Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

13th December 1866

The Caldbeck Fells Lead and Copper Mining Company

(By Our Own Reporter)

The adjourned meeting of the shareholders of this company was held yesterday, at Wigton. It will be recollected that at the meeting on the 17th November, it was announced that the secretary had absconded with some of the funds, and a committee of investigation was appointed, a resolutions being passed at the same time for the transference of the business of the Board of Directors from London to Wigton. The latter resolute, it appears, is strongly resented in London, from which there were several gentlemen present at the meeting yesterday. Sir Robert Brisco took the chair, and amongst those present were the Hon. F. Drummond, Mr. Forkes, barrister, Mr. H. L. Phillips, Mr. R. Davis, Mr. Powell, and Mr. C. A. Powell, of London; William Banks, Esq., Highmoor House; Dr. Cowan, London; Mr. R. B. Brockbank, Carlisle; Dr. Tiffen, Wigton; Mr. Kenyon and Mr. Walker, Maryport; Mr. Crosthwaite, Workington; Mr. P. Iredale, Mr. James Irving, Mr. S. G. Saul, Carlisle; Captain Kitto, late superintendent of the mine, & co.

The report of the committee of investigation, which had been already printed and circulated, was taken as read. We select a few of the more salient passages: -

"Your committee having visited the Roughten Gill Mines find the lodes above the adit, which are all that have hitherto been worked, are regular in their produce and abound in a considerable variety of ores of lead and copper. The main bunches are at considerable distances from each other, and there are poor unproductive portions of the lodes through which the levels have to be driven to arrive at the more valuable parts. This is necessarily slow work, and as the distances are considerable, air shafts are required to be sunk between the levels for ventilation, before the ores can be extracted freely by stopping. Although large discoveries of ores have been made during the 18 months working of the company, and about £18,000 have been spent upon the mine and agencies, we find, after the most careful inquiry, that this part of the mine above the adit is not likely to make returns sufficient to pay dividends on the amount of capital now embarked in the undertaking. It is clear to us that in order to insure the large and regular returns required to pay dividends, a considerable amount of capital must still be spent in developing the mine above the 90 fathoms, and in opening it out below. We are of opinion that below the adit the deposits of ore will be found much richer than those above, and our directors having prudently obtained the extension of lease to 50 years, we think that the engines and engine shafts should be pushed forward with all speed consistent with economy. With respect to the plant which is described in the prospectus as worth £8000, we find that when it was handed over to this company £500 or £600 was much nearer its value, and that it was in such a bad stated of repair as to be of little use, and it has since been nearly all replaced by new crushing and dressing machinery at a considerable cost.

"At Dry Gill little has been done, and that chiefly on the shallow levels. We would recommend that the deeper level be driven on at once, and that a tramway be provided, as the present mode of wheeling it quite unsuited to the mine."

"On reference to the statement of accounts and report by Mr. Lainton, the accountant, appointed by your committee, it will be seen that there are outstanding debts to the amount of £1700; there is also £3000 still unpaid for the extended lease, and £3220 will be required to complete the engines."

"As the mine is not at present paying cost, we would recommend the directors to male an immediate call of 5s per share, which we think is the least that will place the mine in a satisfactory financial position. Your committee may here express their satisfaction at the admirable manner in which Mr. Lainton has fulfilled the duty entrusted to him."

"We find the proceedings of the directors to have been of an extremely unsatisfactory character, inasmuch as they never seem to have worked well together. We have many instances of proceedings being agreed to at meetings of country and London Directors, which have been annulled or rescinded at subsequent meetings, held shortly after, by two or three of the London Directors."

"We find the seats of Mr. Bindley and Mr. Fawkes vacated, on account of arrears of calls, and we recommend the directors to fill them up with men of undoubted standing and business ability."

"We are please to be able to inform the shareholders the Sir R. Brisco, Dr. Cowan, Mr. Banks, Mr. Rummens, receive their fees as directors, dating from the last payment, until such time as the mine may be got into a satisfactory state."

"We cannot too strongly condemn a practice, which appears to have prevailed with some of the London directors, of signing cheques in an irregular manner. On the 5th April, 1865, at a Board meeting, attended by seven directors, it was resolved that no cheque be signed unless ordered by the Board, and 'Payable to order.' In spite of this, we find one case in which Mr. Fawkes and Mr. Bindley, on 12th July, signed a cheque (not at a Board meeting, and without making any minute thereof), nominally for Oatey and Co. 'Payable to bearer,' which was handed to the secretary, and by him converted into cash, and forms part of the £800 deficiency against him.

"We recommend this matter to be placed in the hands of the company's solicitor, and, if recoverable by law, they be instructed to take proceedings against these two ex-directors for the amount."

"The acts of Mr. Powning, the late secretary, from the commencement seems to have been of a most unsatisfactory character; his defalcations amount so far as has come to light to about £800. We cannot too severely condemn the manner in which he has been mixed up in the formation of the company, and the extensive manner in which he has dealt in its shares."

"Of the above sum about £270 has been received by him for calls, remitted to him by shareholders, and not credited to them in the company's books. We would here warn shareholders against in future paying calls to any but the company's bankers, who are the only authorised recipients."

"We would recommend the directors to appoint to the office of secretary some on o the undoubted ability and good conduct, and that whoever he may be, he be required to furnish guarantees to the amount of at least £1000."

"The directors seem to have overlooked this with their late secretary. We would strongly recommend that the offices of the company remain in Cumberland."

"Owing to the absconding of the late secretary, who seems to have been extensively mixed up in this, and the difficulty of obtaining information about it, the committee are unable to report so fully as probably the shareholders would desire. There is, however, no doubt that the prospectus contains many glaring false representations. That the mines produced large amount, of ore to previous lessees is without doubt, but that they ever paid £2000 per annum, continuously, is extremely problematical. The price paid for them, namely £10,000 in cash and £10,000 in shares, is preposterous. We are of the opinion that £10,000 was their extreme value."

"The committee regret to find that although it is expressly stated in the prospectus that there was no promotion money, such was not the case, and that considerable amounts were received, in shares, &c., by certain of the London section of the directors and officials."

Dr. Cowan moved the adoption of the report, which was seconded by Mr. Kenyon, when Mr. Fawkes entered into a long personal defence of the charges brought against him, complaining principally that before the issue of the report he had never been called upon for any explanation.

Mr. Davis, of London, proposed as an amendment; "That the report of the Committee of Investigation is partial, ill-considered, and in may particulars shown to be incorrect, and therefore that it be not adopted. That in the opinion of the meeting Mr. Fawkes is still a director of the company, and that the vacancy created by Mr. Bindley having disqualified himself for a seat at the Board, be immediately filled up."

This was seconded by Mr. Phillips, also of London, in a very energetic speech and after a very warm debate, in which considerable feeling was shown, the amendment was put to the meeting, and lost on a show of hands by 16 to 6. — Mr. Fawkes then handed in a large number of proxies; whilst on behalf of the northern proprietary, there was still a bulkier roll.

A scrutiny was proceeding, scarcely likely to be concluded that evening, at the time our parcel was despatched.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Banks, William      
Brisco, Robert, Sir    Chairman  
Brockbank, R. B.      
Cowan, —, Dr.      
Crosthwaite, —      
Davis, R.      
Drummond, H., Hon.      
Forkes, —    Barrister  
Iredale, P.      
Irving, James      
Kenyon, —      
Kitto, —    Mine Captain  
Lainton, —    Accountant  
Phillips, H. M.      
Powell, —      
Powell, C. A.      
Powning, —      
Rummens, —      
Saul, S. G.      
Tiffen, —, Dr.      
Walker, —      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Drygill Mine (Lead Ore)  Drygill Mine (Lead Ore)
Roughtongill Mine (Lead Ore)  Roughtongill Mine (Lead Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print