|
17th October 1867 Fatal Pit Accident at Cleator MoorThe Inquest — Singular EvidenceAbout mid-day on Saturday last, a man named Thomas Timmins received fatal injuries whilst working in Mr. Stirling's No. 1 Pit at Cleator Moor. A piece of metal weighing about six tons fell upon him crushing him so severely that he died in about 20 minutes after his reception into Mr. Stirling's hospital, where he had been removed. Deceased, who was about 42 years of age, leaves a widow but no children. On Monday morning, Dr. Henry Bell, the coroner, for the liberty of the Lordship of Egremont, held an inquest on view of the body of Timmins at the house of Mr. Winward, Cleator Moor. The following were the jury:— Messrs. Thomas Richardson (foreman), Robert Smith, Lancelot Mossop, Henry Ward, William Ward, Thomas Nutsford, William Armstrong, Robert Slater, Henry Wardle, Thomas Gould, Thomas Clague, and Henry Bell. The Coroner, in opening the inquiry, said that this was the third fatal accident, which had occurred in Mr. Stirling's pit within a very short period. That gentleman naturally felt rather annoyed, and was desirous of having the cause of the present accident thoroughly investigated. If there was shown to be any defect in the mode of working the pits, Mr. Stirling would be the first man to remedy it. The jury would therefore have to go minutely into this case. It was of course quite possible that the man's death might have been purely accidental, but at all events it was desirable that the thing should be thoroughly sifted. The following evidence was then taken: - Michael Cullen, Cleator Moor, who worked with deceased in No. 1 Pit, said: On Saturday, when this accident happened, I was working close beside the deceased. He was killed by a fall of metal partly from the side and partly from the roof. The place where we were working would be about seven feet wide, and it was a good height — perhaps higher than the ceiling of this room [nine or ten feet]. I was filling the bogies, and deceased was in advance of me loosening the stuff. We were six feet in from the drift. [Witness here explained the mode in which they were working. It appeared they were working the metal at the bottom, leaving large quantities of ore overhead.] George Gray, the underground manager, visited the place on the Friday before the accident happened. He said we were to put in some props, but we differed as to the way in which the props should be put in. The Coroner: What did Gray say to you? — Witness: He said something like this, — that if we did not put in wood as he wished he would turn us away from Mr. Stirling's employ. The Coroner: Then, did you do as he told you? — Witness: No, we did not. It was the last day of the fortnight, and we were anxious that our wages should be as large as possible. We had only been making very little in the first part of the fortnight. The Coroner: And that wrought the mischief. In future the overlooker must insist upon you working in his way; otherwise there will be no end of accidents. Did the overlooker not come near you again before the accident happened? — Witness: He was coming when the accident happened. The Coroner: Was there no one inspected the place between the time that Gray visited it on Friday, up till the time of the accident? Witness: Not while we were working. The Coroner: Can you tell us exactly what Gray said to you? — Witness: He said we must use props. The Coroner: But you did not do it? — Witness: No: because it was the last day of the fortnight. The Coroner: Then what is the use of the overlooker if you don't follow his instructions? — (No answer.) A Juror: Suppose it had been the first day of the fortnight instead of the last you would have obeyed him? — Witness: Oh, yes; we intended putting in props to day. A Juror: And by that delay this man lost his life. [Witness, in answer to some questions, said they had been blasting near the scene of the accident on Saturday. They blasted a piece of loose ore, which was too large to break.] The Coroner: Do you consider the pit safe? — Witness: I don't know about the pit. — The Coroner: Do you consider the part where you were working safe? — Witness: "It was not particularly safe. Perhaps it was safe enough." The Coroner: You don't take ordinary care. The overlooker must be told that when he gives orders they are to be carried out, independently of money considerations or anything else. Some questions were put to the witness as to the cause of his having a bad fortnight; but no very lucid answer could be got. — Mr. Richardson (the foreman) suggested that they had probably been working in a place where ore was not so plentiful. Witness, being next examined as to the precise mode in which Timmins met his death, said: First a small piece of ore fell. That appeared to alarm deceased. He threw away his pick, as if intending to escape, but something must have caught him, for he fell. The mass of metal fell upon his back. The only words he said were, "Take me out alive, and don't let me die here." We were half-an-hour before we got him out of the pit. I cannot say how long he lived after that. — A Juror: He lived a quarter of an hour after he was admitted to the hospital. The Coroner: Have you worked in any other pits? — Witness: I have. — The Coroner: Do you think it's as well conducted as any other pit? — Witness: It is a sort of ground that blows — something, like sill. — The Coroner: And that makes it more dangerous? — Witness: Yes. The Coroner: Suppose you had carried out the orders of the overlooker would this accident have happened? — Witness: The metal was as likely to fall when we were putting in the wood as at any other time. We could scarcely have had the props in before the accident happened. We are always supplied with plenty of wood — in fact we have every thing that is necessary. Dennis Kennedy, who also worked with the deceased, was next examined. He said: I was within six feet of the deceased when the accident happened. I was filling the bogies with the loose ore. Gray told us on Friday that we must put in wood. That was to make the place safe for ourselves. We did not follow his orders. The Coroner: Is it customary when he gives you orders that you don't carry them out? — Witness: We were in a hurry; and in that case we sometimes wait a day or two. We had had a bad fortnight. The Coroner: Why had you a bad fortnight? — Witness: We had made a bad agreement for ourselves. During the fortnight we had been clearing our way into this place, and ore was difficult to get. I have worked at the pit two years, and consider it safe enough. We were not so watchful, as we should have been on this occasion. The fault is entirely on ourselves. We usually carry out the overlooker's directions, but in this instance we thought we would not do so till to day. A Juror: Would a better pay not make you more careful? — (No definite answer.) A Juror: How much did you make in the preceding fortnight? — Witness: £1 10s 6d. A Juror: That is not a large wage. The Coroner (to the jury): Suppose you increased a man's wages, do you think it would tend to make him more careful? — Mr. Nutsford (one of the jurymen) thought so. For instance they could afford more time to put the props in. — The Coroner questioned this. He did not believe that with large wages the men would be one whit more careful. — Mr. Nutsford said he had been informed that when the miners in Mr. Stirling's employ made good wages one fortnight they "cut them short" the next. On the other hand, when their wages were small they were not made up. [This point was fully explained in the evidence of George Gray.] Witness continued: This accident happened at the pit where some time ago there was a landslip by which the office was destroyed. It was rather dangerous work. The Coroner: Nothing will prevent the occurrence of such accidents until iron-ore mines are like coal-pits put under Government inspection. We need have no further evidence as to the cause of death. The question still remains why are the orders of the overseers not carried out? We should have evidence on that point. I think it is no part of our duty to inquire as to the wages, which these men are paid, or as to the mode of paying. George Gray, the underground manager who was not sworn, was then examined. He said: On Friday afternoon I visited the place where the accident occurred. I thought it safe enough, but I considered it would be a vast deal safer if they would put in props and remove the loose metal from the roof. I told deceased and the two preceding witnesses to do so. They said, "The roof is good enough," and excused themselves from doing it then, saying they wanted the metal out. I said, "You must have that done before I come back, or I will send you off." The men are all under me. The Coroner: When you give orders of that kind would it not be much better if you insisted upon being obeyed? Witness: I can only insist upon them doing what I tell them by threatening them with dismissal. I also told them on the previous Wednesday to put in props. The Coroner asked if, in the event of disobedience to orders, the witness could not dismiss them instantly? Witness: The overlooker would be in danger of his life. Even as it is, they will threaten my life for doing what I can to save them. It is hard to manage them. The Coroner: Do you mean that your life is threatened? Witness: I say that I have occasionally been threatened with bodily injury if I proposed to dismiss any one. I believe they would do me a bodily injury. I believe if they had commenced to prop on Friday they had time to make all secure before the accident happened. The Coroner: Does the mine, generally speaking, require great caution in working it? Witness: It does. There are some sill beds, which make it dangerous. Notwithstanding the risk, and the great care required, the men are very reckless. On the last day of the fortnight I have seen the men nearly breaking one another's legs in their hurry to get out the metal. Witness was then examined as to the mode in which the men were paid. He said he allowed deceased and those working with him something extra in consideration of the difficulty of getting out the ore in that place; he allowed them 2d per cwt. Several of the jurymen remarked that this was very good pay. The Coroner: That does away with any notion that the men are underpaid. Witness, in answer to a question, said that the average wages of all the men employed at the pits during the last fortnight was £2 13s. The Coroner: It has been said that when the men's wages are large something is deducted. Is it a fact that when a man makes a good deal of money in any particular fortnight something is kept back from him? Witness: That is not so. We calculate that the men should make about 4s a-day. When I find that they are making perhaps £4 or £5 a fortnight I know that that part of the working is getting softer, and I make a fresh arrangement with them. On the other hand, when they do not make 4s a-day I make it up to them by increasing the price paid per cwt. The Coroner: And you consider that the deceased and the men who worked along with him were paid a fair average price? Witness: Certainly. The Coroner: Don't you think it would be better to make it a rule that when the men do not obey your orders they should be liable to instant dismissal? — Witness: It would be very difficult to carry out such a rule. I could not take it in hand. I would sooner leave my situation than attempt such a thing. I could not put such stringent laws in force. — Witness then withdrew. The jury found as their verdict that the deceased was killed accidentally; and with regard to the mines they found that they were properly managed, and that the men are themselves to blame for such accidents as that which proved fatal to deceased.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||