1st February 1866
Stephenson and Others V Carmichael
In this case, the plaintiffs, who are miners, sued the defendant, Thomas Carmichael, iron ore proprietor, for £37, work done. Mr. Paitson appeared for the plaintiffs, and the defendant was represented by Mr. Howson. A written contract signed by
the respective parties was put in, showing the plaintiffs had agreed to do certain mining work for the defendant at 6s 9d per ton — seven kibbles to be a ton. It was part of the contract that the defendant should keep the water out of the mine, so
as to enable them to do their work; and as alleged by the plaintiffs, they were to be paid for the loss of shifts occasioned by the water flooding the works. From time to time, fortnightly, the plaintiffs received money on account of their contract; but
no final settlement had been come to, until the termination of the agreement. When the time of settlement came, defendant told plaintiffs that they should only have £2, but to settle the matter, he would give them £10. They, however,
refused to accept the £10, and took proceedings for the recovery of the balance which they alleged to be due. These facts having been proved by the witnesses called by Mr. Paitson, Mr. Howson proceeded to address the court for the defence. In
doing so, he denied that the defendant had ever agreed to pay for the loss of shifts occasioned by the water going into the mine; and that although the large price of 6s 9d was paid to the plaintiffs, they did not fill the kibbles as they had contracted
to do. The ton was not a ton of avoir dupois, but a ton royalty. That he contended ought to weigh 70 cwt.; and each of the kibbles did not weigh 10 cwt each. Consequently, in that respect, they did not perform their contract. Evidence in support of
this statement was called, but his Honour requested still further evidence, to satisfy him that the ton royalty was 70 cwt. As the defendant was not prepared with evidence of this character, the case was adjourned until next Court day, in order that it
might be produced.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Carmichael, Thomas | | Mine Owner | |
| Howson, — | | Solicitor | |
| Paitson, — | | Solicitor | |
| Stephenson, Robert | | Miner | |