12th February 1869, Page: 5, Column: 3
Breach Of Contract
In the Court of Queen's
Bench, Westminster, on Wednesday, before Justices
Mellor and Hannen, in the case of Love v. Ekless,
was an action for damages for breach of contract in
not accepting a cargo of coals. The plaintiffs are the
Messrs Love, coalowners, in the county of Durham ;
and the defendant is in the coal trade at Southampton.
The case was tried at Durham Assizes, before
Mr. Justice Hannen, when a verdict was entered
for the plaintiffs, with leave to the defendant to
move to show cause why a verdict should not be
given against plaintiffs. A rule nisi was granted accordingly.
The facts of the case appeared in the
correspondence. Mr. Wishart (who was plaintiffs'
agent) wrote on the 19th of February, 1868, to the
defendant, saying he should be glad to supply him
with a regular quantity of South Hetton coals at 10s
6d per ton, but should require a reference, and unless
defendant had vessels, plaintiff should be glad
to charter. The defendant, in answer, thought the
price too high ; but was willing to take 200 or 250
chaldrons at 17s 6d per ton, cost and freight, or 6d
less than plaintiff's offer, Mr. Wishart's reply to
that was that he did not think defendant could get
good coals at less than 10s 6d ; but at the same time,
he should have no objection to ship a trial cargo at
defendant's reduced price of 6d per ton. The plaintiff
commenced to ship the coals, and defendant
wrote two days afterwards to plaintiff, whom it did
not reach till the 26th, informing him of the price
of coal in general, and incidentally mentioning that
the coals referred to on the 22nd, two days previous
to this writing, were not to be sent. This was the
alleged breach of contract. — After a lengthened argument,
the rule was made absolute, thus reversing
the decision of the jury at Durham Assizes.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Ekless, — | | | |
| Hannen, — | | Justice | |
| Love, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Mellor, — | | Justice | |
| Wishart, — | | Agent | |