|
22nd December 1864 Sewell and Others V CarmichaelThis was an adjourned case from the last court day, for the purpose of giving the particulars of the claim into court. The action was brought by four men named Sewell, Fox, Cook, and Tremble, iron-ore miners, to recover a balance of wages from their employer, Thomas Carmichael. Mr. Webster appeared for plaintiffs, and Mr. Howson for defendant. The defendant, who is the lessee of the Knockmurton iron-ore mines, it appeared, had engaged the men to work in the mine, to be paid at a certain price per ton for ore raised, and so much per yard for working the forehead of the drift. After having been engaged for some time it was discovered that they had not carried forward the drift, but got the ore out of the roof, where it was better to obtain. By this proceeding, damage was done to the pit, which cost £4 2s 0½d to repair. The plaintiffs, to meet this argument contended that they were short of wood, and that the roof had fallen down through not having been properly timbered up. The amount sued for was £4 2s 0½d, being part of their wages, which the defendant had refused to pay, as the men had not done the work as per contract. Several witnesses having been examined on both sides, the judge, after a careful deliberation, said that although as a rule he had always found workmen pretty accurate as to the quantity of work done, and their accounts, yet there was something preposterous in the present case. The plaintiffs were engaged to do the work, and have so much per yard for getting the ore out of the forehead; but according to their own statement they did not do so, and never carried the drift forward at all. He did not dispute the quantity they had raised, but under the circumstances he thought they had already been well paid, and he should order a non-suit, without allowing costs.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||