Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

19th January 1865, Page: 2, Column: 5

The Recent Case Of Suffocation At Friar's Goose Pit

Coroner's Inquest

Yesterday, an inquest was held in the Ship Inn, Tyne Main, Gateshead, before Dr. Davis, deputy-coroner for Chester Ward, on the body of Thomas Heslop, whose death, together with a man named Charlton, by suffocation, whilst down the Friar's Goose Pit, on Monday last, was recorded in Tuesday's Journal. During the course of the inquiry, there were present — Charles Carr, Esq., consulting engineer of the colliery ; Matthew Dunn, Esq., Local Government Inspector ; and Mr. George T. France, of the Jarrow Chemical Works.

The first witness called was

Robert Reed, resident viewer of the Felling and Tyne Main collieries, who deposed as follows : Wishing to ascertain to what height the water in the pumping shaft of the Friar's Goose Colliery would have to ascend before it reached the drift between that shaft and a staple, he had been instructed by the owners to descend that pit and get the depth. In order to do so, he had taken with him from the Felling Pit the deceased Charlton, and met at the Friar's Goose Pit, Heslop, who descended the shaft. Before the men went down, he, in company with the engineer of the pit, Mr. George Gilroy, lowered down a lighted torch to see that the air was good, and which burning freely, the flames being blown at right angles, they judged all right, and accordingly rigged a snatch block and tackling to the "gin" at the bank of the pit, and lowered the man Charlton first, shortly afterwards followed by Heslop. The distance of the drift from the main engine shaft to the staple where a set of pumps were placed, and where Mr. Gilroy was standing — witness being at the top of the main shaft — was 56 feet. The distance from the drift to the bank was 8 fathoms (48 feet) — the drift being situate underneath the engine-house. While the men were down constant communication was made by them to Mr. Gilroy and Mr. Reed. To make a fresh current of air pass down the staple, along the drift, and up the main shaft, a covering had been taken off the top of the staple, so both witness and Gilroy could hear distinctly what was passing in the drift where the men were. When the men got to the landing-box they reported all was well, and proceeded along the drift, although not ordered to do so, merely having to ascertain to what height the water had risen in the pit shaft.

By the Government Inspector : The staple was four feet six inches wide ; and was partly filled with rubbish when the boards were taken off the top, although a good current of air was passing down.

Coroner: Hearing a splash in the water down the shaft, I shouted ; and no answer being given, Gilroy and I afterwards went down to see what was the matter. Before hearing the splash, I heard Charlton say that they should return along the drift. We could hear quite distinctly what the men were saying. When I went down, I found Heslop with his face in the mud, which was some inches in depth at the bottom of the drift, and quite dead. I thought the gas we perceived was sulphuretted hydrogen, and had that peculiar horrid smell which is always found in gas of that description. The bodies of the men, when brought to the surface and cleaned, were of the darkest blue, and the colour of the clothes quite black. At the bottom of the drift the water was completely surcharged with the gas.

Cross examined: Both were competent men ; one being a deputy, and the other a master-shifter. The shaft has been used for many years, belonging to a pumping-engine; and the drift dips from the shaft towards the staple.

By the Government Inspector: The current of air would be perfectly pure — besides passing down the staple, coming up the culvert from the river.

Mr. France, who was present, said this would not be the case, as there was running in the same culvert the refuse water from a "tank heap." Tank was a refuse from the soda-balls manufactured in the chemical works both at the Goose and the Felling, and the water from the tank heap passed into a small burn which run through the dene adjoining the pit, and likewise ran into the culvert, thus rendering the water and air highly charged with sulphurous matter.

Reed's examination continued : I believe the men had fallen into the mud, as there was a slight mark on the forehead of one of them. The bodies were considerably swollen.

Cross-examined : Believed that the trickling of the water in the shaft had been occasioned by the water mixed with the mud at the bottom of the drift having become disturbed by the men walking in it, thus disturbing the noxious gas, and so being the cause of the death of the men.

By a Juror : A candle would burn in the gas, owing to the ventilation they had made pass between the staple and the shaft.

By the Government Inspector : Never felt the gas at the top of the shaft.

By a Juryman : The water in the shaft was within two feet of the drift where the men were. Thought that the culvert would be completely filled with the refuse of the tank-heap thus causing the gases to come into the drifts.

By the Coroner: It would now be highly dangerous to descend to the drift. In his opinion the men had met their deaths by being suffocated by impure gases, but could not say exactly that they were those coming from the Friar's Goose Chemical Works.

A Juryman said several cases of death from men inhaling these noxious gases had occurred in the neighbourhood. One man had been in a drift, and where it was ascertained that percolation had taken place from the gases of a neighbouring tank-heap, and the odour of which in the neighbourhood was abominable.

The Coroner also remarked that in that neighbourhood he was only astonished how the inhabitants preserved the sense of smelling.

George Gilroy was the next witness called, and gave evidence chiefly to the same effect as the previous witness. He was resident engineer at the colliery, and was in company with the last witness at the time of the occurrence. He had been employed at the colliery for a considerable period, and had been told by his father that such a gas existed in that drift, and had also observed in the staple that everything was of a blue colour, which, on being removed, showed a pure white, indicative of the presence of sulphurous matter. He had gone down the shaft with Mr. Reed, and narrowly escaped suffocation likewise.

George Thornton France, who had been present in the room during the inquiry, at the request of the coroner was sworn, and deposed as follows : I am manager at the Friar's Goose Chemical Works. Yesterday, three gentlemen (Mr. Coxon, a viewer ; Mr. Reed, viewer ; and Dr. Pyle) called at my office in the works, and asked me if I would come and give evidence as to what had been the cause of the death of these two men. They asked me likewise if I could tell them what gas was likely to have been present in the staple at the time of the accident. I told them if the staple was open to the culvert, which comes into the river near the pit, there would undoubtedly be sulphuretted hydrogen gas. I have since seen the place, and from the appearance of it I have perceived that there is a strong current of air passing upward from the river, driving this gas into the shaft. If there was that presence of gas in the shaft, I am of opinion that it would also be in the drift. That it is caused by that current I am perfectly satisfied, inasmuch as the marks of its presence becomes blacker as you go down the shaft, caused by its losing strength as it comes up the shaft. I do not agree in the opinion that the tank heap which is marked on the plan before me is the cause of the presence of the gas in the drift, as the tank heap there has been so for upwards of eleven years, and as it becomes more exposed to atmospheric influence it necessarily becomes self-supporting and of great strength, rendering it impossible that its fluid could percolate through the ground and so into the working of the mine. But when the tank has been put down in later years, it would certainly percolate and go into the workings of the mine. The gas has been generated in the tank, but not by that placed above the drift. All the tank refuse from the factory is now taken out to sea in hopper barges.

In cross-examination, Mr. France said the tank was quite surcharged with sulphur, and which was quite wasted, there being no process cheap enough to pay its being extracted from the tank.

The Deputy-Coroner said, although the occurrence had been purely accidental, it was to be hoped that at Tyne Main pit a great deal of care would be taken in future in sending men down before seeing that the gas was cleared away. There was no other conclusion to be arrived at than that the case had been one of "Accidental death."

The jury accordingly returned that verdict, several of their number suggesting that, before any person ventured down again, expedients should be used to clear away the noxious gases. Mr. Reed said that pumping water through the drift would be the only way to remedy the evil.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Carr, Charles      
Coxon, —      
Davis, —, Dr.      
Dunn, Matthew      
France, George Thornton      
Gilroy, George      
Heslop, Thomas      
Pyle, —, Dr.      
Reed, Robert      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Felling Colliery  Felling Colliery
Tyne Main Colliery  Tyne Main Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
17 Jan 1865  Fatal Accident At Friar's Goose Colliery (Shields Daily Gazette)
17 Jan 1865  Fatal Accident At Friar's Goose Colliery (Newcastle Daily Journal)
19 Jan 1865  Inquest (Shields Daily Gazette)
19 Jan 1865  News (Newcastle Daily Journal)
19 Jan 1865  The Recent Case Of Suffocation At Friar's Goose Pit, Coroner's Inquest (Newcastle Daily Journal)
21 Jan 1865  Accident At Tyne Main Colliery (Newcastle Weekly Chronicle)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Friars Goose
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 18 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print