22nd December 1866
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
Sir,
The dreadful colliery explosions which happened on the 12th and 13th inst. are not improbably connected with a rapid fall of the barometer which was proceeding at the time. If so, they are undoubtedly preventible, and lie upon the national conscience.
Considering the dire importance of the subject, you will perhaps allow me to explain the nature of the connexion as far as I can see. I impute blame to no particular persona, and regard the explosions merely as natural events, which may have natural
causes under the average degree of caution observed in coal-pits.
We should remember, in the first place, that two distinct causes are needed to produce an explosion :—
1. The cause which leads to the fouling of the air.
2. The cause which ignites the explosive mixture of gas and air.
These are quite independent. The air may be foul for days without an accident, but the first lamp that is then opened occasions the death of hundreds.
The fall of the barometer is evidently a cause which will lead to the fouling of the air in a pit. For the diminution, of atmospheric pressure which it indicates is felt in the pit just as on the surface, and the consequence is that all inflammable gas
accumulated in crevices of the coal, in goaves in vacant spaces left by the partial fall of the roof, or that possibly which lies by its low specific gravity in cavities of the roof in tranquil, remote parts of the pit, expands slightly. Thus, if the
barometer fall one inch, all accumulations of gas give off one-thirtieth part of their bulk, so that a vast addition may suddenly be made to the ordinary evolution of the gas. Now, ventilating arrangements which may be quite adequate to carry off the gas
in ordinary circumstances, and keep it fully below the exploding point, may be quite inadequate when a sudden addition is made to the inflammable gas evolved.
From the table of the variations of the barometer below it will be seen that between 9 a.m. on Tuesday, the 11th, and 3 p.m. on Thursday, the 13th, the barometer fell one inch. On Wednesday, at 1 p.m., the great explosion at the Oaks occurred ; on
Thursday, at 11 a.m., the second explosion at Tunstall occurred. These two coincidences alone would prove nothing ; but similar coincidences between explosions and falls of the barometer are well known to persons engaged in coalmining to have happened
before. When it is added that the physical connexion or reason of the coincidence is evident, a serious probability arises that we have here the cause of these terrible events.
The subject, however, is not free from some difficulties. I give below a table of the variations of the barometer since the beginning of the month, which has been kindly furnished to me by Mr. Bryan, optician, of Manchester :—
| 1866 | 9 a.m. | | 3 p.m. | 9 p.m. |
| December | Inches | | Inches | Inches |
| Saturday | 1st | 29.85 | | 29.78 | 29.74 |
| Sunday | 2nd | 29.73 | | 29.70 | 29.60 |
| Monday | 3rd | 29.69 | | 29.53 | 29.52 |
| Tuesday | 4th | 29.48 | | 29.44 | 29.57 |
| Wednesday | 5th | 29.70 | | 29.74 | 29.81 |
| Thursday | 6th | 29.84 | | 29.51 | 29.36 |
| Friday | 7th | 29.29 | | 29.32 | 29.70 |
| Saturday | 8th | 30.24 | | 30.37 | 30.45 |
| Sunday | 9th | 30.13 | | 29.89 | 29.84 |
| Monday | 10th | 30.03 | | 30.14 | 30.22 |
| Tuesday | 11th | 30.34 | | 30.31 | 29.13 |
| Wednesday | 12th | 29.76 | * | 29.70 | 29.73 |
| Thursday | 13th | 29.35 | * | 29.35 | 29.34 |
| Friday | 14th | 29.34 | | 29.36 | 29.43 |
| Saturday | 15th | 29.44 | | 29.35 | 29.40 |
| Sunday | 16th | 29.59 | | 29.70 | 29.94 |
| * This mark indicates the occurrence of an explosion. |
It appears that throughout this period the atmosphere has been in a remarkably perturbed condition. There have been four considerable falls of the barometer since the beginning of the month, as follows :—
| 1st, | 9 a.m., to 4th. 3 p.m. | Fall, .42 inch. |
| 6th, | 9 a.m., to 7th, 9 a.m. | .55 |
| 8th, | 9 p.m., to 9th, 9 p.m. | .61 |
| 11th, | 9 a.m., to 13th, 9 p.m. | 1.00 |
The first of these falls of the barometer was comparatively slow and limited. The other three were rapid, and dangerous to coalminers. My difficulty is not that explosions occurred on the last occasion, but that none occurred in the two previous falls.
This is perhaps explained in the case of the third by the fact that it reached its climax on Sunday, the 9th, when there could be but slight chance of the gas becoming exploded. The exact moment of the occurrence of explosions is of course determined by
the moment at which the top of a lamp is taken off, or when a blast or some other accidental cause ignites the gas. It is quite possible, therefore, that the air may become seriously fouled by a fall of the barometer without any explosion occurring, or
that explosions originating in the same fall of the barometer may not happen on the same day.
It may be asked, will not one fall of the barometer so clear the reservoirs of gas that there will be less chance of a second fall having a dangerous result ? The barometer fell lower on the 8th than on the 13th, when an explosion occurred. Ought not the
first fall to have prevented a calamity on the second occasion ? The fact, however, is not so. All depends on the rapidity with which the barometer falls. If the barometer falls very slowly, the inflammable air in all the crevices swells very slowly, and
the ventilation is sufficient to carry the gas off without any great danger. However low the barometer falls, provided it falls slowly, no evil results. But if it rises again and then fall suddenly there is danger. By the rise of pressure a little air is
driven back into the crevices, supposing they are not filled up with new gas evolved from coal. The next fall of the barometer causes as great an outpour of gas as the former, and if sudden the ordinary ventilation of the mine may for the time be quite
inadequate.
Two kinds of precautions are taken in coalpits against explosions :—
1. The guarding of lights, to prevent ignition.
2. Ventilation, to prevent the gas reaching the inflammable point.
It is a maxim among coalminers, or, if it is not, it ought to be, that the second kind of precaution can alone be relied upon. The first kind of precaution is subject to all sorts of accidents beyond human foresight, as well as to all the carelessness of
individuals. It is the very fact that ventilation generally renders a pit secure that makes colliers too confident and reckless in the use of lights. The dangerous conjecture, then, is when some incident like the fall of the barometer interferes to
render the ventilation insufficient. Then an act of carelessness (repeated, perhaps, hundreds of times before with impunity) brings sudden death to hundreds.
Those who employ machine ventilators, like the powerful new one of M. Lemielle, which seems likely to come into use, should observe that, if they too suddenly increase the draught of air from the pit when the barometer is falling, they will only increase
the evil they wish to avoid by still further lowering the pressure of air in the mine.
Now I ask, Sir, are precautions generally taken in coalmines against this obvious tendency of the air to foul during a rapid fall of the barometer ? I know that the barometer is carefully observed in many deep mines ; it ought to be constantly observed
in all mines of any extent and of fiery character. Any viewer who has omitted it hitherto would do well to begin to-morrow, and no more intermit his observations for the future than a cautious sea captain would intermit his observations of the weather
when he was in the region of the typhoons.
Any barometer will do, provided it is not one of the old school barometers. An aneroid barometer would be very convenient, and not liable to breakage. The instrument, however, which I should most recommend would be the sympiesometer, invented by
Adie of Edinburgh, and to be had from all instrument-makers. It acts by measuring the volume of air enclosed in a tube, and thus exactly represents the expansions and contractions of the gas in the crevices. The instrument would thus serve to
indicate and explain to the under-viewers and others the necessity of caution. A good sympiesometer placed in the mine and a barometer in the office at the bank would be sufficient. Observations should be made the first thing in the morning on entering
the pit, and at noon, and, perhaps, 6 p.m. The observer need only watch for a sudden fall in the barometer, and when
That is occurring he should cause a very careful examination of the mine to be made, and the men at once should be withdrawn from any part of the mine where unusual symptoms of fire-damp are observed. It does not matter whether the barometer be high or
low, provided it be stationary, or rising, or only slowly falling.
I should like to know in how many collieries the new instrument of Mr. Ansdell, founded on the discoveries of Mr. Graham, the Master of the Mint, is used for detecting the presence of fire-damp. £15 or £20 would furnish the
largest colliery with abundance of barometers, sympiesometers, and fire-damp indicators, and their observations would be a pleasure rather than a trouble or an expense to any intelligent viewer or under-viewer. And yet a little niggardliness and a great
deal of stupidity inherent in the English character may cause the neglect of all such precautions, and may lead to catastrophes which weigh upon the conscience of the nation.
Coalowners are fond of assuring us that we need to be under no apprehensions of a want of coal, for they can easily sink to any depth, and work any number of square miles of country from a single shaft. Have they all of them clear consciences ? Have they
all of them adopted the latest and most efficient means for ventilating their mines and detecting danger ? If not, I wonder that they can sleep in their beds at night for thinking of the heaps of blackened corpses in the burning pit, and the villages
full of orphaned children and widows.
Yours obediently,
W.S.J.
~ An explosion occurred at Bolton at 2 p.m. on Monday afternoon, but it was caused by an accidental discharge of gas, and had no connexion with the barometer, which was rising.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Adie, — | | | |
| Ansdell, — | | | |
| Bryan, — | | | |
| Graham, — | | | |