|
24th November 1864 Whitehaven County Court - Fox and Others V CarmichaelThis was an action to recover the sum of £4 2a 0½d by John Fox, Daniel Cook, John Sewell, and William Tremble, from Thomas Carmichael. Mr. Webster appeared for the plaintiffs, and Mr. Howson for the defendant. The debt was for work done by the plaintiffs, who are miners, for the defendant, the proprietor of the Knockmurton iron ore mines. John Fox, on being sworn, deposed that he and others had been engaged by Mr. Allan, foreman to Mr. Carmichael, to work in the mine, and to be paid 4s 6d per ton for the ore they obtained. They raised 82 "bogies" or 12½ tons, after which a fresh bargain was made, by which they should be paid 4s 9d per ton; and under this bargain they raised 153 "bogies." It was for the non-payment of this work done that the present action was brought. In cross-examination by Mr. Howson, witness said the bargain was that they should carry the drift forward, and get room on the sides for the work there to be carried on. They were to properly timber and keep the roof up. The roof got bad and difficult to work, in consequence of their being only one shift of men instead of three. The timber was put up properly and well, but the roof came down; the reason of this was that there was not the proper shifts of men. Daniel Cook and William Tremble were also examined, and deposed that they were engaged by the defendant's foreman, John Allan, to get the ore at 4s 9d per ton, but that afterwards he refused to pay them because Sewell and Fox had left the pit. Mr. Howson, for the defence, said the defendants had given the plaintiff credit for 30 tons at 3s per ton, but they disputed the full amount charged for raising the ore. The agreement was that they should work the drift in the forehead, and clear the sides, and properly timber up the roofs; but instead of this it was found that they had got the ore out of the roof instead of the forehead, and this considerably damaged the roof. The drift by this means was nearly stopped up. The plaintiffs afterwards got some of the ore which had fallen from the roof for which they were paid 3s per ton. His Honour at this stage interrupted the case, and asked Mr. Webster to prove the items of the claims as there were certain sums down which had nothing to do with the present bargain. Mr. Webster said they were balance of a previous account of which he had no particulars by him. His Honour said Mr. Webster must prove the items, or they could not be allowed. If the parties did not settle it in some other way, the plaintiff must set down the particulars of all the money they had received, and also a proper statement of the items of their claim. The case was then adjourned until the next sitting of the court.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||