|
19th July 1866 Important Colliery Inquest at EllenboroughAn adjourned inquest was held at the old school-house, Ellenborough, on Monday, before Mr. Howson, deputy coroner, and a respectable jury, on the bodies of Benjamin and Thomas Varty, brothers, who were so severely burnt, on the 18th ultimo., by an explosion in the Dearham Out gang Pit, the property of Messrs Walker, of Maryport, that they both died. Mr. Atkinson, the Government inspector of mines for Durham, was in attendance. Isaac Dixon, engineer, deposed that deceased were coal haggers at Lonsdale Pit. On Saturday evening, the 17th ultimo., Ben came into the engine-house for a light, and witness understood his brother was waiting at the pit top to go down. Cautioned him, and told him not to go down into that place unless he had got a lamp. He said he left it clear of gas on Saturday night at half past six. He had no lamp, but an open lighted candle. Witness lowered him down, because he promised to go and get a few tubs out of his uncle James's place. Did not know anything was wrong till about twenty minutes after, when a signal came from the bottom of the shaft to lower the cage, and when it came up it contained the brothers Thomas and Benjamin Varty. There was no hooker-on at the bottom, nor any banksman at the top, as they draw no coals at nights. He believed there was a rule requiring them to be present when any person was let down. By the Inspector: I have not seen a rule requiring that no man is to be lowered in the cage without a distinct order from the banksman. Examination resumed: When the two men came up he saw they were both burned, and Dr. Thompson was sent for, and attended them immediately. None of the men who went down the pit were overmen or deputies, nor had any been down on the Sunday from the time witness went to work, and he told the deceased this. The deputy or overman was not in the habit of going down, and he had no orders to not to let men down till some deputy or overman had gone down. George Tinnion said he took the injured men into his house after the accident, where they were attended to by his wife. Robert Nixon, manager at the Lonsdale Pit: I have managed these collieries for twenty years. I am acquainted with the rules of the colliery. I produce a printed copy, dated 1856, and I was informed these rules had the sanction of Mr. Dunn. I have adhered to them as strictly as possible. George Nixon is the overman in Lonsdale Pit. I may have had a copy signed by Mr. Dunn, but I know these rules were approved by Mr. Dunn in 1856. Thomas Steel and Henry Lightfoot are deputies to George Nixon in the ten-quarter district, where this accident happened. These rules were given out to the men, and one was posted at the pit top. On the night of the 17th of June they did not examine the pit, as it is not worked till after Sunday. The accident occurred at the extremity of the heading at the ten-quarter district. This part of the pit was well ventilated by an air-shaft and furnaces, and the air was very good. Orders had been given not to let any one down without a lamp. I gave these orders on the 21st May verbally to deceased and some others, as they were then working with their lamp-tops off. They said they had lamps at home. We have no lamp-locker nor lamp-shop, nor any supply of lamps, as this is the only working with fire. I was not aware that there was any rule requiring some one to be appointed to see the lamps locked. I never appointed a deputy to go down and examine the working before any one else was allowed to go down the pit. Mr. T. Walker (one of the owners): I have always given orders to Robert Nixon to send down a deputy where there was any appearance of fire-damp, and I don't know why this has not been done on this occasion, except that pitmen are so excessively careless in these matters. George Nixon, overman in Lonsdale Pit for the last thirteen years: It is not a fiery pit; there has been fire in odd places. Safety lamps have not been used except by the man who went in first to view the workings. We have no regular system of examining the workings before the men go in. The place was not dangerous on Saturday noon when I was there. These men had orders to use safety-lamps, but they were allowed to take the lamp-tops off, but they were never allowed to go in after they had been absent without their lamp-tops on. Thomas Steele, deputy under the Nixon's in Lonsdale Pit, and John Lightfoot, deputy, were examined, and generally corroborated the evidence of the overmen. The inquest was then adjourned till Wednesday, the examination of witnesses having lasted four hours. The inquest was resumed on Wednesday, when George Martin, a miner in the Lonsdale Pit was examined. He said: I considered it quite safe to work with naked lights. I did not consider we were transgressing the law. Robert Nixon, the viewer, has seen us working in this drift with naked lights and said nothing, though it was a fortnight after he had given us orders to work there with safety lamps; and still we were permitted to work on. Joseph Sanham; Robert Nixon ordered us to bring lamps, and forbid us to use naked lights. The deceased did not carry lamps; they used nothing but naked lights. I told them it was dangerous, and often remonstrated with then for their imprudence. John Kirkbride gave evidence to the same effect, and after the examination of some unimportant witnesses, the Coroner summed up. Mr. Howson reflected strongly on the very lax manner in which the several overmen had issued their orders without seeing them carried out, after they knew that fire was in this working, and might accumulate and explode. But this culpable neglect on the part of the overmen and their deputies, though very censurable, did not amount to such criminality as to convict any of them of manslaughter. It was in evidence that the deceased had been repeatedly warned of the danger; and efforts had been made to make the men protect themselves in spite of themselves, — still they rushed into danger. The others working there, who had adopted the cautions suggested, had never created an explosion. The Coroner concluded his very able summing-up by cautioning the jury to divest their minds of anything they might have heard in the village, and confine themselves to the evidence. The juries retired at nine o'clock, and at one o'clock in the morning, the jury on Benjamin returned a verdict of "Accidental Death." The jury on Thomas, composed of six of the former and six others, sat till past six in the morning, and not agreeing, were then dismissed without a verdict; the Coroner binding over the jury, as well as the witnesses in their own recognisances to appear at the next assizes at Carlisle. — Abridged from the Maryport Advertiser.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||