Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

12th October 1869

Important Mining Case

Steward V Jones

Mr. Quain, Q.C., the arbitrator in this case, has just made his award, and has given the plaintiffs £6,500 damages, with the costs of the reference and award; which decision, according to the terms of the order of reference, carries with it the costs of the action.

The plaintiffs are trustees claiming under the late Isabella Fletcher, of Whitehaven; and the defendants are the executors of the late Anthony Hill, of the Plymouth Iron Works, in South Wales. The action was brought in June, 1867, for the recovery of damages for improperly working an iron ore mine, situate at Moor Row, about three miles from Whitehaven, held by the defendants under an agreement made in April 1864, between Miss Fletcher and Mr. Hill, for a term of 21 years, which expired on the 25th March, 1867.

Mr. Kay, Q.C., and Mr. Charles Compton, instructed by Mr. Postlethwaite, of Whitehaven, one of the plaintiffs, and Messrs. Gray, Johnson, and Mounsey, of Gray's Inn, were counsel for the plaintiffs; and Mr. Jones, Q.C., instructed by Messrs. Upton, Johnston, and Upton, of Austin Friars, was counsel for the defendants.

The first and material count of the declaration stated that the defendants were tenants to the plaintiffs of the mines in question on certain terms — amongst others that they would work the mines in the best and most skilful manner; that they would leave sufficient roofs and pillars for preventing the pits, shafts, levels, &c., from being closed up and crushed until the same were fairly wrought out; and that, at the end of the tenancy, they would surrender the mines to the plaintiffs in a fair working state and condition; and the roofs and pillars of such of them as should be unexhausted well secured and supported; and all the levels, pits, shafts, &c., belonging to the mines and works, and then in use, in good and sufficient order and condition for the working thereof. Upon this count five breaches were assigned; The 1st claiming for some land which the defendants had taken up in the course of the works; 2nd and 3rd — that they had not left sufficient roofs and pillars; and 5th — that the mines were left at the end of the term in a bad and unfair working state and condition; and with the roofs and pillars of the unexhausted parts badly secured and supported; and with the levels, drifts, &c., then in use, in bad and insufficient order and condition for the future working of the mines, and with certain of them, which were necessary to be kept open for the future working of the mines, filled up, demolished, and injured to the great damage and deterioration of the mines.

The defendants pleaded 1st, denying the tenancy; 2nd, denying the several alleged breaches; and 3rd they paid into court £71 10s, the sum claimed for land taken up; and upon the two first pleas issue was joined.

By an order of Mr. Justice Bramwell, made in July, 1869, the action was referred to Mr. Quain, Q.C., who viewed the mines, and held together 38 sittings, 28 of which were occupied in hearing the evidence on both sides, seven by defendant's counsel in summing up, and three by the plaintiff's counsel in reply. The sittings were held at different places — five at different times in London, and the others at Whitehaven, Grange, Malvern, Keswick, and Brighton.

The plaintiff's witnesses were Mr. J. L. Burns, the lessee of the mines; Mr. Forster, of Newcastle-upon-Tyne; Mr. Marley, of Darlington; Mr. Dixon and Mr. Hodgetts, of Whitehaven, mining engineers; Mr. Kirkconel, manager of the Cleator Moor furnaces; Mr. John Wilson, a lessee; Messrs. Kitchen, Thompson, Irving, and Nicholson, overmen; and 20 miners. The defendant's witnesses were Messrs. Wadham and Turner, of Dalton-in-Furness; Mr. Adams, of Ferndale, South Wales; and Mr. Bewick, of Hadon Bridge, Northumberland, mining engineers; Messrs. Davidson, Grey, Musgrave, and Barrett, managers and overmen of mines; and two miners.

The Moor Row Estate contains 73 acres, of which about 20 were opened and worked by the late Mr. Hill, but of these about five acres on the west were sub-let to the Bigrigg Iron Ore Company; six acres on the north-east, called Robin Benn, to Messrs. Lindow; and the remaining nine acres constituted the portion worked by the defendants, and called Fletcher Pit. It appears that in February 1825, Mr. Hill took on a lease for 40 years, from the Earl of Egremont, a very large part of the iron ore royalty in the Lordship of Egremont, in West Cumberland. The provisions of this lease, which it will be seen are important in reference to this action, very carefully direct the mode in which the mines are to be worked during the term, and left at its conclusion. About the same time Mr. Hill also took several small royalties in the neighbourhood of Whitehaven, on agreements for terms of 21 years, amongst which was the Moor Row royalty, which was situated within 200 yards of the boundary of Mr. Hill's Egremont royalty. These agreements were generally of the same character as the agreement for the Moor Row royalty, which was made in April, 1825, and contained, besides the ordinary provision for carrying on the mines in a workmanlike manner, a special provision that the lease to be granted should "contain all the provisions, stipulations, and agreements therein before contained, and all other provisions, covenants, stipulations, and agreements which were usually contained in leases of a similar nature in the same neighbourhood, and particularly in leases of ore granted by the Earl of Egremont." The first agreement between Miss Fletcher and Mr. Hill expired in 1846, when an agreement for a further term of 21 years, in similar terms, and containing the same special clause, was entered into between the parties. It was upon this agreement that the action was brought. Mr. Hill did not raise any ore from the estate during the first agreement nor did he commence to raise ore under the second agreement until March 1860, when seven years of the term only remained unexpired. From this date it was proved that Mr. Hill and his sub-lessees raised 373,407 tons, which, at the average market price during the period, of 13s a ton, would produce £242,714; and after deducting 5s per ton for royalty, interest on capital, and working expenses, a net profit of nearly £150,000 would remain for the seven years, being at the rate of upwards of £21,000 per annum. Mr. Hill died in August 1862, and the defendants, his executors, continued to carry on the mines. It appears that in the year following they entered into an agreement with the gentlemen forming the Plymouth Iron Company, in South Wales, to sell them for £250,000, a large amount of property belonging to Mr. Hill, in Wales, together with "the ore in stock, and to be raised during the remaining period of the Whitehaven leases, to be delivered free on board ship there, at 9s 6d per ton, and the quantity to be maintained as far as possible." At the time of this agreement there were about two years to run in the Egremont lease, and four years in that of Miss Fletcher. The average price of ore during these four years was about 14s per ton at the pit top, or 15s 6d delivered free on board at Whitehaven. In the month of May, 1866, ten months before the end of the lease, it came to the knowledge of Mr. George Dixon, the plaintiffs' check viewer, that the defendants had removed some of the iron ore pillars, and intended, removing others, and he thereupon gave the following notice: -

May 9th, 1866.

"Dear Sir, — I forward you enclosed a tracing from the plan of the Fletcher Pit, showing a portion of the workings and pillars supporting the roofs and roadways of the mine, and I have to request that none of the pillars shaded or tinted brown be removed, taken away, or diminished, but left as they now stand and are shown on the plan, for the proper and sufficient support of the several roadways, air and water courses, and the support of surface works, and which require to be left in an open and efficient state for the future working of the mine, and the unwrought portion of the royalty. — I am, &c.,

George Dixon

"Jas. Davidson, Esq., Moor Row Mines, Whitehaven."

At this time there were 35 iron ore pillars supporting the mine, all of which Mr. Dixon required to be left. On receiving this notice the defendants called in Mr. Wadham, the mining engineer, to report upon it, furnishing him with extracts from the Egremont lease. His report bears date 18th June, 1866, and in it he recommended that nine of the pillars on the west side of the workings which Mr. Dixon had required to remain, might be removed, and as to the remaining pillars he reported as follows: -

"I find that a considerable quantity of ore yet remains to be worked away from the north — east end of the working, and I consider that all pillars necessary for the up — holding of the tramway from this part of the working to the "pits-eye" should be left untouched."

The defendants, it would appear, very soon after this report, of Mr. Wadham, called in another gentleman, Mr. Adams, and these gentlemen then made a joint report which is as follows: -

September 10th, 1866

"Fletcher Iron Ore Pit, Bigrigg, Cumberland."

"Dear Sir, — In accordance with your request we have read over Mr. Dixon's letter to Mr. Davidson on the 9th of May last, and examined the tracing from the mine plan accompanying it, on which he has coloured the pillars he desires may be left."

"We have also read the extracts from the Egremont lease of this mine to the late Mr. Anthony Hill, referring to the working of the mine, and have subsequently and separately visited the mines and have carefully examined them."

"The lease provides that the lease shall and will leave sufficient props and pillars for preventing the pits, shafts, sought, levels, or groves from being closed up and crushed until the same are fairly wrought out, and air the mines, ores, minerals, and metals, and substances hereby demised."

"And also shall and will at the end or other sooner determination of the said term of forty years hereby granted, to leave, surrender, and yield, up to the said Earl of Egremont his heirs and assigns, the said mines and premises hereby demised in a fair working state and condition, and the roofs and pillars of such of the said mines and premises as shall be unexhausted, and supported."

"We find that the ore on the south-west side of the property, and which in the accompanying trading is tinted brown, has been worked, and so along on the east where the roof has fallen in."

"We recommend that a double shift of men be put on in every available place for getting ore, and that the face of the north workings be pressed forward with all dispatch, also that the present inclined plane be lengthened to rise a shown in tracing, and a new line of tramway laid from this point to the face of the workings as shown by dotted blue line, with the exception of about 11 yards between C and D, the road can be laid very shortly an the distance between these points can be driven and cleared in about eight weeks, as men can be put on at both places."

"This done, we recommend the removal of the whole of the ore pillars marked with pink lines, leaving those shaded pink and lettered 'A' entire. This we think will be ample support for the safety of the mine, and the future workings of the pit, and quite in accordance with the provisions of the lease."

"By this working with a double shift of men, we think 1,000 pit tons per fortnight may be obtained for the remainder of the term of your lease. — We are, &c."

Edward Wadham,

William Adams.

"David Joseph, Esq., Ely Rise, Cardiff"

The pillars thus advised to be removed were the same pillars which Mr. Wadham had advised in his first report should remain, and about ten of them were on the east side of the workings. The 1000 pit tons per fortnight mentioned in the report were frequently referred to in the letters put in evidence of the defendant, Mr. Joseph, to Mr. Davidson, as essential to be kept up, and must be taken as the quantity to be maintained under the contract with the Plymouth Company. According to the suggestion in the joint report, the defendants made the new drift-way, and removed the ten ore pillars flanking the old tramway, which, it appeared had a gentle fall to the shaft, while the new drift-way was on a rise and required a horse to draw the ore. It would appear that the defendants, fortified by these reports, proceeded with the removal of the ore pillars without regard to Mr. Dixon's notice, and without giving him any intimation of what they intended to do, or of their having called in Messrs. Wadham and Adams to inspect the mine. Finding that his notice was disregarded, and that nearly all the pillars which he required to be left had been taken out, Mr. Dixon gave a second notice on the 2nd January, 1867, in reply to which he had the first intimation from Mr. Davison of the course they were pursuing, in the following letter: -

"Whitehaven, 16th January, 1867."

"Moor Row Royalty."

"Dear Sir. — I duly received your favour of the 2nd inst., referring to your previous communication of the 9th May last. I beg to state that on receipt of your communication, of the 9th May last, I forwarded the same to Mr. Hill's executors, and that they placed it in the hands of some of the first mining engineers in the country, together with the tracing plan which accompanied it, and that they (the mining gentlemen) carefully inspected and examined the workings in Fletcher Pit, and that what has since been done there has been done under their express directions and approval."

I remain, &c.,

"James Davidson."

"George Dixon, Esq."

The defendants continued removing the ore pillars and thinning the few that remained up to the last hour of the lease; and when it expired, nearly all the pillars, except six or seven small ones for the support of the jigger road had been taken out. Within a week after its expiration, a heavy fall or crush of the roof, extending over great part of the workings, took place, and other falls continued from time to time afterwards, which completely checked and blocked up the workings and cut off the access to the unwrought ore. Shortly before the expiration of the lease the entire royalty was let by the plaintiffs to Messrs. Lindow, who took possession as soon as the defendants left, and commenced at once to build massive limestone pillars for supporting the roofs and roadways, and have continued building such roofs and pillars ever since at a large expense. Finding the new driftway, recommended by Messrs. Wadham and Adams, inconvenient to work, they abandoned it and opened out through the fallen debris the old tramway, supporting it with timber.

The defendants contended and endeavoured to prove that the mine was practically exhausted; that all the available ore had been got from the parts whence the pillars were removed, and that they were therefore entitled to draw back the pillars and let down the mine; that the roof or gut ore was of trifling width and not worth working, and rose only a short distance in the roof to a point, and could not be worked in any other manner than by taking the pillars as they had done, letting down the roof, and then drifting through the fallen debris for the ore fallen with it, or that this was the cheapest, safest, and best way of working such ore; that they adopted one uniform mode of working throughout; and that Mr. Dixon, plaintiffs' check-viewer, had, in a report in October, 1866, approved that mode, and all that had been done up to that time, and that there was no reason why they should change this mode afterwards; that they had sufficiently supported the roads and tramways necessary to be left; that they were not bound by the precise terms of the Egremont lease, but only to work properly, which they had done.

The plaintiff, on the other hand, contended and gave evidence to show that the mode of working adopted by the defendants in the last year of the term was wholly unjustifiable and contrary to the usual and proper mode of working such a mine; that during this time the defendants had proceeded to get as much ore as they could without regard to the safety of the mine or the condition in which it should be left at the end of the term; that the mine was not exhausted, and especially that these large deposits consisted of guts or channels of ore rising from the roof of the flat ore, widening upwards to the whirlstone roof, a height of about 40 feet, and running north and south the whole length of the mine; that they varied in width at the bottom from a few inches to three feet, frequently expanding to a very large deposit under the whirlstone; that there were at least ten such unworked guts in the Fletcher mine, some of which ran into Messrs. Lindow's adjoining mine, called the Walsh mine these guts had been worked and cleaned out before any of the pillars which supported them were removed; that this mode of working ought to have been adopted in the Fletcher mine, and that by removing the pillars and letting down the roof, as the defendants had done the chief part of those upper deposits was entirely lost, and each part of them as might be afterwards obtained by drifting, as the defendants suggested, would be greatly deteriorated by admixture with the fallen debris; that the mode of working adopted by the defendants' was a bad and improper one, and had failed to bring the ore down from the guts, which could be seen still hanging there above the falls, where it must necessarily remain, owing to the formation of the upper part of the gut acting as a shelf in keeping it up; that the mine was left by the defendants in an altogether unsafe and ruinous condition; and it was due solely to the massive limestone pillars built by Messrs. Lindow that any part of it was still open; and lastly, that the defendants were bound by the Egremont lease, and that their mode of working was a direct breach of its provisions, which, as well as requiring that the mine should be skilfully worked, prescribed when the pillars should be left and when they might be removed, showing how proper mining was to be interpreted; and that, under these provisions, the defendants had no right to take any pillars until all the ore had been obtained in the part which such pillars supported.

The evidence on both sides was given at great length on the various points, and was of the most conflicting nature. The defendants contended and gave evidence that guts of the width of three feet were not commercially workable, and it appeared that they had not paid higher wages for working gut ore than 7s per pit ton; while the plaintiffs' evidence went to show that the Bigrigg Company were working guts in the part sub-let to them by Messrs. Lindow of the width of 14 inches, which they could do profitably at wages amounting to 17s a pit ton; and that the smallest indications of ore ought to be explored, as they frequently led to large upper deposits, as was proved in the case of one of the Fletcher guts (E), which at its commencement was a mere string, and afterwards expanded to a large body of ore. The defendants' scientific witnesses also alleged that the limestone pillars built by Messrs. Lindow to support the roof and keep open the roadways were of no use, and the expenditure upon them wholly thrown away.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Adams, —      
Barrett, —      
Bewick, —      
Bramwell, —, Justice      
Burns, J. L.      
Compton, Charles      
Davidson, —      
Dixon, —      
Dixon, George      
Egremont, Earl of      
Fletcher, Isabella      
Forster, —      
Gray, —      
Grey, —      
Hill, Anthony      
Hodgetts, —      
Irving, —      
Johnson, —      
Johnston, —      
Jones, —      
Kay, —      
Kirkconel, —      
Kitchen, —      
Lindow, —      
Marley, —      
Mounsey, —      
Musgrave, —      
Nicholson, —      
Postlethwaite, —      
Quain, —      
Thompson, —      
Turner, —      
Upton, —      
Wadham, —      
Wilson, John      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Fletcher Pit (Iron Ore)  Fletcher Pit (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print