4th June 1867
Cleator Moor Water Supply
To the Editor of the Cumberland Pacquet
Sir, — At a meeting of the Cleator Moor Local Board held on 6th inst., there were copies of two memorials read, which had been sent to the Secretary of State for the Home Department, on the subject of a supply of water for that district.
In the first — emanating from certain of the inhabitants — I find it stated "that the water is supplied from iron ore mines, unfiltered, and necessarily impure in its character;" "that such supply is dependent on the good will
of John Stirling, Esq.;" and "must inevitably be incompatible with purity, and injurious to the health of the population."
In the second — which is signed by 14 medical men practising in the vicinity, — it is stated, "That the supply, coming from iron-ore workings, and used without filtration is, in our opinion highly detrimental to the public health."
Such statements being totally incorrect, and calculated to create alarm in the minds of the people, as to one of the few sources of supply now available to them, and by so doing, to increase the very evils which the memorialists are desirous of
mitigating, I cannot allow them to pass without contradiction. The facts are these: The water in question is found in a thick gravel bed 90 feet from the surface. It is therefore, in its natural state, filtered in the most perfect manner.
It is never allowed to descend that pits, but is pumped up direct from the gravel, into iron pipes, through which it is forced to Cleator Moor; therefore, it is never in contact with iron ore at all, and does not, as stated by the medical men, "come
from iron-ore workings."
With respect to the quality of it, and whether it can, be possibly, be injurious to the health of the people, I beg to refer you to the report and analysis sent herewith, which I have just received from Mr. Tosh, of Maryport. This speaks for itself, and
I am happy to see, leaves no doubt as to the purity of the water and its fitness for domestic use. I have merely to add, that if any one concerned doubts the accuracy of what I have stated, let him come and see, and so judge for himself. That a proper
and permanent supply of water for Cleator Moor is absolutely necessary, no rational man will deny; but it appears to me that the memorialists, in their praiseworthy efforts to attain this most desirable object, have allowed their zeal to outrun their
discretion. — I am, &c.,
John Stirling.
Montreal Iron-ore Works,
Whitehaven, May 29th, 1867.
Analysis Of Water
Maryport, May 22nd, 1867
The sample of water examined was taken by myself, on the 14th May, at the tap from which the inhabitants of Cleator Moor draw their supplies. The water was slightly muddy in appearance, had a soft taste, and was devoid of smell. A careful analysis showed
it to contain the following ingredients, in the proportions denoted: -
| | | Grains per
|
| | | Imp. Gal.
|
| Carbonate of Lime | | 2.407 |
| Carbonate of Magnesia | | .206 |
| Sulphate of Lime | | 4.599 |
| Sulphate of Magnesia | | .270 |
| Chloride of Magnesium | | 1.487 |
| Chloride of Sodium | | 1.347 |
| Clay, &c, mechanically suspended | | .709 |
| Organic Matter | | 2.592 |
| Nitrates & Ammonia | | distinct traces |
| Total Solids | | 13.617 |
| Degrees of hardness, | | 6.1. |
From the small quantity of dissolved salts, and the innocuous nature of the organic matter (probably of vegetable origin) it is evident that this water is of good quality, and well suited to domestic purposes. Compared with the water of London and other
large towns, it is much superior in every respect. In degrees of hardness, already low, may be reduced by boiling to 3.5. Nitric acid and ammonia, substances always abundant in water contaminated with sewage or decaying animal matter, exist here only in
appreciable amount,
(Signed) Edmund G. Tosh, Ph.D
John Stirling, Esq., Whitehaven.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Stirling, John | | Mine Owner | |
| Tosh, Edmund G. | | | |