|
23rd February 1869 Important Fishery Case at KewickThe Goldscope Lead Mine And Newlands BeckAlleged Destruction Of FishAt the petty sessions held at Keswick on Saturday last before T. S. Spedding, S. Z. Langton, William Oxley and J. J. Spedding, Esqrs, Mr. Plummer, manager for Mr. May, lessee of the Goldscope Lead Mine, appeared to answer a complaint preferred by the Derwent Angling Association of poisoning the fish in Newlands Beck, by discharging into it poisonous liquids, the washings of the lead ore. Mr. Moordaff represented the Derwent Angling Association; Mr. Webster appeared for the defendants; and Mr. Saul, jun., attended to watch the case on behalf of Lord Leconfield, as lord of the manor. Mr. Samuel Gordon, secretary to the Angling Association, deposed that he had known Newlands Beck for 40 years, near which he had a farm. There was no a fish in that part of the stream where the Goldscope mining water entered. It used to be one of the best trout streams in the neighbourhood less than 25 years ago. It contained trout all the way down to Bassenthwaite, and was one of the best spawning rivers in the neighbourhood. Was at the mines in January last with Mr. Harrison and Mr. John Bowe, of Stair, when he saw the water flowing from the washing pits into the river. — Witness was cross examined by Mr. Webster, with a view to show that of his own knowledge he could not tell what had poisoned or driven the fish from the river, and he was asked whether he had looked under every stone in the river to see if there were fish there — a "riddle-me-ree" question which elicited such an exhibition of feeling from the crowd in the hall, that Inspector Rollinson threatened to have the court cleared. Mr. Peter Harrison, schoolmaster, had known Newlands Beck for 45 years. Had fished there before it was polluted by the mining water, which had destroyed the fish. Had fished there every season till about 21 or 22 years ago. It had been the most prolific river in the neighbourhood for trout. Had been the habit of fishing from Stair to Goldscope, below where the water came in from the mine. Remembered the late Mr. Clarke coming into the neighbourhood and opening the mine. Before that gentleman came the stream was swarming with trout. After Mr. Clarke's arrival the washing of lead ore commenced. It was 16 or 17 years since the trout began to be found dead in the stream. Had seen thick, slimy water coming from the pits into the water. There was no fishing whatever now in Newlands Beck. At certain seasons of the year the fish had been in the habit of running up from Bassenthwaite Lake to spawn in Newlands Back. Now no fish were ever seen in the stream below Newlands Beck. Thomas Saulder, innkeeper, Keswick, who had lived at Braithwaite for 25 years, and John Bowe, yeoman, of Stair, also gave evidence as to the destruction of fish in Newlands Beck since it had been made the receptacle of the ore-washings from Goldscope Mine. Mr. Webster said that before his clients could be convinced it would be necessary to prove that the fish had been killed by the poisonous substances emanating from the mine. Until the bench were satisfied that the water flowing into the beck was deleterious, said that the fish had been poisoned by the same, there was no case against his clients. There was an absence of proof of evidence on the part of the defendants. No witness had been called to prove the commission of an offence on the 22nd January last; and he should be able to prove by analytical evidence that the water issuing from the mine had not destroyed the fish. Mr. Benjamin Plummer, the manager of Goldscope, described the process by which lead is separated from the ore (illustrating his narrative by a plan of the works at the mine); and, in referring to the washing of the lead, said that every effort had been made at a reasonable cost to remove the deleterious matter from the slime. — Cross examined by Mr. Moordaff; Catch pits had been adopted at the mine for the purpose of purifying the mine. Charles Lowden, a miner, said there were eleven catch pits at Goldscope. He did not think they could be improved. Joseph Pooley, miner, considered everything had been done that could be done to purify the water. Mr. C. A. Haywood, analytic chemist, Whitehaven, engaged on the Cleator Iron Works, said that on the 18th instant he had analysed samples of water from Newland Beck, and he did not find in it a sufficient quantity pf any matter to poison fish. Mr. Spedding intimated that he thought the case was proved, whereupon Mr. Webster said his clients were willing that the works should be examined by a specialist and is to be agreed upon between the parties. It was ultimately agreed that the case should be adjourned for a fortnight, the works in the meantime to be examined.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||