4th October 1866
An Isle Of Man Mining Case In Chancery — Judgement
During five days of last week an Isle of Man mining case occupied the attention of Vice-Chancellor Malins, in the Chancery Court, Lincoln's inn, and on Tuesday afternoon the judgement in it was given. The plaintiffs were Chas. Saxelby, John Edwards, and
Christopher Hicks; and the defendants were the Great Mona Mining Company (Limited), James Ashe, Henry Johnson, and Leslie Lockhart.
There was a formidable array of counsel on both sides, namely, Mr. Glasse, Q.C, and Mr. Danney for the plaintiff; Mr. Locock Webb for the company; Mr. Kay, Q.C, and Mr. Eddis for Mr. Ashe; Mr. Osborn Morgan for Johnson and Lockhart; and Mr. Archbold
Smith for the official assignee.
Extracting from a multiplicity of details the following appeared to be the facts of the case:— Mr. Saxelby is a woollen draper of Shrewsbury; Mr. Edwards is an accountant, of Shrewsbury; and Mr. Hicks is a solicitor of Shrewsbury. On the 5th
December, 1863, a lease was made between the Hon. James Kenneth Howard, the Commissioner of Woods and Forests, to whom the management and direction of the land revenues of the Crown in the Isle of Man had been assigned, and John Boulton, of Grey-street,
Liverpool, of the mines, minerals, and mineral substances which might be found within, under, or upon a certain piece of land situate in the parish of Moughold, in the Isle of Man, and containing about 7,000 acres. The lease was for twelve months, but
with liberty under certain circumstances to have it extended for 21 years, and it was granted to John Boulton as a trustee for the defendant James Ashe, of Norfolk House, Greenbah, Isle of Man. The two other defendants, Henry Johnson and Leslie
Lockhart, afterwards acquired by arrangement with James Ashe some beneficial share or interest with him in the lease. After the lease was granted mining operations were commenced by Ashe, Johnson, and Lockhart, and a mine having been discovered on the
land, they entered into negotiations with a Mr. Ralph Howard and others with the view to forming a joint stock company to be called "The East Laxey Mining Company (Limited)," for the purpose of purchasing and working the mining rights. In this
way expense was incurred, and Mr. Howard acquired a lien or charge upon the lease. The intended company was never formed. In May, 1864, the defendants applied to the plaintiff, Christopher Hicks, to get up a company, and he and his co-plaintiffs agreed
to endeavour to do so. It was then arranged that the promoters of the intended East Laxey Mining Company should relinquish their undertaking, and give up the lease upon being paid the outlay and expense incurred by them. It was also agreed that the
plaintiffs, in the event of there succeeding in forming such a company, were to be entitled to certain remuneration for their trouble, and that in the event of their not forming a company the plaintiffs should have a lien or charge upon the mine and the
lessees' interest under the lease for all moneys which they might advance in relation to the premises. On the 30th of August, 1864, while the plaintiffs were engaged in their attempt to form the company, they, at the request of Ashe, Johnson, and
Lockhart, paid to Mr. Ralph Howard the sum of £507 9s 2d, the amount of his lien upon the lease and thereupon the lease come into their possession, and the term of it was extended by the Crown to 21years. The plaintiffs were unable to form the
company, but the defendants succeeded in forming one — namely, the Great Mona Mining Company (Limited) and that was duly incorporated, with a nominal capital of £25,000 in 5000 shares of £5 each. Johnson and Lockhart became two of its
directors. Previous to and after its formation the plaintiffs made frequent applications to the defendants for payment of the moneys which had become due to them upon their security, but this claim has hitherto remained wholly unsatisfied. The prayer
of the petition now was, that it might be declared that the plaintiffs were entitled to a lien upon the mine for the amount paid by them.
Vice-Chancellor Malins delivered judgement. He thought that Mr. Ashe had granted a lien, that that the gentleman's defence to the suit had caused an unwarrantable waste of time, and that his defence was a dishonest one. Therefore he should fulfil his
lien and pay the costs. Johnson and Lockhart had also most improperly defended the suit, and they must pay the costs as against them. If the whole three of these defendants failed in the performance of their duty, then there would be a lien by the
plaintiffs against the Great Mona Mining Company.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Ashe, James | | | |
| Boulton, John | | | |
| Danney, — | | | |
| Eddis, — | | | |
| Edwards, John | | Accountant | |
| Glasse, —, Q.C. | | | |
| Hicks, Christopher | | Solicitor | |
| Howard, James Kenneth, Hon. | | | |
| Howard, Ralph | | | |
| Johnson, Henry | | | |
| Kay, —, Q.C. | | | |
| Lockhart, Leslie | | | |
| Malins, Richard, Sir | | Vice-Chancellor | |
| Morgan, Osborne | | | |
| Saxelby, Charles | | Woolen Draper | |
| Smith, Archbold | | | |
| Webb, Locock | | | |