|
Whitehaven HeraldArticle from the Whitehaven Herald, 27th February 1864 The Late Fatal Accident at No.2 Pit, Cleator MoorOn Wednesday evening. The adjourned inquest to inquire into the death of William Napier, coalminer, aged 58, who was killed on Tuesday night, the 16th inst., at No.2 pit, Cleator Moor, was held at the Globe Hotel, Hensingham, before William Lumb, jun., Esq., coroner, and a jury consisting of the following gentlemen:- Messrs W. Bennett (Foreman), Jos. Rothery, John Briggs, Joseph Sumpton, Joseph Mawson, Joseph Skelton, W. Sherwen, Robert Bell, James Best, Jacob Kitchin, Nelson Little and John Young. Mr. Webster appeared on behalf of Mr. Dunne, the Government Inspector, and Mr. Paitson appeared on behalf of the proprietors of the pit. Mr. Bailes, the manager of the pit was also in attendance. The following evidence was taken: - William Noden said he lived at Hensingham and was a deputy in No. 2 pit Cleator Moor. Deceased was a coal miner in the same pit, and witness went into his workings with him on the night of the accident, and examined it to see that all was right. Found, by holding up his lamp, a small portion of gas coming from a hole in the roof. The hole had been caused by some falls of coal — three or four tubs, about 14 cwt. Called the deceased's attention to it, and he said it was nothing and would go away as soon as they got to work. He left the gas as it was and did not attempt to "bat' it out. Deceased's son went into the working shortly after. About 11 o'clock witness was running a rolly, when Geo. Foster came and told him that the Napiers were covered up. He (witness) sent for assistance, and told Barney McCormick to go for Hughie Emmerson. Geo. Foster and witness went to where the Napiers were working and found the son nearly covered over with a fall which had come from the roof. Witness said 'Oh! Harry, wheres th' father?" and he replied that he had gone to look for assistance. Some men were set to clear away the fall, while he and Emmerson went in search of the father. They went through all the old places, the foreheads and roads to see if they could find him. They searched about an hour and a half without success, and again went to the son when witness, addressing him said "Ista sure, Harry, th' father's out of the fall?" He replied that he was quite positive. Witness continued his search in company with Barney McCormick for half an hour longer, when he returned to the fall, and began to remove it, thinking the deceased must be under it. While he was so employed Hughie Emmerson came and told him they had found deceased. He saw deceased after he was found, and he was quite dead. Mr. Bailes, manager of the pit, was called to prove a plan of the place where deceased was found. He pointed out the place were deceased was working, and the road he must have taken to arrive at the place where he was found. That place had been abandoned about eight weeks. William Noden continued: He said he first saw the Napiers at the pit top and they were perfectly sober. They knew the roof was bad as well as he. From the time they left the pervious shift till they returned there had been a fall of coal: Mr. Paitson said he did not think it was material to go into the fall so minutely as it was material which caused the old mans death. The Coroner said he was not so sure about that, because when the fall took place the old man went out to look for assistance and was lost. The presumption was that if the fall had not taken place he would not have gone out. He did not think he could stop such evidence, but they could give as little about the fall as possible. In reply to Mr. Webster, witness said the deceased had been employed in the pit three or four months. At one of the entrances to the place where deceased was found there were two brattice boards and a flat head, and a man would have some difficulty in creeping through between them. By the coroner: The place was an air course, and could not be walled up. There were other old workings fenced in the same way. By Mr. Paitson: The small quantity of gas which he saw in the working could have nothing to do with the fall. The business of deceased and his son in that working was to take down the top coal, and this was done by taking out the props. Deceased had taken out some props improperly, and he attributed the fall to the deceased drawing the timber too soon. It was the duty of the overman to go into the place where deceased was found every Monday morning and see that all was right. In going into the place he had to take down part of the brattice. Mr. J. B. Wilson said he had examined deceased, and could find no marks of violence to account for death. He believed suffocation was cause of death. Martin Chandler, one of the deputies of No. 2 pit said he went into the pit about 3 o'clock in the morning and met William Noden, who told him what had happened. He went for Mr. Bailes, who returned to the pit with him. He afterwards went in search of deceased, and found him in an old working about 300 yards from where the fall took place. Witness had to shift a signboard to get into it. There was a flat-head on one side of the entrance and three brattices on the other with "dirt" marked upon them. One of the brattices had been shifted from the time he saw it all right at 4 o'clock the previous afternoon. No man could possibly have got through without one of the brattices being shifted; and no one could have arrived at the place where deceased was found without knowing they were going into danger. When he found deceased he had about he had about four stones of coal — lying upon his back. Deceased had fallen upon his lamp, and it was out. It was usual to protect places of this sort with brattices similar to this. He had seen gates used instead of brattices, but he never saw locked gates. He considered that the protection which was up there was as good as gates. He did not take his lamp into the place where he found deceased at first, but hung it up on the inbye end of the brattice. By Mr. Paitson: There was not much gas in the place where he found deceased; if there had been he would have felt it. He was in the working five minutes. He believed a man could have worked in it half a day without injury to himself. To stop up the places altogether would stop ventilation of the pit. Richard Dixon, overman of the pit, having given similar testimony to that given by the previous witnesses, Mr. Paitson stated that he had more witnesses to call up to speak to the same facts if the jury wished to hear them, but he did not wish to detain them unnecessarily. The Coroner then summed up, and having cleared the room, left the jury to consider the evidence. After a short consultation they returned a verdict of "accidental death," with a recommendation that the manager of the pit should protect the dangerous places with stronger bratticing. Mr. Bailes said he should attend to the recommendation of the jury.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||