|
30th July 1864, Page: 5, Column: 1 Manslaughter At MurtonOn Tuesday, Mr. Maynard, coroner, held an inquest at Murton Colliery on the body of John Hastie, aged 53, who was killed by a companion on Saturday night. Edward Lowther, a pitman at Murton Colliery, said that about 12 o'clock on Saturday night he came up to the inn door and met Hastie and Mullins coming out arm in arm. They walked up to Lawson's grocer's shop together. He heard a conversation between them, and both were in liquor, Mullins being the worst of the two. When he followed them about ten minutes afterwards he found Hastie lying on the ground at "Sandgate Raw end," Daniel Mullins being down beside him. Hastie was on his knees and his son was holding him. Witness helped to carry deceased home, but heard nothing said about the affair, either by Hastie or Mullins. The latter helped to carry deceased home. — William Gilroy, another pitman, said he and Thos. Waggott fell in with them near Sandgate Row end about ten minutes past twelve, and saw Hastie lying, Mullins attempting to lift him up, and shouting for help. They went up to help, and Hastie's son, who had "heard the noration" came out and went for the doctor on hearing his father complain that his neck was broken. Witness and his companion were first on the spot, no one else being there at the time the two men were on the ground. Deceased had not fallen down any steep, because the road is a level one. Their clothes were not torn, and the ground did not seem as if there had been a struggle. Deceased was lying near the oven, with his face towards it, and his back to the rails. He lay curled up on his side, and said Mullins had flung him. Mullins did not deny having done so. — Mr. Bewsher, assistant surgeon, said he went immediately, at the call of deceased's son, and found Hastie complaining that his neck was out. On examining him he found the neck was broken, and after putting it right he directed the men on the spot to take him home. Mullins was one who assisted, but after deceased was laid on a long-settle the neck seemed to go out again. After a few minutes had elapsed, witness asked how it happened. Deceased said he had been up at Lawson's shop getting two cabbages, and met Mullins there. Coming over in company, Mullins told him some one had been vexing and irritating him, but he and Mullins had had no words, and were quite friendly. When they got to Sandgate Row end, Mullins suddenly caught him and cross buttocked him, saying. "This is the way I would have done it." Mullins said, "You don't mean to say I did it on purpose ? You know I did not do it maliciously." Hastie replied that it was a bad job, and he did not think he had done it on purpose. Deceased added that there was no irritation between them, or quarrelling. Mullins repeatedly said he was sorry for it, and did not do it on purpose, deceased always replying that he quite believed that. Deceased died about nine o'clock on Sunday night. A bone setter, named William Simpson, was called in, and as the man was dying, witness cautioned Simpson, and told him not to interfere with Hastie, as a magistrate had been sent for, to take his dying deposition. Simpson put his hand upon deceased's neck, and said the windpipe was broken. He next began to pull and rotate the head, and most certainly hastened his death. Deceased could not have recovered after the injuries he had sustained on the Saturday night, but he might have lived for some hours longer if Simpson had not interfered with him. — Dr. Broadbent said he went from South Hetton to see deceased on Sunday morning, and found the vertebras of the neck fractured, but no external injuries except a small bruise on the forehead. He had lost the power of swallowing, and there was a total loss of power of all the upper extremities. Witness wanted some leeches applied to his neck, but he positively refused, and refused to try to swallow. He saw it was a perfectly hopeless case. Witness made a post-mortem examination afterwards, and described the appearances, which he said were sufficient to account for death. Deceased could not possibly have recovered after receiving them. Such injuries must have been done with very great violence. When the magistrate arrived, the deceased was too far gone to make any deposition. — By the prisoner: Deceased told me it was an accident, and you bore him no malice, and that you were going to show how to put the hang on the people who had been calling you "Irish." — P.C. Welford said he saw deceased on Sunday morning, Mullins being present, and asked him how it occurred. He said Mullins told him some one had been vexing him and calling him an Irishman, and said, "I'll show you how I'll do with them." Mullins then took hold of him, put the hang on, and cross-buttocked him, throwing him heavily on his head. Deceased did not say he had allowed the other man to do it, but said that as he had a cabbage under each arm he could make no "fend" for himself. Witness apprehended Mullins in the afternoon in Hasties house, and charged him with "attempting to murder." Prisoner replied that he did it, but not through any ill-will towards the man. — Mr. Bewsher le-called, said the deceased was perfectly sober when he got to him. — The Coroner said the evidence for the consideration of the jury was very plain. It might be an accident; or if an assault upon deceased it would be manslaughter ; but if an assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm, it would be murder. — The jury, after a short consultation, returned a verdict of manslaughter against Mullins, who was, therefore, formally committed for trial.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||