Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

17th July 1865

The Hematite Deposits Of West Cumberland. - No. IV

As intimated in the concluding remarks of our last article, we have now something to say respecting the origin of our red ore deposits, and the conditions under which they were formed. Remembering the class of readers for whose benefit we have undertaken to pen these lines, we shall not give direct replies to the queries proposed in our last communication, but enter into such explanations as will tend to make the positions we are inclined to hold intelligible and feasible. As the subject is confessedly one involved in much obscurity, some may be ready to question the propriety of theorising on a matter beset with so many difficulties; but instead of a useless expenditure of time and energy resulting from such speculations, pursued with becoming modesty, the probability in that they will give a definite direction to our ideas and investigations.

We have, first, then, to inquire: Whence are those vast bodies of Hematite ore, found in this locality, derived? Some men would cut the knot at once, and say, in reply to such a question, that those masses of ore have been placed in their present positions by the direct fiat of the Deity, and without the agency of secondary causes. Now, far be it from us to question the possibilities of Almighty Power, but we beg to state that we very much question the probability of such acts in a world constituted like this. That is evidently not the way in which operations are conducted in the laboratory of nature. Experience and science both teach us that the universe, in all its departments, is governed by the agency of general laws, and, therefore, if we would properly understand the nature of any given results, we must endeavour to find out and clearly trace their causes.

One of the theories, which finds favour among geologists, in accounting for metalliferous deposits, is that such deposits are the result of a process called segregation, by which metallic particles are separated from the surrounding rocks. This doubtless, is one way in, which the contents of certain ore-veins have originated. The cracks we sometimes see in clays, filled with iron pyrites or with sulphate and carbonate of baryta; the joints in granite rocks, occupied by a different kind of granite from the mass; and the veins occurring in various kinds of marble, filled with metallic substances, seem to countenance this theory. But to rely upon this hypothesis in every case, without any regard to others, would be to encounter a host of insuperable difficulties, for if the segregation process be the only cause of metalliferous deposits, how does it happen that the same kind of limestone, and with similar fissures as we have in West Cumberland, is in other districts of the country destitute of immense beds of hematite ore?

Perhaps some of our readers are disposed to give countenance to the old alchemic doctrine of the "possible transmutation of earths into metals." But we confess our inability to accept such a doctrine. At the same time, any person acquainted with some of the marvellous doings of chemistry will acknowledge that the old alchemists were not such fools as we moderns often deem them. When you think that frequently the chemical combination of two or more substances will generate another substance, perfectly different in its nature from the rest; when you are aware that the carbonate of iron may be converted into pure hydrous peroxide of iron — that a slight change in the temperature will be sufficient to convert the prismatic crystals of aragonite into the rhombic crystals of calc spar; and that by means of an electro-chemical apparatus you may get from the same solution different substances, we need not be surprised that the old experimentalists supposed that some earths could be transmuted into metals! But though this supposition may never be realised, yet we dare believe that chemistry is destined to reveal many secrets on these and kindred subjects, now scarcely dreamt of in our philosophy.

But, in reference to the sources of West Cumberland hematite deposits, it has been suggested that it is probable they were derived from the masses of vegetable matter which went to form the Cumberland coal-field. No doubt a portion of iron may be found in vegetable matter. In fact, traces of iron and other metals have been detected in the ashes of coal when burned. BISCHOF, the celebrated chemical geologist, informs us that VAUX frequently found the ashes of coal to contain traces of copper and lead; and that DAURREE discovered arsenic and antimony. BAER also found that the principal substances in the ashes of coal examined by him were peroxide of iron, alumina, lime, silica, sulphuric acid, and sulphur. But one cannot avoid thinking that the quantity of iron which the vegetable matter, now seen in the condition of coal in West Cumberland, could afford, would be totally inadequate to supply the millions of cubic feet of the hard, compact hematite of this district. But, granting that there was an unusual supply of the oxide of iron in the vegetable products when they passed into coal, by what process, we should like to know, could the oxide be separated from the entire mass? Coal is evidently an organic product, having been once some kind of vegetable matter. It contains four organic elements, oxygen, hydrogen, nitrogen, and carbon, and small quantities of eight or nine inorganic elements, of which iron seems to be one. The inorganic substances are found in the ashes when the coal is burned. Now, in the transformation of the vegetable matter into coal, decomposition would set in by some force or other, and, consequently, part of the gaseous elements would be driven off, leaving carbon and the inorganic elements behind. Of course, the proportion of the gaseous elements expelled would depend upon the amount of the decomposing force brought to bear on the vegetable mass. Hence we have coals in our country with scarcely any organic element left except carbon, as, for example, the anthracite coals; and then we have coals highly bituminous, and, therefore, containing a considerable amount of oxygen, hydrogen, and nitrogen. So, from the above considerations, we conclude, first, that seeing that iron forms but a very insignificant part of the inorganic elements of vegetable matter, the carboniferous vegetation converted into coal in West Cumberland, immense as that must have been to form fifteen feet of average thickness of workable coal, and with an area of twenty miles in length and four or five in breadth, could not have furnished our immense beds of hematite; and, secondly, that even supposing the quantity of iron in the carboniferous vegetation to have been sufficient for the supply of hematite, the decomposition to which it would be subjected would not have the effect of disengaging the metal from the mass, but of leaving it behind with the rest of the inorganic substances. Perhaps we shall be reminded that iron ore is most plentiful in the coal measures, and that often from the same pits are extracted coal and iron, as a proof that the ancient forests have been the sources of the iron formation. We admit the facts, but we cannot accept the conclusion based upon them. Because we cannot properly explain how it happens that iron ores should occur so abundantly in the coal measures, it does not follow that the one is the cause of the other. But it ought to be known that all coalfields do not yield iron ores. The Newcastle coalfield, for example, said to be the richest coalfield in the world, produces so little iron that the furnaces, which are worked in that locality, are chiefly supplied by ores brought from other places.

But, although it may be anticipating a little, it may be desirable to observe here that it is possible that the connection of the vast iron deposits with the coal measures may arise in this way: At the close of the Silurian age, and during the carboniferous and Permian periods; the waters of the globe may have been abundantly charged with the oxide of iron, partly derived from the decomposition of the older rocks, and partly from volcanic eruptions. In some cases the oxide has been deposited with a small mixture of foreign impurities, as seen in the hematite ores of Cumberland and Lancashire, while in others the deposits seem to have been formed under different conditions and produced amidst a large amount of earthy matter, and also of decomposing vegetable and animal substances, as shown in the clay ironstones and black bands of Staffordshire and elsewhere.

Then some speak as if the hematite flowed in a molten condition into its present receptacles from some immense reservoir, located in the interior of the earth. But we see no reliable evidence to warrant as in entertaining such a theory. In fact, the evidence points in a different direction. The presence of thin shale partings, interstratified with the iron ore, the laminated structure of the ore in many places, the nature of the floor of deposits on which it rests, and the absence of every thing like the results of igneous action from the sides of the clefts through which this supposed molten metal must have passed, forbid our crediting such a hypothesis even for moment. The special phenomena, which have led some to imagine such an origin for our invaluable hematite, such as the occurrence of cairties in the body of the ore, and lined with various crystals, and the kidney like concretions of the ore, we shall notice in our next communication.

Cynthia.

Cleator, July 17, 1865.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Baer, —      
Bischof, —    Geologist  
Dauree, —      
Vaux, —      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print