Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

23rd February 1867

A Disputed Royalty

John Munroe Mackenzie and Others v John Stirling

This case was tried by a special jury, several of whom had had a view of the locus in quo.

Mr. Quain, Q.C., with whom were Mr. Campbell Foster and Mr. Herschell, appeared for the plaintiff; and Mr. Manisty, Q.C., with whom was Mr. Kemplay, appeared for the defendant.

The declaration stated that the defendant had broken into and entered the mines and veins of ore of the plaintiffs, and took ore out of it. The defendants had pleaded, firstly, not guilty, and secondly, that the goods taken were not the plaintiffs'; and there was an additional plea that a certain trespass had been committed upon the plaintiffs' property by the defendant, and upon the defendant's property by the plaintiffs.

Mr. Quain, in stating the case to the jury, said that the action was brought to try the right to the minerals under an occupation road crossing the farms which would be distinguished as Walker's Crossfield and Dean's Crossfield. The plaintiffs claimed the whole of the road, and the defendant claimed half of where it skirts his property, and the whole of it where his property was situated on both sides. The lane itself was not of very much importance, but it became of importance on account of the minerals under it. The dispute arose in 1865. The Crossfield Iron Ore Company found that at a place a long way from the lane they had trespassed upon the property of Stirling, and had been mining under a portion of it. It was arranged that Mr. Dixon should investigate and arrange the matter. In the course of the investigation it was found that Mr. Stirling had trespassed upon the plaintiff's property, and taken there from 39 tons, and the company had taken from Mr. Stirling 1272 tons.

Hugh Munroe Mackenzie (one of the plaintiffs) was the first witness called. He deposed: In September 1865, we discovered we had made a small trespass on defendant's estate. I saw Mr. Stirling, and mentioned the matter to him. I had a survey made, which almost corresponded with a survey made for Mr. Stirling by Messrs. Wadham and Turner, mining engineers. Mr. Stirling afterwards gave us intimation that he had made a small trespass on our estate. This was intimated to us on the 11th December, 1865. We agreed to leave it to Mr. Dixon to settle the value of the ore we had taken. Mr. Dixon fixed the value at £308 5s, and I sent a cheque for the money. Some weeks afterwards there was a meeting of our company, and I wrote on the 4th of January, 1866, asking for a plan showing the place where the company had trespassed. Their persistent refusal to give me a plan led me to suspect that the trespass must have been under the lane. My brother and I afterwards went over the estate, and our tenant pointed out a gate, but I don't remember whether he said who kept it in repair.

John Munroe Mackenzie, a brother of the first witness, and one of the plaintiffs, was also examined, and gave somewhat similar evidence.

John Alexander Dixon, assistant to Mr. Dixon, mining engineer, Whitehaven, said in February, 1866, he made an examination of the workings under the lane. He made a drawing representing the quantity of ore taken. The gross quantity taken was 1457 tons; the quantity taken beyond the middle line, between hedge and hedge, on the Walker side, 148½ tons. He took one-tenth per stone off to give the quantity of ore, reducing the nett to 1310 tons; and after deducting the 39 tons at the same rate, made the total result to £1,477 7s 6d. This was, however, subject to certain deductions.

Cross-examined by Mr. Manisty: I was sent to check Wadham and Turner's calculation of 39 tons being taken. In the first instance I could not detect any encroachment, taking the boundary as shown on Wadham and Turner's plan. I was then sent to measure from fence to fence, and ascertain the amount taken from under the whole of the road.

Lancelot Mossop, of Crossfield, Henry Bell, butcher, of the same place, and eight other witnesses were examined to prove the absolute occupation of the lane in dispute by the tenants of the Walker Crossfield estate.

This concluded the plaintiff's case.

Mr. Manisty then opened the defendant's case. He described the lane in question as an accommodation lane to three farms. He took it that wherever they found such a lane as this, leading sometimes through one estate, sometimes through two estates, the presumption and the probability, and therefore the law, says the fact must be taken to be that both parties gave up from their lands on each side, a piece of land, which he would call a roadway, in order that it might be used as an accommodation way. He contended that the portion of the lane at the railway end, which was bounded on each side by Dean's property, belonged to that property.

The first witness called was Charles Mossop, of Montreal, Crossfield, the farmer of Mr. Dean's land, who said he had known the property upwards of 50 years. The lane passed through a certain portion of Walker's land on both sides, and then through a portion of Dean's land on both sides. It continued so for a short distance, and then it came to witness's farm again on both sides. Then it came to the railway, and after passing the railway, going towards Crossfield, it continued through witness's farm nearly all the way. He had repaired the fences along his land for 23 years. Whenever the lane passed through his land on both sides he repaired both fences.

William Anderson said he had been in the service of Mr. Charles Mossop 17 years. He and another of Mr. Mossop's men helped to repair the road five years since.

William Harrison, a very deaf old man of 82 years, said a great many years ago he made three gates for the tenants of Montreal Farm. One of the gates was put across the lane at the railway end; another was put about 100 yards further down; and another across the Keekle. He got the wood out of Mr. Dean's land.

This concluded the evidence of the defence, and Mr. Manisty then addressed the jury. He submitted that there was no doubt the lane was Mr. Dean's property, unless he had lost it through encroachment. The learned counsel appealed with confidence to the jury not to take away a man's property upon such ragged evidence as had been brought forward.

Mr. Quain replied on the whole case. He ridiculed Mr. Manisty's argument, and contended that the land in question never did belong to the Dean property. The learned counsel submitted that whilst the defendant had shown no ac's of ownership, the plaintiffs had over and over again not only de-pastured their cattle in the lane, but they had turned other people's cattle out, and closed the gate upon them. In conclusion, he expressed his confidence in the judgement of the jury.

His Lordship, in summing up, carefully summarised the evidence on both sides, briefly commenting on it, and directed the jury to consider whether the evidence of the defendant was sufficient to outweigh the mass of evidence adduced by the plaintiffs, and find a verdict accordingly.

The jury then retired, and after an absence of about a quarter of an hour, returned into court, when the Foreman said: We find a verdict for the defendant; the division of the road to be made between the two fences.

His lordship, considering that the Foreman had made a mistake, inquired if they thought first that the whole of the land in the lane up to the railway end belonged to the plaintiff?

The Foreman replied that they found that the portion of the lane bounded on both sides by Dean's property belonged to Dean, and one-half of the other.

His Lordship: You find that that portion of the land bounded on both sides by Dean's property, belonged to Dean; and only that part which lies between the line drawn half-way between the hedges and Walker's land belongs to Walker.

The Foreman replied that it was so.

His Lordship: Then that is a verdict for plaintiff.

A verdict was accordingly entered for the plaintiff, damages £40 for the minerals.

The case was not concluded until seven o'clock in the evening.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Anderson, William      
Dean, —    Land Owner  
Dixon, —    Mining Engineer  
Dixon, John Alexander    Mining Engineer  
Foster, Cambell    Solicitor  
Harrison, William      
Herschell, —    Solicitor  
Kemplay, —    Solicitor  
Mackenzie, Hugh Munroe    Mine Owner  
Mackenzie, John Munroe    Mine Owner  
Mainsty, —    Q.C.  
Mossop, Charles    Farmer  
Mossop, Lancelot    Butcher  
Quain, —    Q.C.  
Stirling, John    Mine Owner  
Turner, —    Mining Engineer  
Wadham, Edward    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page
Walker, —    Land Owner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Crossfield (Iron Ore)  Crossfield (Iron Ore)
Montreal (Iron Ore)  Montreal (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print