|
3rd August 1867 Charge Against An Engineman Of Endangering LifeJames Johnson, an engineman, appeared to answer an information laid by Mr. William Miller, charging him with having neglected, for the space of one hour, and upwards, to attend to a steam-engine at No. 1 pit, Crossfield, the property of John Stirling, Esq., which it was then and there his duty to attend to, whereby the lives of other workmen were endangered. Mr. Webster appeared in support of the information, and Mr. Howson for the defendant. The case for the prosecution was that the defendant, who had been in the service of Mr. Stirling since September last, had charge of two engines at a sinking pit — the one a pumping engine, and the other a winding one. On the date mentioned, about nine o'clock in the morning, the defendant had some words with the manager, a man named George Grey, in consequence of the pumping engine making a greater number of strokes per minute than the latter had ordered him to drive at, and by which, it was alleged, he was endangering the pipes. Grey gave the defendant a week's notice to quit, and then left the place to go down another pit. It was an understood thing at Mr. Stirling's works , that if either wished to put an end to an engagement, a week's notice should be given, but Mr. Grey was unable to say whether or not, when he engaged the defendant, anything was said to a week's notice being given. When the dispute took place the sinkers were down the pit engaged in blasting, and it was the defendant's duty, just before the fuse was applied to the powder, to draw up the men from the pit at a given signal. About five or ten minutes after the defendant had received his notice, he went up to Grey and demanded his wages. Grey asked him if he had left his engine, to which defendant answered that he had. Grey warned him of the consequences of leaving the sinkers in the pit, but the defendant proceeded to the office, which was some distance from the pit, and there demanded his wages. Mr. Miller, in consequence of a message he had received from Grey, refused to pay the defendant his wages, and told him that he would have to hold himself responsible for leaving the pit in such a manner. Defendant eventually returned to his work after the absence of about an hour. During that time there was no person in charge of the engines, and there was no person to have drawn up the sinkers had it been requisite. The pit, it was stated, made a great deal of water, and had the pumping engine been by any means stopped, the pit would soon have been flooded, and the men, had they been suffered to remain in the pit, would have been drowned. The defendant had since been dismissed, but the liability of Mr. Stirling to pay the man his wages up to the time when his notice would expire was admitted. In cross-examination, Mr. Howson elicited from Grey the fact that he had said to the defendant, "You can leave when you choose, but I give you six days notice." He explained, however, that he did not mean by that that the defendant should leave his work at once, as, on the contrary, he warned him of the consequence of doing so. For the defence Mr. Howson submitted that there had really been no offence, even supposing the defendant had been bound to give a weeks notice. He contended that the defendant, according to the terms of his engagement, was not bound to give a week's notice, but said it was not his intention to press that point. All that his client had done was going between the works and the office in consequence of a difference arising between himself and Grey. He returned to his work, but on the following day another engineman was obtained, and the defendant was dismissed. He submitted that if the man had intended to desert his work he would not have returned, and that he would not, before leaving, have secured the handles of the winding engine and made the pumping engine act more slowly, as he had done. It was said that so-and-so might have happened, but nothing did happen, nor was it probable that anything would after the precaution taken by the defendant. Ramsay, the foreman of the sinkers, was then examined in behalf of the defendant, after which the magistrates retired to consider the case. On their return into court, the Chairman said the magistrates, after taking the case fully into consideration, had come to the conclusion that the defendant was not justified in leaving his engine, as thereby serious consequences might have ensued. As, however, a wish had been expressed that the bench should act leniently, their sentence would be that the defendant should be imprisoned for 24 hours.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||