|
24th September 1864, Page: 4, Column: 1 Important Case To Colliery OwnersAt the North Shields County Court, on Wednesday before W. Blanshard, Esq., judge, the case William Davies v. John Straker and John Coppin was heard. The plaintiff sought to recover from the defendants, as owners of the Hartley Cowpen Colliery, the sum of £40 for ten days detention in loading his vessel, the Clarinda, which had been promised to be loaded by the defendants or their agents on or about the 21st of April last, whereas, in fact, the loading was not completed until the 5th of May. Mr. Wawn, appeared for the plaintiff, and Mr. Blackwell, barrister, instructed by Mr. Kewney, for the defendants. The case turned upon an alleged promise on the part of Mr. Fothergill, agent for the owners of the colliery in question, that the Clarinda should be loaded in five or six days from the date when she was entered for "turn" — viz. the 16th of April. The plaintiff said that, in consequence of this promise, he reshipped his crew, and thereby incurred an expense of £40 which he would not have had to pay had the men been on shore while the vessel was waiting to be loaded. He sent an account of this amount to Messrs. Bilton and Williams, brokers, who mentioned the matter to Mr. Fothergill, and he, simply to avoid litigation, offered to pay £10 as compensation, and afterwards raised his offer to £12 10s. This sum was refused, and he declined to give any more. The Clarinda, though entered for turn on April 16th, did not, it appeared, get to Howdon Dock, where she was to be loaded, till the 21st, when five days had already expired. It was proved that the vessel was loaded in her regular turn, and that no preference was shown to any other. His Honour, at considerable length, showed that the promise was merely conditional, and could not have been otherwise, owing to the operation of the Coal Turn Act, which provided that all vessels must take their turn in loading. He believed that the offer of compensation implied no liability, excepting the reason given by Mr. Fothergill for making the offer. The plaintiff was non-suited.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||