8th August 1865
The Hematite Deposits Of West Cumberland. - No. V
Some persons who altogether favour the igneous origin of our West Cumberland hematite fancy that the noted concentric, kidney shaped concretions of the ore, and the occurrence of cavities in the mass, are evidences that it flowed into its present
repositories in molten condition. But these phenomena are not, in our humble judgment, the unmistakeable evidences of such a condition of the ore as some suppose. Little is known how these characteristic kidney-like structures are produced. All that
we know is that certain minerals often assume these definite forms. But red hematite is not the only substance, which exhibits these forms; brown hematite (differing from red hematite in having water as one of its component parts), chalcedony (a mineral
belonging to the quartz family), malachite (the green carbonate of copper), and limestone, are also found with these reniform, concretionary developments. But it does not follow that, because we are unacquainted with the precise circumstances under
which these peculiar forms were produced, we are to conclude that they must have been developed when the ore was in a liquid, molten state. The observations of BISCHOFF go to show that these globular forms might take place without the necessity of
entertaining such a view. He noticed in one place that the oxide of iron had been deposited in cavities, to which air had access, in kidney-like forms, resembling brown hematite, from springs with a temperature not higher than 91°Fahr. In this case
the spring, containing the oxide of iron in solution' arose from a boring more than two thousand feet deep. It flowed at the rate of a cubic foot in a second, and formed a considerable deposit of the carbonate of lime and hydrated peroxide of iron
(brown hematite) in an open channel, which had a length of nearly three thousand feet. At the points where the water fell in small cascades, and presented abundant surface of contact with the atmosphere, by which the escape of carbonic acid and the
higher oxidation of the iron was facilitated, the deposit had, at the time BISCHOFF saw it, a height of nearly three feet, and yet only five years had elapsed since the discharge commenced. [See BISCHOFF'S Works, vol. 1; translated by the Cavendish
Society.] Then what becomes of the igneous theory, in the face of these facts noticed by an observer so acute and so learned?
As to the supposition of cavities in the ore favouring the notion of its once igneous condition, this is perhaps not so untenable as the one just noticed. It is true that cavities are found in crystalline bodies which were evidently once in a state of
igneous fusion, but it is equally true that cavities are found in minerals whose formation arises from deposition from solution in water at a temperature not much lighter than our ordinary temperature. But there is a marked difference, as Mr. SORBY of
Sheffield has clearly shown, between cavities formed in bodies formerly in a melted condition and those formed in rocks of an aqueous origin; the former being stone or glass, or both water and stone or glass cavities, while the latter are cavities
containing water. Now the cavities in our red hematite seem to be of the same kind as the fluid cavities in limestone and some other aqueous deposits, and hence the theory of the genuine igneous origin of our red ore becomes, in our estimation,
improbable.
But we return to the question previously proposed, " Whence are those vast bodies of ore, found in this locality, derived?" This question, perhaps, can never be answered with certainty, but the probability is that our hematite is
derived, as we before intimated, partly from the decomposition of the older rocks and partly from volcanic eruptions. That the hematite had, in some measure, its origin from volcanic influences seems not unlikely; for the formation of lodes of iron by
sublimation may sometimes be observed going on at the present time in the fissures of the volcanic mountains. "Thus for instance," says the Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal, published a few years ago, "during an eruption of
Vesuvius in 1817, a fissure of more than three feet in diameter was filled within the space of ten days with specular iron ore, deposited from the vapour of chloride of iron evolved." Judging from certain phenomena in the Silurian and carboniferous
formation, we may suppose that volcanic eruptions were not rare occurrences during these periods, we may reasonably suppose also that the chloride of iron not only found its way into the fissures of the rocks, but, likewise, into the waters of the globe.
As some of our readers may wish to know the opinions of some of our eminent geologists on the subject under consideration, we beg to inform them that Mr. BINNEY, of Manchester, a geologist of acknowledged reputation, believes that all iron ores have had
their origin from volcanoes, however much they have since been mingled with the superficial crust of the globe and the waters upon it. He says, "The chloride of iron from volcanoes in ancient times, when there was most probably, much less dry land
than at present on the earth's surface, would more frequently flow into the waters of the sea than remain in the fissures of the rocks. Now, the chloride of iron might be ejected in at least three different ways: first, it might be ejected dry into the
atmosphere, in which case chlorine and the peroxide of iron would result; next, it might be ejected with vapour of water, in which case muriatic acid and peroxide of iron would be formed; and, thirdly, it might be ejected into water, having lime, either
in solution or as a deposit. In this case, the lime would take the chlorine, and throw down the peroxide of iron, leaving chloride of calcium in solution." He further observes, that no one, after carefully examining the beds of hematite in the
vicinity of Whitehaven, can scarcely doubt but that they had their origin in volcanic vents, and flowed into the waters of the sea, where they were deposited with the argillaceous (clayey) and siliceous (flinty) impurities found associated with them,
layer by layer, like any other substance thrown down from suspension. Mr. HUNT, of the Museum Economic Geology, in a recent number of the Practical Mechanics' Journal, thus writes respecting the same subject:— "From whatever source the
ores at Whitehaven and Ulverstone may have been derived, there are indications which show that they had a common origin; the probability being that oxide of iron, which existed in rocks, possibly much older than those in which the ore is now found, was
dissolved out by carbonic acid in water and held in solution so long as there was an excess of that acid, or of vegetable matter undergoing decomposition, and thus producing it. When, however, ferruginous water, lost by exposure its carbonic acid, the
iron would become oxidised on its surface, and be deposited as a peroxide in the state in which we find it."
It will be perceived that while Messrs. BINNEY and HUNT differ as to the source of our hematite, the one attributing it to volcanic influences, and the other tracing it to the decomposition of the older rocks, they agree in regarding it as a deposit from
water. And this is the light in which we view it: believing that the ore did not flow into the caverns or chasms of the limestone in a molten condition, but was carried therein by water, being held in solution, and then, when the necessary conditions of
its deposit arose, it was thrown down as a peroxide, as we now find it. It may have undergone several chemical changes before it assumed its present state; for the salts of iron are very numerous and susceptible of a variety of alterations. You find
iron in one condition in a bed of deposit and you find it in another condition in a mass of granite. Here it is red hematite and there it is brown hematite. Here the carbonate of iron has been converted into a hydrated peroxide by atmospheric
oxidation, and there the peroxide has been reduced by organic products to a protoxide of iron. Here the protoxide has been converted into a carbonate of iron, and there you see the presence of proto-silicate of iron in green earth. Even in the
carboniferous formation we have abundant proofs of the great solubility and numerous combinations of which iron is capable within the limits of chemical affinity. In our own locality, and at Ulverston, we find it as a peroxide, and in other districts it
shows itself as carbonate. It may have been the same oxide, which was originally held in solution by the waters of the carboniferous era, and the differences of the final deposits may arise from the various chemical changes through which it has passed.
In the case of our hematite deposits, there was probably nothing to prevent the oxidation of the iron held in solution; but in the case of the ironstones of the coal measures, the presence of decomposing vegetable matter would tend to prevent this
result. The decomposition of vegetable matter in the formation of coal would necessarily be attended by the production of carbonic acid, one of the most powerful reducing agents. "This carbonic acid" (as the late Sir H. DE LA BACHE has
explained in the Memoirs of the Geological Survey, vol. 1, p. 185), "mixed with water, would spread with it over areas of different dimensions, according to circumstances; forming salts, and meeting with protoxide of iron in solution, it
would unite with the protoxide and form a carbonate of iron. The carbonate of iron in solution would mingle with any fine detritus which might be held in mechanical suspension in the same water; and hence, when the conditions for its deposit arose,
— which would happen when the needful excess of carbonic acid was removed, — the carbonate of iron would be thrown down, intermingled with the mud; and, if not in sufficient quantity to form continuous layers, would aggregate into nodules,
and be arranged into planes amid the sediment.
But this article must have an end, although we feel there is still much to be said. From the foregoing observations the reader will now perceive the force of our remarks in our third article touching the connection of chemical geology with the problems
we have suggested; for it is in that department we may reasonably expect to find their solution, if anywhere. If we have been the humble means of helping some of our readers to a clearer understanding of the phenomena around them, we shall be amply
repaid for any expenditure of thought and time our papers may have cost us. If any of our readers think that our main positions are not in accordance with well authenticated facts, we shall be glad to receive their corrections through the editor of The
News; for the attitude we endeavour to maintain in this wondrous world is to keep our mind open, ready like children, to receive new impressions, but careful like men, to test and examine them.
Cleator, August 9th, 1865.
CYNTHIA.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Beche, H. De La, Sir | | | |
| Binney, — | | | |
| Bischof, — | | Geologist | |
| Hunt, — | | | |
| Sorby, — | | | |