Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

24th February 1870

Action For Damages Against A Colliery Company

White v. Simon, Tait, and Brown. — This was an action brought by the plaintiff, a mason resident at Barngate, Distington, to recover from the defendants, the Haycastle Colliery Company, the sum of £50, £45 being claimed for damage done to two houses belonging to the plaintiff, and the remaining £5 for coal removed from his close. — Mr. Webster was for the plaintiff, and Mr. Howson for the defendants. — Mr. Webster, in opening the case, said he was instructed that the defendants had for some time past been working a colliery near to the plaintiff's property, and had put their workings under two of his houses, thereby very much damaging them. — Plaintiff, on being sworn, deposed that he lived at Barngate, and was the owner of two dwelling houses and half a close of land, with the royalty. Some time in the year of 1867 he found that the house in which he dwelt was beginning to shrink and crack. In consequence of his property being damaged in this way he made application to the defendants in May last, through his attorney, for compensation. He got no reply whatever, and made a second application with no better success. In consequence, he sunk a pit shaft on his own land, for the purpose of ascertaining to what extent they had trespassed in his close. He found they had worked under both of his houses, and it was in consequence of this that his houses were cracked. The sinking of his own shaft did not do any damage to his property. He got a plan made of the defendants' workings by Mr. Peile, late colliery surveyor to the Earl of Lonsdale. [Plan put in.] Referring first to the houses occupied by himself, plaintiff stated that the ceilings were cracked. The window stone of one of the room windows was a little dragged out of its place. There was a crack in the angle of one of the bedrooms and in one of the parlours. The wall was cracked in various places from the ground up to the roof — it was cracked the whole height of one gable. The parlour walls were out of plumb. When windy the air came through the cracks with sufficient force to blow a candle out; it was so cold these wild nights that they could hardly live in the house, some of the cracks being so large as to admit a finger. In the other house the chimneybreast was parted from the wall, and the smoke found a vent. There was a little crack on both sides of the window in the front room, and also a little crack in the ceiling; water came into the room through these cracks. The house was in such a state that he had not been able to have it occupied for twelve months. He estimated the damage to his property at £45, and he claimed £5 for the coal taken from underneath his house. They had also taken coal from about four yards of his close and from under his garden, but he had not taken this into account. Previous to the colliery being worked by the defendants, his houses were in substantial and good state. — In cross-examination, plaintiff said he did not know of any cracks in his house until about October, 1867. He commenced to sink his own pit in June last. The shaft was within six or seven feet of the wall of one of his houses. He found only about 3ft. of covering, and had somewhere about 10 fathoms of rock to go through. He began to take out coal about September, but did not know how many tons he took out. For some of the coal he got 4s 3d, for some 4s 6d, and for some 5s a ton — inclusive of labour, royalty, and everything. The Haycastle colliery was a few hundred yards off his houses, which were cottages. Did not know at what amount they were rated. The walls were common rubble wells, and the buildings were old ones. When blasting the rock to make his shaft he received some complaints. He did not think, however, that his blasting shook his neighbours' buildings — it did not crack them, nor blow the coals from underneath them, either. (Great laughter.) — Re-examined: Simply sunk the pit to hole into the defendant's workings to see what they were doing. — Mr. Peile, whose plan was admitted by Mr. Howson, said he went down the pit sunk by the plaintiff, and found that defendants had been working under his houses. Found also that shrinking had been going on, the height of the original workings, 2ft. 8in., having in some places come down to about a foot. He observed that both of plaintiff's houses were cracked, and the shrinking to which he had alluded was likely to have caused the cracks. He estimated the quantity of coal taken from underneath both houses at 32 tons, for which he thought £5 was a moderate amount to claim. — In cross-examination, witness said he did not think the plaintiff's shaft and workings had in any way caused the damage complained of. He attributed the whole of the damage to the defendants' workings. Made his survey on the 29th ult. — In answer to his Honour, witness stated that the defendants' works were now stopped. — Mr. Webster: But the subsidence has not ceased. — His Honour: I suppose if the houses are repaired next week, they may be in as bad a condition again in a month. — Witness: It may be so. — Mr. Richard Pickering, having examined the houses, estimated that £25 would be required to repair them, and that they had sustained permanent injury to the extent of £20. The buildings would always be fractured after the necessary repairs were made. — In cross-examination, witness stated that when first called in to examine the houses, in January, 1868, he found no cracks but what were recent. The cottages are four roomed, and perhaps 80 or 90 years old. At Distington cottages let for very little. — Captain Wilson said the Haycastle Company worked under his property, which adjoined the plaintiff's, and paid him £137 for the damage they did. — Mr. Howson said witness's was quite a different sort of house from those of the plaintiff. — Witness, in continuation, said it was on the 30th of September, 1867, that he first noticed the plaintiff's house was "going." He had never previously noticed any cracks, but from that time until the present they had gone on increasing in number. He considered that £45 was too small an estimate of the damage done. The turnpike road had sunk bodily down two feet in front of the property, and he did not think the shrinking had yet ceased. In his own house he had from time to time to ease his doors and windows. — In cross-examination, witness said that when plaintiff was blasting, the rebound of the gunpowder shook a little his (witness's) already very much-cracked house, and he requested him to desist. — Mr. Webster intimated that he had two other witnesses to speak as to the workings of the colliery, but his Honour expressed himself satisfied with the evidence of Mr. Peile. — Mr. Howson, for the defence, said there was no doubt his clients had been working coal in and near the plaintiff's property, but they informed him that it was done under some arrangement with Mr. White — that a passage was to be cut underneath his property by his consent. As to their having taken coal out, they were willing to pay whatever his Honour thought was a just recompense. This applied to the second article of particulars. As to the first, they had had the opinion of practical men, who said that their workings had been properly conducted and in a skilful manner, and that the roof had not given at all. The houses, it was their opinion, had been cracked before. They were old rubble buildings — cottages of a very cheap class — and if the defendants had to some extent damaged them, the amount now claimed was preposterous. His Honour would see that if the plaintiff had not himself caused the damage complained of he had contributed to it, the plaintiff ought not to make the defendants pay for what he had done himself. — His Honour asked Mr. Howson what he meant by saying that the plaintiff had contributed to the damages. — Mr. Howson said his Honour would have observed that the plaintiff sunk a shaft within 6ft of his own property, going through, he believed, 12ft. of loose material on which his houses were built, before he reached the rock, blasting through the rock, and taking out a quantity of coal. He would not say how many tons he got out, but there was no doubt he took out as much coal as he could. It was a very extraordinary thing, that although the particulars covered three years, 1867-8-9, no formal application should be made to his clients until less than a year ago, and that immediately thereafter plaintiff should set to work to sink a shaft which must have contributed very largely to the damage sustained by his houses. — Joseph Monkhouse, a colliery viewer of 20 years' standing, said he had seen the plaintiff's pit, which was sunk within six feet of his property. Plaintiff must have sunk through looses material into teens of feet below the foundation of his property. That would have a tendency to make the buildings shrink. He had seen the state of the workings of the defendants' colliery. The pillars were all standing, and the main body of the roof was as firm as could be. He did not think the defendants had been the cause of the cracking in the houses. — His Honour: What has? — Witness: I don't know. — Mr. Howson: When a colliery is shrinking the roof falls? — Witness: Yes, sir. — His Honour (smiling): Do you mean there cannot be shrinking without the roof falling? — Witness: I don't know that. He had made no estimate, but a fair amount of rental for coal taken out of such a place would be 1s a ton. He observed some old cracks in the plaintiff's property. It was evident that at some time the gable had been laid open, and there was a crack connected with that opening. — In cross-examination, witness stated that on his visit of inspection he was all round the houses but not under them. He, however, saw the pillars, and would say that they were not broken down. The sill was raised up a little, but that was due to the action of the atmosphere. He could not account for all the cracks in the plaintiff's and Captain Wilson's houses. — His Honour: Is this as far as you can carry your scientific evidence Mr. Howson? (Laughter.) — Mr. Howson: I think we have proved — His Honour: You have proved nothing. Your witness has not seen what he ought particularly to have seen. — Mr. Howson intimated that he had two other mining witnesses; but one of them (James Rankin) on being called did not appear. The other George Kirkbride, a miner, said he knew the colliery, and could say that the stone roof was standing firm, as were also the pillars under the plaintiff's houses. He had been under the houses, and seen the pillars. — John Dent Fraser said he was a builder, at Harrington. Examined the buildings of Mr. White on Monday, and saw the whole of the cracks. They were all old cracks with the exception of two, which appeared to be new. — By the Court: Knew they were old cracks because they had cobwebs in, and were covered with old paper and old roughcast. — Re-examined: The house was very badly built. Would build such a house for £60 or £70. For £24 would do the whole of the work. A crack in the gable end would have been caused by putting in an oven some years ago. — Cross-examined: Could repair it in a month; and didn't think that people would have to leave the house. Heard Mr. Pickering say it would cost £25 to repair the walls. Would not allow anything for permanent damage, nor anything for allowing one house to stand empty. — John Jackson, Distington, has been in the habit of passing Mr. White's house frequently. Seen cracks in Mr. White's house cracked six or seven years ago. There are houses in Distington, some of the best in the village, had been cracked in the same way. — Cross-examination: Did not know that the road had gone down 18 inches. he cracks were not so large that one could get his hand in. — His Honour said it was a matter of cost. The estimates differed, but the witness Fraser said £25 was fair for repairs of the walls. According to the evidence the damage would be reasonable at £40, and he would give a verdict for that amount.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brown, —      
Howson, —    Solicitor  
Jackson, John      
Kirkbride, George    Miner  
Lonsdale, Earl of      
Monkhouse, Joseph    Colliery Viewer  
Peile, —    Mine Surveyor  
Pickering, Richard      
Simon, —      
Tate, —      
Webster, —    Solicitor  
White, —      
Wilson, —, Captain      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print