24th February 1866
Stephenson V Carmichael
This was an adjourned case from the last Court, the action having been brought to recover a sum of money alleged by the plaintiff, Robert Stephenson, a miner, to be due to him and others by the defendant, Thomas Carmichael, a mine proprietor, on account
of certain contract work performed by plaintiff. It will be remembered that when the case came on for hearing, it was alleged for the defence, that the "kibbles or bogies" were not full, and that as there were to be seven full
"bogies" to the ton, the contract had not been performed; and it was further alleged that the plaintiff had been paid for all that he had done. The case was therefore adjourned for the production of witnesses to prove that there should be a
specified quantity in each kibble, as the ton understood was not a ton avoir dupois, but a ton royalty. Mr. Paitson appeared for the plaintiff, and Mr. Howson for the defendant. Evidence was called to show that the "bogies" held 11cwt of iron
ore, but the defendant was not able to prove that he had not received that quantity in each "bogie." He had a man there who was bound to check the quantity of ore sent up, or if he had not it was his fault as was alleged on behalf of the
plaintiff. It transpired in the course of the hearing of the case that the defendant had written a letter to the judge since the case was adjourned, which his Honour characterised as very improper. After a good deal of evidence was heard, none of which
bore so directly on the point which required to be settled, as to satisfy his Honour that the work had not been done by the plaintiff and his companions according to their contract, a verdict for the plaintiff was given for the full amount claimed.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Carmichael, Thomas | | Mine Owner | |
| Howson, — | | Solicitor | |
| Paitson, — | | Solicitor | |
| Stephenson, Robert | | Miner | |