31st August 1865
Frivolous Litigation
Mr. Fisher, farmer, Lamplugh, charged William Frears and Thomas Smith, miners, working at Mr. Carmichael's mines, with going over an iron rail, which, he contended they had no right to do; there-by doing damages which he laid at one penny. — Mr.
Webster appeared for the prosecution and Mr. Howson for the defendants. — Mr. Fisher said: I am a farmer, and reside in Lamplugh. There is a common which I farm and have lately enclosed near Mr. Carmichael's mines, which his men are in the habit
of going across as it saves a considerable amount of distance. They have no right to go across it as there is no footpath, and by going over the iron fences they have greatly slackened it, and done a great amount of damage to it. I saw the two men
Frears and Smith going over it that day. I went up to them; Frears said he would not go over it again, but Smith said he had the right to go over. — P.C. Howard said: I am a policeman and reside at Lamplugh. I was set by Mr. Fisher to watch for
trespassers, and saw the two men go over. They slackened the fence and might do a pennyworth of damage. (Laughter.) I heard Smith say he would go over it again. — Mr. Carmichael: I am the lessee of the mines near the common, and have been for
thirteen years. About two years ago Mr. Fisher enclosed the common. My men have always been in the habit of going across, and there was a good broad footpath. Mr. Fisher never told me not to go across although I have gone hundreds of times, and I
believe I have a right granted in my papers for going across. — Cross examined by Mr. Webster: Commenced working the mine about thirteen years ago, and on my oath. Mr. Fisher never told me not to go across. — John Hellons said: I am a miner,
and reside at Lamplugh, and have done for ten years. I know the common in question and have gone over it frequently. There is a broad footpath, and miners have been in the habit of going across ever since I was there. Mr. Fisher never hindered me in
going over. — Mr. Webster then wished to recall his client, but Mr. Howson objected to that, as he (Mr. Webster) had closed his case. — The bench then asked the complainant if he had ever told Mr. Carmichael not to go over, and he answered
that he had frequently. — Mr. Webster said that they did not wish for a very heavy penalty. — The Bench, after a short consultation, fined Smith 20s.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Carmichael, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Fisher, — | | Farmer | |
| Frears, William | | Miner | |
| Hellons, John | | Miner | |
| Howard, — | | Policeman | |
| Howson, — | | Solicitor | |
| Smith, Thomas | | Miner | |
| Webster, — | | Solicitor | |