Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

29th November 1866

A Cumberland Mining Company In Difficulties

The half-yearly general meeting of the shareholders in the Caldbeck Fells Consolidated Lead and Copper Mining Company (Limited) was held at the King's Arms Hotel, Wigton, on Wednesday to receive the report of the directors, and a statement of accounts to the 30th of October last, and for the general business of the company. There was a large attendance, the London interest being fully represented. The chair was taken by Sir Robert Brisco, Bart, Crofton Hall (chairman of the company). Amongst those present were Mr. Banks, Highmoor House; Dr. Cowan, Edinburgh; Mr. Phillips, London; Mr. Rummens, London; Mr. Vaughan, Edmond Castle; Mr. Glen, Melrose; Mr. Davis, London; Mr. S. Saul, Carlisle; Mr. F. Walker, Maryport; Mr. James Irving, Carlisle; Mr. Ward, London; Mr. H. Bewes, Wigton; Mr. Brockbank, Carlisle; Dr. Tiffen, Wigton; Mr. Fawkes, London; Mr. Bell, Elmond Castle; Mr. Nicholson, Whitehaven; Mr. T. Crosthwaite, Maryport, &c, &c.

The Chairman said that he regretted to say that the force of circumstances obliged him to take upon him the duties of secretary, and to have read the notice calling the meeting. He had a painful duty to go through; he had to explain to them the reason why the directors had come there so unprepared. They had no report and no statement of accounts to lay before them, because their secretary had not prepared any. It was under these circumstances very difficult for him to explain matters to them, so that their minds might follow him, and understand the position of the company. He should however lay before them as much information as the directors possessed themselves. They would be aware that Mr. Powning was the secretary to the company. His conduct as secretary had not on many points been satisfactory to them, but his conduct of late had brought things to a crisis. The directors had arranged to have meetings in order to prepare the report, and agreed to have a final meeting to go into the accounts and prepare the report, but when they met the secretary was not there to meet them. As if to throw them off their guard, he sent word that he was unwell. In a day of two however he set off, and they did not know where he was. All his books and papers were seized by two of the directors. Previous to this other books and papers belonging to another company had been sized by the directors, and all were given in charge of a legal gentleman. The Chairman said he thought it was right that they should hear the minutes which had been made by the directors at their meeting in London, and read the various minutes over. At their last meeting it was resolved to adjourn until the 21st of November, to the meeting of the shareholders to be held at Wigton. The secretary had been ordered to request the agents to furnish a report of the prospects of the mine to prepare for the report, but this was not done. At their meeting, on the 7th November, the directors found that they were sundry accounts owing which they wished to have paid, and as there was a cheque just come in from Messrs. Cook and Co. for £305 they agreed that they should be paid, and handed over to their secretary with cheques for the amounts. These cheques had however been returned dishonoured, and it seemed that the cheque for £305 — which they expected to have had to their credit in the bank — had not been paid in. They had not examined all the accounts yet, but they feared that there were other irregularities, defalcations, and unaccounted for cheques. Having said this much, the Chairman said he should now consider their present position, future prospects, and financial state.

As to the mine, it was to the best of his belief and knowledge a most admirable one. (Hear, hear.) Like everything else, however, if badly managed, it was no better than a bad one. He feared they had far too much expense connected with it. He thought Cumberland mines would never pay to be managed like the Cornish mines. They ought to be managed cheaply. The Cornish captain of their mines had decided that it was desirable to open the lower levels of the mine, and they had got an engine for that purpose, but they ought to take into consideration whether it would pay to raise the ore from so great a depth, and if they had the means to do it. Also, if the expense could not be spared, and ore got at a cheaper rate than they were doing. (Hear, hear.) There was strong presumptive evidence that there was a great deal of ore about this lower level they were opening out, and this would be got much more cheaply than when it was below the water level as it required no water pumping out. Every ton of ore that they brought from the lower depth cost them just twice as much as that got from above. If that was the case, the question was whether they should not work it above. The mine was now ready to have money expended upon it. Now, that was the position of the company with regard to the mine. He suggested that they should have a committee on the spot to look after it. Speaking of what the mine was doing, the Chairman said the receipts for last month for ore sold were over £800 and for the previous month nearly £900. What was their financial position? Their bank-books showed that their assets were nil, except £2 or £3, and there was a month's pay due to the men. They expected to have a tender for some ore, and they might thus get a little more money. There was also a bill due at three months from the date of delivery of the ore, for about £900, and this was all they had to look to, except the payment of arrears from shareholders. [In answer to a question from one of the shareholders, it was explained that the amount required per month was about £900. This was also altogether, both for current expenses, and expenses which were chargeable to capital account.] This, said the Chairman, appeared to be the financial position of the company, so far as their paid-up capital was concerned, but there was a large sum of arrears for the unpaid-up calls, which it was impossible to calculate, owning to the bad state of their secretary's books. He thought, however, it might amount to about £3000. He thought the main point for them to consider was what was the best line of action for them to pursue under the circumstances. Then they must take measures after whatever decision the meeting might come to. Under the circumstances in which they were placed, the Board was placed in the greatest possible difficulties, and this had rendered it an arduous task for them to appear before the shareholders. Speaking of the management of the business of the mine, the Chairman said they had had a Board in London, and they had tried a committee on the spot; and they had decided that they never would have their interests properly attended to unless they had a Board here near to the mine. They could not look after the mine so well at a distance as they could on the spot, as they could not pay that close attention to it which it required. On the spot the mine could be examined, and on the spot everything was under the control of the Board, if they were locally constituted. The difficulties of a Board in London, and a management on the spot, were very great. They could never expect to get directors in Cumberland who would go up to London, perhaps once or twice a week, to attend the meetings of a London Board; and between the two difficulties the interests of the concern were lost. The Chairman said he had prepared one or two resolutions which he read. [They are in substance given below.] One of the minutes referred to Mr. Vercoe, late one of the captains of the mine, who had been forbidden to go near it, or he would be treated as a trespasser. The concern was in all respects in a most deplorable state; they did not know in what position they stood, and they must now take upon themselves the duty of looking into matters themselves, and seeing for themselves what could be done. (Applause.)

After some discussion, the Chairman said it would be requisite that they should adjourn that meeting to give time to a committee which ought to be appointed to investigate the state of the concern to prepare their report. He must again repeat to them that they must take up the question as to where the Board ought to be placed, also, where their registered office ought to be; and they must take immediate actions as to their financial position, as they must not allow the cheques which were out to go about dishonoured. — Mr. Brockbank, in answer to some portions of the minutes read by the Chairman, said that he had engaged Mr. Vercoe, as a disinterested party, to pay a visit to the mine to see in what state it was, and wished to know if a shareholder had a right to go himself to the mine, and send any one he thought proper to examine it. He thought the shareholders ought to be allowed the privilege. — The Chairman said that the company had thought it proper to dismiss Mr. Vercoe, and he was not the proper person to send to make a report for Mr. Brockbank. Otherwise the directors could have no objection to any shareholder either going to the mine or sending a person to examine it. — Mr. Brockbank asked how it was that in the prospectus, which was first issued it was stated that the mine was making £2000 as year, while now they had not sold £2000 worth in three years. — The Chairman said that it was through Mr. Vercoe's statement that the prospectus stated that £2000 as year was being made. It was possible that they had made £2000 in one year by taking only the finest ore.

Mr. Banks said that Mr. Bindley, one of the directors, had been convinced that £2000 a year was being made at the time the mine was purchased. It was very likely that it was by "picking the eyes," as it was termed. — The Chairman said that they did not intend to continue the system of "picking the plums out if the pudding." They were working to get all the ore out they could to be ready for their new crushing machinery, and much time was being consumed in taking it out.

Mr. Brockbank said he had inquired of the captains of the mine, and found that they were only getting £6 to £7 per ton for the ore. Now, he was one of the old shareholders of the mine, and had experience in sampling ores for 25 years, and they had always realised from £13 to £14 per ton, so that when he found this he thought he was justified in sending a man to look into matters. — The Chairman said Mr. Brockbank was quite justified in doing what he did; the only thing was the means he employed in carrying it out. As to the price realised for the ore, they had been using up a quantity of common ore, and besides this they could not get the ore into of fine a condition through their not having the proper machinery yet in working order. Now they were making £13 or £14 per ton.

A Shareholder asked how long these defalcations of the secretary had been going on, and for how long back the books were in an irregular state. — Mr. Fawkes explained at some length how it was that Mr. Powning's irregularities were first discovered. He (Mr. Fawkes) was a shareholder in the Frontine and Bolivia Mining Company, of which Mr. Powning was their secretary, and from something he had found out, he caused the books to be seized, and given in charge of a solicitor. This led to inquiries, and it was found that the books of the Caldbeck Company were in a bad state, so they were also taken charge of. — The Chairman said it was on the 13th November when the irregularities were first noticed, but they did no know for how long back they extended, until they had examined the books. — Mr. Fawkes said that Mr. Powning had actually sent out circulars to those shareholders who were in arrears to pay the amount of arrears to him, and not to the bank, as the directors had ordered. It appeared that he had two kinds of circulars, one a correct one, and one in which he was to have the money paid to him. The directors could not therefore say who were in arrears and who were not. — Mr. Rummens, as a director, said that he could say positively that the Board never authorised the sending out a circular to pay the money to the secretary. — The circular was produced at the meeting, and handed round. Some of those present said that the circular they had received was quite different.

Mr. Davis said that he was an unfortunate to shareholder in the three companies of which Mr. Powning had been secretary, namely, the Caldbeck Fells Mining Company, the Frontier and Bolivia, and Penhale and Lomax Companies. All of these concerns would be sufferers by their secretary. He (Mr. Davis) had come down from London to attend the meeting, and to move a resolution which he thought would be useful, but he was glad that their excellent Chairman had rendered it unnecessary for him to do so, having forestalled him. He had intended to move that a committee of investigation be appointed to examine the books, and to thoroughly investigate the affairs of the concern, and then lay a report before the shareholders. It gave him great pleasure to hear that the Chairman already proposed this himself, as it relieved him from what he feared might be looked upon as showing a doubt of the management of the directors, but now when one of their own body moved it, no such idea could exist. ("No, no" from several shareholders.) There had certainly been horrible mismanagement on the part of their secretary. In one of the companies referred to they actually found that Mr. Powning had made a call upon the shareholders entirely on his own responsibility. Mr. Davis concluded by mentioning the Hon. Mr. Drummond and Mr. Phillips as members of the committee — more to be added by the meeting. — The Chairman said it would be better to have a local committee, as they could look into the state of affairs very much more easily than a committee in London could do. (Hear, hear.) There were a great many shareholders in the neighbourhood, and it was only right their interests should be represented. — Mr. Fawkes said that at all events the London shareholders should have a voice in the matter; more than half the shares were held by London men, and the concern was launched in London.

Dr. Cowan thought that full powers should be given to the committee which might be appointed by that meeting, to inquire into the origin of the company, and the duties of the committee should comprehend a searching inquiry into whether any "promotion money" was paid at the time the company was formed. He was the largest shareholder in the concern, and did not fear but it would ultimately pay, but the committee should try to reduce the expenses as much as possible. They had paid £20,000 for the mine, and he had heard that as much as £10,000 of that went for "promotion money." — Mr. Banks said he had been told by one gentleman in London that he had got 300 shares for promoting the company. — Mr. Fawkes said he knew the gentleman very well, as a most honourable man, and the 300 shares were all he had for his work and expenses when the company was formed. — The Chairman said that when he was asked to be the chairman of the company, he was told that £20,000 was the sum that was paid to the proprietor of the mine. If he had known that any sum was to be paid for promoting the company he should have washed his hands of it altogether. (Hear, hear.) The Chairman then proposed the following resolution:- "That a Committee of Investigation be formed to inquire into the position of the company."

Mr. Glen (of Melrose), who had asked two or three times to be heard, asked if it was true, as he had seen in the mining newspapers, that a discovery had been made in the mine of a quantity of ore of the estimated value of £100,000. If this were true it might tend to send the shareholders home in better spirits. — The Chairman said Mr. Glen was not in order, as they had formal business to go through. — The resolution was then put to the meeting and carried unanimously.

Dr. Tiffen moved that these shareholders who had not paid up their calls should not be eligible to act upon the committee. — This was seconded, when an amendment was proposed to the effect that the committee might be composed of any shareholders, whether they were in arrears or not. The resolution was carried by a large majority, the Chairman remarking that it did not so much matter who were on the committee; after all the great thing would be to have an accountant. The following gentleman were appointed as the committee: — Sir Robert Brisco, Bart, Crofton Hall; W. Banks, Esq., Highmoor House; Dr. Tiffen, Wigton; Mr. Brockbank, Carlisle; and Mr. James Irving, Carlisle. It was suggested that Mr. Laington, of Maryport, be appointed as accountant; but it was agreed that this should be left to the committee to decide upon. Some of the London shareholders thought they ought to have a London accountant, as the London shareholders would have no confidence in an accountant down here. It was proposed "That the committee investigate the affairs of the company, and report thereon, for the information of the shareholders, and send a copy of the report to each shareholder; and that the committee be empowered to engage a competent accountant to act along with Mr. Lang (the assistant secretary to Mr. Powning) in going over and examining the books of the company."

Dr. Tiffen proposed that the registered office of the company be removed to Wigton. It was necessary that they should be a registered office at once, and he thought it would be much the best plan to have one at Wigton, which was near to the mine. This was agreed to, and it was resolved that in the meantime the books and papers be handed over to Mr. Banks, and that his office be registered as the office of the company. — Mr. Rummens said that some action should be taken with regard to their late secretary. Nothing had been done, and something should be to endeavour to bring to justice. There were some deflections he was certain, and there were other sums which were unaccounted for. — Some opinions were expressed that the secretary was still the secretary of the company, and so it was resolved that he be formally dismissed from the company's service. — Dr. Tiffen said he presumed that the action of the directors would not, in the meantime, be suspended, but that they would still go on with working the mine. — The Chairman said of course they would proceed as they had been doing. They would be receiving a sufficient sum of money shortly which would enable them to go on for a little time.

It was resolved to adjourn the meeting until the 12th December next; the meeting to be held at the King's Arms Hotel. — A vote of thanks to the Chairman concluded the proceedings, which lasted about four hours.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Banks, —      
Bell, —      
Bewes, H.      
Bindley, —      
Brisco, Robert, Sir    Chairman  
Brockbank, —      
Cowan, —, Dr.      
Crosthwaite, —      
Fawkes, —      
Irving, James      
Nicholson, —      
Philips, —      
Powning, —    Secretary  
Rummens, —      
Saul, S.      
Tiffen, —, Dr.      
Vercoe, —      
Walker, F.      
Ward, —      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print