Communion Service. The well-educated population show a disposition to pass to the mainland, for they are much appreciated there, and receive high wages. But all this is as it should be, and Mr. Smith deserves our thanks for having preserved to us an example of what the Government intended to do, but failed to accomplish — viz., to direct the subject-matter of education to the occupations of the people. The great advantage of directing education towards the pursuits and occupations of the people, instead of wasting it on dismal verbalism, is that while it elevates the individual it at the same time gives security for the future prosperity of the nation. In the industrial battles of peoples we are content to leave our working classes armed with the old Brown Bess of warfare, while men of other countries are arming themselves with modern weapons of precision. The speaker then proceeded to draw an elaborate contrast between Spain and Holland, and afterwards to enlarge upon the benefits of physical training and bodily exercises. Alluding to the subject of compulsory education, he said that the logic of circumstances drove Parliament into the recognition of compulsion, and the same logic will oblige the Legislature to make it sufficient. You cannot give political power to a people and allow them to remain ignorant. But it would be an unredeemed hardship to compel children to remain at schools unless these were made suitable to their wants in life. The address then referred at some length to the methods of compulsion, whether direct, as by the operation of law on the parent, or indirect, by the prohibition of industrial occupation to an untaught child, and leaned rather towards the latter method. The subject of Scotch universities and their connexion with the grades of education below them was next taken up, and the necessity for some means of gradual ascent from the English primary schools was pointed out. The speaker then referred to the existing provision for the supply of teachers, and described it as being over costly and excessive for the present kind of instruction, and altogether inadequate for the higher teaching that would in future be required. He said that no more important object lies before the Education Department in the future than the efficient organization of the scholastic profession as a whole, so that it may become an object of ambition to the best youth of the country, and may afford to them adequate remuneration in their years of working vigour, with the power of providing for their old age. This would be a true economy to the nation, for a country which has sufficiently large resources in schools and teachers possesses the elements of continued prosperity, and has little to fear in the advancing competition of the world. I have now done. This year is memorable because, for the first period in our history, the State has been brought into national relation with education, and has accepted large responsibilities. If you believe that this Act has settled the scheme of national education, even for a few years, I trust that you are much mistaken. It has just touched the outskirts of the subject. The great object before us is to establish an efficient organization of public intellect. Now, the national relations to it are in a state of chaotic confusion. There is the Committee of Council with two departments running side by side on parallel rails, yet never touching each other lest disagreeable collisions might result. The elementary school department will have no aid from the science and art department ; and yet both are under the same masters — the President and Vice-President of the Council. Again, you have a third body, the Endowed School Commissioners, tacked on to the same committee by a loose sort of thread, but not bound to co-operate with either department. Then you have all sorts of Government schools outside the education department altogether. Union and workhouse schools under the Poor Law Board ; military and regimental schools under the War Office ; naval and ship schools under the Admiralty ; factory and industrial schools under the Home office. Some of the Universities receive large sums from Parliament, but are responsible to no public department for their proper use. In fact, we have educational material in abundance, but no architect to make a national edifice out of them. We have not even decided which of them should be selected for the building of the future. Brick, stone, wood, iron, are all useful in building ; any one will do, yet all united would answer the purpose better. But we quarrel among ourselves as to which should be used, so a substantial building is not even begun, and our castle is in the air. Humanists, realists, religionists, and secularists contend for their separate views, and refuse to co-ordinate them for the public good. In this confusion the public call for a Minister of Education, in the hope that he may be a nucleus round which the various education materials may crystallize in a definite form. In the competition of nations, both in war and in peace, their position for the future will depend upon the education of the peoples. Local advantages or practical aptitudes may give them pre-eminence to-day, but, unless supported by knowledge, these will vanish to-morrow. The competition of the future will be one of public intellect. The Act which I have criticized is our first effort to elicit order from disorder. But it is the mere beginning of a mighty work, which this country must perform, if she is to escape the sentence passed on the Church of Sardis — "Thou hast a name that thou livest and art dead." At the conclusion Of Dr. Lyon Playfair‘s address, Mr. Pears, the general secretary of the Association, read to the meeting a letter which he had received from Earl Russell, in reply to a request that he would take the chair at one of the meetings of the International Law Session. The letter was as follows :— "Minto, Hawick, Sept. 23. "Sir, — I have received your letter of the 20th inst. too late to avail myself the proposal contained in it. Had I remained in the neighbourhood of Newcastle I should have been proud of the honour of presiding this day at the International Law Section. The question seems to be one rightly put, — Is it desirable to prohibit the exportation of contraband of war ? This question has been generally resolved in the negative by writers on the law of nations. Even the export of armed ships is not prohibited by these writers. The United States of America first, and the United Kingdom of the British Isles secondly, have departed from the rule in the instance of armed ships of war and enlisted troops. But these relaxations have given rise to complaints and conflicts, which make it doubtful whether the obligations of neutral nations ought not rather to be diminished then multiplied. The German States at present complain that arms are sent to France by manufacturers. At the same time coal is sent in large quantities to Hamburg, and will, no doubt, be used on the railways which convey German troops to the frontiers, or even into the interior of France. If arms are not to be exported, can we expect that France will not complain that coal, manifestly intended for warlike purposes, is exported to the German Confederation without impediment ? It appears to me that troops drilled and organized, and ships armed and manned, ought not to be allowed by neutrals to leave their shores for the purpose of assisting either belligerent. But beyond this I would not go. In short, I would maintain the doctrine laid down by President Washington. — I remain your obedient servant, Russell." The Departments then assembled in their several rooms. In the Municipal Law Section of the Jurisprudence Department, Dr. Waddilove read a paper "On the Law of Mortmain in Connexion with Charitable Trusts." He described the existing law as being capricious in its operation, and as tending to prevent bequests to useful and beneficent purposes. He then gave the meaning of "mortmain" and its origin, and selected one anomaly as an illustration of the working of the Acts — namely, that any quantity of land might be given by will for a tomb or a mausoleum, but not a foot for the erection or endowment of a hospital or museum for instruction. The paper concluded by a recommendation that the Mortmain Act should be repealed, and that land as well as money, realty as well as personalty, should be permitted to be given by any means for any charitable purpose, such as donation, however, to be under such restrictions as a body of commissioners, or some branch of the Court of Chancery, might impose, and that such body should have a power of supervision and inquiry, so as to determine the policy of permitting such gifts to take effect, and of altering or modifying them so as to adapt them to the wants and habits of the age ; and that, moreover, no gift of any kind should take effect until it had received the sanction of the controlling body. After some discussion on this subject Mr. Alexander Innes read a paper on "The Universal and Necessary Relations of Church and State," which had reference to the action of the secular courts in enforcing the rules or controlling the proceedings of non-established religious communities. In the Repression of Crime Section Mr. Colam read a paper on "Legislation with Regard to Cruelty to Animals," pointing out what he conceived to be omissions or defects in the existing law ; and Mr. D. D. Main read a paper on Reformatory Schools, in which he urged that their action should gradually be restricted to the more hardened class of juvenile offenders. In the Education Department a paper on the "Education of Miners" was read by the Rev. W. A. Scott, M.A., vicar of New Seaham, and contained an account of his experience after being 13 years vicar of a populous pit parish, and a manager of the Londonderry schools, in the county of Durham. Infant schools he recommended should be established, with a view to make the most of the few years a pit boy had for education. They were generally popular, largely attended, and could be made nearly, if not quite, self-supporting. The religious difficulty was unknown in the colliery schools. Sunday-schools, though hindered by the difficulty of obtaining well-qualified teachers, did good service. The night schools were specially interesting. Necessarily limited in size, they often contained pupils of indomitable energy and great perseverance. The long hours of labour, however, made it impossible for the boys generally to avail themselves of the night school. The Mines Inspection Acts had done and were still doing good as regards the age at which boys begin work in the coal mines. Twelve seemed likely to be adopted as the minimum age. Some would insist upon it being fixed at 14 ; but, considering the pressing demand for boys' labour, the wishes and necessities of the parents, and the desires of the boys themselves, he was not prepared to object to boys going to work at 12, provided means were adopted for carrying on their education. He spoke of the long hours of labour. The boys were called out of their sleep soon after 3 a.m. to go to work, and frequently when visiting in their houses he had seen them returning between 5 and 6 p.m. Each set or shift of boys worked for and with two shifts of men. The men's hours of labour being less than eight the boys hours were never less than 12, and often 14 and even more. On winter evenings at his home you would see the boy utterly exhausted, lying at full length asleep upon the floor, black as he came from the pit. In summer, if the fine evening entices him out to play, he may stay at it too long, lessening his hours for sleep so much that when he goes down the pit there is danger of his falling asleep and getting maimed or killed. The nature and duration of the work prevented this class of lads from getting much good from the night schools. These long hours for work lasted through the very years most favourable for instruction — viz., from the time the child first goes to work till he is 18 or 20 years old. About that age his hours become the same as the men's — i.e., less than eight ; but meanwhile habits and powers of study have been lost, and evil and vicious habits too often have come in their place. The results of all this were pernicious in many ways. Even as a question of pecuniary loss they were very serious. Mr. T. E. Forster, in his evidence before the Select Committee of the House of Commons, stated from the pay Friday to the following Wednesday, from 30 to 40 per cent. of the men absent themselves from work. Much of this lost time would certainly be redeemed and much waste and recklessness avoided if the men were better educated. He concluded by commending the case to the sympathies and support of the public. The pit boys were a gallant set of little men. They and their fathers deserved well of their country. They contributed alike to our commercial prosperity and domestic comfort. In the discussion which followed this paper, the Rev. J. C. Street took occasion to protest against the statements which lately appeared in Good Words in reference to the condition of the miners, and which represented them as rude and barbarous. He said that as far as the miners of Northumberland were concerned, there never had been a greater libel. He strongly advocated that attendance at school should be made compulsory. Mr. John Glover spoke of his own experience as a manufacturer in the neighbourhood of Newcastle. For many years he had continued to refuse to employ in his mines any children who could neither read fluently nor write legibly ; and the result was that the parents, instead of acknowledging their obligation to their children by sending them to school, removed to a locality where no such restrictions were enforced. Therefore, to talk of the parents being desirous to educate their children was sheer nonsense. It was a fact that the parents themselves were not sufficiently educated to know the value of education. If possible, the children should be sent to school by the force of compulsory law until they reached the age of 13 or 14, as all influence failed to induce the parents to give them necessary education. In the Health Department there was a paper on the "Public Health in Newcastle," and another on the "Sanitary Aspects of the Sewage Question." In The Economy And Trade Department Professor Leone Levi read his paper on "The International Coinage Question," of which the following is an abstract :— Three great difficulties stood in the way of a sound system of international coinage. The first was difference in the monetary standards, some nations using gold, some using silver, and some both. The second was a difference in that of account, some having the pound, some the dollar, some the franc, and some the thaler or the rouble ; and the third was the difference in the sub-division of the coinage, some adopting the decimal and some the duodecimal. As regards the monetary standard, there seemed to be a general concurrence in favour of a single standard, and that gold. Side by side with the designation of the metal we must put fineness, which differed in some countries. At this present moment some 14,000,000 people use the franc, 40,000,000 the dollar, 30,000,000 the sovereign, and 130,000,000 more use other coin ; but the tendency has for many years been towards an increase in the numbers using the franc, especially since the Monetary Convention between France, Italy, Belgium, and Switzerland, to which other States have now adhered. In order to harmonize the systems of the franc, the dollar, and the sovereign, it has been proposed that the sovereign, which is now worth 25f. 20c., should be reduced in intrinsic value to the level of 25f. and the dollar to that of 5f., and that both the United States and France should coin gold pieces of 25f., to be exchangeable with the pound sterling. Neither France nor the United States has ever proposed to adopt the sovereign as a unit, and, therefore, we shall still have to multiply the money by five or 25 in order to bring them to our denomination, while the decimal portions of their units will have no correspondence whatever with the decimal or duodecimal portions of ours. In order to provide for these essential elements in any system of universal or international coinage, the best method would be the following :— Let the pound sterling, reduced to the value of 25f. ; be divided into 25 shillings, instead of 20 shillings, as at present. Let the new shilling be of tenpence each, and, therefore, the sovereign 250 pence instead of 240. And let it be permissive to use for decimal or international purposes a new unit of 100 such new pence, which will be the equivalent to ten francs, or 8s. 4d. of the present money, two and a half gold pieces or Victorias being equal to the sovereign. We should by this means build a new decimal coinage in this country on the penny, which is universally known and in the hands of every one, and for international purposes we should have one universal money of accounts all the world over, because with the decimal computation we would have only to move the comma from one figure to another to alter the value of the franc to that of ten francs. France having now resolved upon adopting a gold standard, will readily take the ten-franc unit in preference to the franc, and then we shall have not only harmony, but perfect equality, both in the units and in all the subordinate coins — an important subject, let, it be remarked, since the largest number of transactions, whether within the nation or in international business, are made in the penny, in the cent. in the shilling, in the pound sterling, and other integral units being used only in financial or other statistical computations. Sir John Bowring quite concurred with Professor Levi, that an international coinage would be a great advantage to civilization ; but, from his investigations on the subject, he had come to the conclusion that it would be next to impossible to substitute anything for the pound sterling. The sovereign was the only negotiable money that was known in all parts of the world. There was not one single Exchange in which it was not known. Its purity was acknowledged everywhere, and this purity, universality, and antiquity was one great advantage to its constant use. He quoted statistics showing the loss that would be sustained by those in British commerce if the suggestion of Professor Levi was carried out, whose project would lower the value of the sovereign at least 1 per cent. If the arrangement could be made by which the French coin could be allowed to pass current in this country, It would be a great advantage, indeed, to all. While in France, he (Sir John) was always struck with the number of ladies employed in business. The reason for this, he believed, was, that the system adopted in France was so simple that any lady could easily master it. Dr. Farr supported the introduction of the technical system into schools, and handed round copies of a table explanatory of the meaning of the terms, and thought the system sought to be adopted by the paper read was very much allied to it. The system of decimals was much safer and easier to acquire than the old system, and the commission which had inquired into the question of standard weights and measures had reported that the time had arrived when facilities should be afforded by the Government in order that the benefits of metrical weights and measures should be afforded to the people. There was a point in this currency question he wished to draw attention to. The sovereign was issued from the Mint without question, but if you went to the Bank of England with a packet of sovereigns they were weighed, and if one of them happened to be light it was cut, and 4d. would be charged its owner for it. He did not know how it came that the public should be charged for this. It was proposed that if a person found a sovereign in his possession light, he should be afforded the facility by which he might change it for one of proper weight. In conclusion he apologized for the time he had occupied the meeting, but he might say that at the meeting held on this subject of the coinage at the Hague, many of those present were in favour of adopting the franc in preference to the sovereign. Professor Leone Levi afterwards read a second paper on the best mode of obtaining uniformity of weights and measures applicable to the sale of grain and other agricultural products. After pointing out the great advantages which would accrue from the establishing of a uniformity of weights and measures, he stated that a joint committee of the Chamber of Commerce and the International Decimal Association had been considering the question, and made the following recommendations :— "1. That, in the opinion of this committee, it is desirable that the Government should be requested to act upon the recommendations of the Standards Commissioners, in their second and third reports, by legislating, with the least practicable delay, in preference to the introduction of the metric weights and measures in this country, and facilitating their use by making proper arrangements for the legal verification and stamping on such weights and measures. 2. That the Chambers of Agriculture and the Chambers of Commerce be recommended to petition the Legislature to pass, with the least practicable delay, such enactments as will establish the kilogramme with its decimal multiples and divisions as the standard unit of weight in lieu of the present pound avoirdupois and other imperial and customary weights. 3. That, in the opinion of your committee, the use of such standard weights should be made compulsory within a definite time ; and, thenceforth, contracts made by any other weights should be invalid. 4. That although the Central Chamber of Agriculture has recommended that grain should be sold by the ‘cental' of 100lb., which is in use at Liverpool, yet, as your committee find the general average weight of a sack of the different kinds of grain to be about 224lb., or the tenth part of a ton, they are of opinion that it would be desirable to substitute for the ‘cental' a weight of 100 kilogrammes (or, in other words, a ‘quintal') which only differs by a fraction from 220lb. 5. That this report be printed and copies transmitted to all the Chambers of Agriculture and Chambers of Commerce, to Agricultural Societies, Farmers' Clubs, and Municipal Councils, with the request that they will circulate the same and consider the recommendations of this committee at their earliest convenience." After a short discussion it was moved by Mr. Edwin Chadwick, seconded by Mr. Raper, and carried, — "That the section would draw the attention of Council to the desirability of requesting the Civil Service Commissioners to provide that the questions put for testing the fitness of candidates in arithmetic should be confined to questions on the metric and decimal systems, and would further advise that the Government be requested to provide that all contracts made by them should be framed on the decimal and metric systems, and tenders be requested in the same." In the second section of this department, Mr. Bailey Walker read a paper on the "Organization of Societies," in which he referred at length to the immense waste of power and money that is the result of the existing large number of separate organizations for promoting religious, social, political, missionary, benevolent, educational, and other objects, and suggested an elementary plan of agency on behalf of all societies, for obtaining increased efficiency, economy, and harmony. He defines a "society" as a combination "of benevolent, not profit-making, effort, which (a) aims to effect some good, (b) is general in its action, and (c) supported by voluntary contributions." Every society has at present to do two kinds of work — that special to its own objects, and that general and common to all societies. This latter, or general business, absorbs a vast amount of their labour at a correspondingly large cost. It would be possible to do, at a proportionate trifling cost, much of this business, now done by each society for itself, on a small and expensive scale. Mr. Walker proposes :— 1. The establishment of a societies' agency, which should offer facilities for the transaction of this general business. 2. The agency to offer a means of intercommunication to societies and the public, in the shape of a known central office and trained staff. This known office is the backbone of the project. 3. The agency to be directed by a Board or body of gentlemen of known reputation, of all opinions and commanding general confidence. It should be national in its action, its comprehension, and its confidence. 4. Through this known office general business of all societies might be transacted. By it (a) "communication could be effected with any society existing ; (b) information disseminated ; (c) subscriptions, &c., received." 5. The agency would issue condensed classified lists of all societies, with comparative facts respecting them. Reliable data of these numerous bodies would obviously be of the greatest value and interest to those of the general public who support them, and in other ways. Respecting these proposals Mr. Walker observes (1.) that the plan is essentially elementary. However many improvements may be wanted they cannot be done all at once. One step at a time can only be taken ; to attempt more would be to court failure. (2.) An "agency on behalf of" is all that is proposed, not any fusion of the societies themselves. Such fusion is so obviously hopeless that its suggestion would codemn at once as Utopian and impracticable any scheme of which it should form an organic part. (3.) It has the convenient merit of entirely escaping the obstacle known as the religious difficulty, as of all similar ones arising from differences of opinion. (4.) Its commencement need not involve any considerable outlay when established, would become largely — perhaps altogether — self-sustaining. (5.) It would be capable of indefinite expansion. Once established, other agencies for good would be ranged about it, or adapt themselves to its machinery. Mr. Alsager Hill said the idea so ably put forward by Mr. Bailey Walker was not altogether a new one. In 1851 Mr. Samuel Gurney made an attempt to secure a registration of the charities of London, and more especially of the charitable societies. Mr. Hicks and himself made an attempt, about four years ago, to tabulate the charitable societies of London, and issued a notice asking for information, but they obtained but a small amount of support. In 1868, through the exertions of Mr. Solly, a movement was started for organizing the charities of the metropolis, a work which was found to be very extensive, and one requiring great labour and patience to carry out. Some other speakers having been heard, Mr. Walker, in replying, expressed his conviction that 10 or 15 per cent. of the funds of philanthropic societies was expended over working expenses, a state of things which a centralization of offices and organization such as his paper proposed would obviate. He believed the three classes of workmen's societies — co-operative, friendly, and trade organizations — were steadily gravitating towards centralization. A paper by Mr. Parker, on the "Supervision of Pauper Children when Boarded Out," was then taken as read, and the business of the section closed for the day. Besides the actual work of the Congress there was also on Saturday a good deal of collateral and irregular activity. A large party of the members and associates visited the Roman wall, under the able guidance of the local antiquary, Dr. Collingwood Bruce. A public meeting of "ladies" was held, in order to talk about the Contagious Diseases Act, and in the evening another public meeting for the purpose of protesting against standing armies, or, in the exact words of the promoters, to "propose" the abolition of national armaments. There was here an abundance of fluency, and the speakers appeared to have no shadow of suspicion that their "proposal" was, to say the least of it, somewhat in advance of the time. A meeting was also held under the presidency of Sir John Bowring, to discuss the principles on which working men's social clubs and institutes should be established and conducted, and was addressed by Miss Emily Faithful and other speakers. On Sunday Sir John Bowring delivered a lecture in a Unitarian chapel, on "Religious Thought outside the Christian Pale ;" and gave his hearers an interesting account of the leading features of the Buddhist, Brahminical, Parsee, and Mahometan religions ; and also of that phase of Hindoo belief which has been lately made known in England by the visit of Baboo Keshub Chunder Sen.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||