|
17th August 1869 Letters to the EditorColliery ExplosionsSir, Recent explosions in coal mines at home and abroad have deservedly attracted much attention, and have called forth communications and proposals from gentlemen unconnected with the mining profession, which, although they look all very well on paper, would be thoroughly impracticable and even mischievous. I give them full credit for their laudable intentions and scientific attainments, but if they had more acquaintance with the arrangements of mines their proposals would not have been made. After so much of this sort perhaps a few remarks from one in the profession will merit a little of your valuable space. Mr. Bessemer's proposal is not wholly new. So long as 40 years ago Dr. Clanny invented a safety lamp, to burn oil, which was to be supplied with air from above ground, and many variations of the same idea and arrangements have been proposed. The liability of such a complicated and extensive system of pipes as Mr. Bessemer's to go wrong would produce far more danger than it would obviate, not to mention the impossibility of keeping it up. A good-sized colliery would require gasworks competent to supply a little town, an engine capable of drawing its coal, perhaps 20 miles of pipes, and some thousands of lights. The temperature would be greatly increased by the number of lights, which would necessarily be stationary (in itself a great disadvantage), and the danger of fixed lights to the putters and those who travel is too well known already. In fact, I cannot trespass on your space to enumerate a tenth of the objections to it. And for what purpose does Mr. Bessemer advocate this system ? Because the miner requires a powerful light, one that never goes out, never needs trimming. But, if so powerful light is necessary, how is it that the great proportion of miners prefer a Davy or a Clunny lamp, which gives the best light we know of ? The present lamps very seldom go out, and, as to trimming, a few seconds suffice for the operation, and it lasts three hours. For safety, convenience, and economy this system could never compete with a system of portable inexplosive lamps ; and as regards cost, where Mr. Bessemer's plan would cost £1,000, inexplosive lamps might cost £5. In the Iron and Coal Trade Review of the 11th inst. the editor remarks that the "antiquated plan" of furnace ventilation, even under the most favourable circumstances, only allows of a comparatively small amount of air being sent through a mine. I would refer him to the Colliery Guardian of the 6th inst., where the furnace ventilation of Eldon Colliery for one seam is stated to be 255,000 cubic feet of air per minute. And also in his remarks on the influence of barometric pressure on ventilation he is decidedly in error ; the number of accidents with a falling barometer not only preponderates over those with a rising pressure, but over the combined number of those with steady and rising barometers. Much is said of the power of ventilation, and certainly this department cannot be too much attended to ; but too much confidence may be placed in it. In a paper on "The Tension of Firedamp in situ," Mr. J. J. Taylor says :— "To depend on mere ventilation in encountering so powerful an agent is only an abuse of a very excellent principle ; we require further security, and that security must rest at present upon the universal employment of the safety lamp in our deep and fiery mines." And if a safety lamp is to be used, why not have one "in reality and effectually a safe lamp ?" Recent experiments have most powerfully demonstrated the need of such a safety lamp, but experiments only may not convince ; I, therefore, refer any sceptic on this point to the report of the South Shields Committee, to Mr. Thomas E. Wales's (Mining Inspector of South Wales) Report for 1865, and to the Transactions of the North of England Institute of Mining Engineers, vol. 15, part 4, pp. 99-102 ; and, while so many accidents are put down to the recklessness of miners, bad ventilation, &c., it would be well to remember there have been such explosions as that at Wallsend in 1818, the Jane pit, Houghton, in 1864, Cwmaman in 1865, Pelton Fell in 1866, and Monterrard, St. Etienne, in 1869, where the cause was most certainly the failure of the present safety lamps. In giving his Parliamentary evidence (1852) Mr. Darlington said, "There are very numerous instances of accidents taking place that we could attribute to nothing else than the failure of lamps in use." In the above article it is said, "If a collier were working in an explosive atmosphere the flame of his lamp would give him ample warning of his danger, and we cannot believe that even the most reckless men would madly rush to destruction by tampering with what they are led to believe is their special safeguard." Miners have in general too great a confidence in the Davy, and many will expose a lamp where they ought to retreat ; and it is not necessary to lay even this at the door of the miner — he may be exposed to a blower or a rush of gas from many causes, in which case he would have little or no warning — a current of 20 feet a second would not leave him one solitary second's warning. It may be urged that some circumstances may not occur in 20 years, yet no one has any guarantee they will not occur to-morrow ; they have occurred, and, unless proper precautions be taken, will sooner or later occur again, to the horror of the public and the shame of the mining profession. We require a lamp which will not burn in a comparatively still atmosphere of gas, and will not pass the flame in the strongest currents of mines, and that such can be had several mining engineers can testify. It is, therefore, evident at whose door the fault will lie if this simple but effectual remedy be not adopted. None of the three greatest precautions can be dispensed with ; ventilation, discipline, and inexplosive lamps are all necessary, and no one can spare the other. "Index," in the Colliery Guardian of the 6th inst., says (and I perfectly agree with him) "it is evident to all that abundant ventilation is not in itself sufficient to prevent these deplorable accidents ;" and with regard to the statement of Mr. Macdonald that "gas given off should be so diluted by abundance of fresh air that no reckless miner could set fire to it," "Avaucez" truly says, "To a practical pitman the above will tend to provoke a smile rather than to confirm his claims to a practical acquaintance with coal mining in fiery districts." That we may never be able to provide against all the contingencies of mining operations does not in the least reduce the obligations of all parties to adopt whatever science can offer that is practicable to secure the greatest safety of life and property ; and I think it rather strange that, amid all the discussions of the last few months, so few have given this question that calm and deliberate consideration which its great importance truly deserves. I am, Sir, yours faithfully, Aug. 14. "Moneo Et Munio."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||