Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

18th February 1864

Fatal Accident at Cleator Mill

On Friday morning, a melancholy and fatal accident occurred at the flax mill of T. Ainsworth, Esq., at Cleator. From enquiries, which we have made, we are enabled to place before our readers the following particulars as to the accident, which, at the time, caused great excitement in the neighbourhood of Cleator. It appears that for some time past, extensive alterations have been going on at the mill, with a view of rendering it proof against fire, the alterations in question being carried on under the direction, we understand, of Mr. Fairbairn, civil engineer, of Manchester. The mill is four stories high, and in order to make it fire proof it was necessary to rebuild the interior. This was being done by putting in cast iron girders from one side to the other, such girders being supported by an iron pillar from the floor in the centre. Each girder is nine feet apart and is arched over with firebricks. About ten o'clock on Friday morning, John Oliphant, joiner, of Cleator, was working on the top of one of the arches in the upper story, when he heard a rumbling noise and almost immediately found the bricks give way under his feet. He at once ran off the place and escaped unhurt. William Banks, a mason, also of Cleator, was working on the same arch, but unfortunately could not escape from the place in time. He fell through on to the ground floor and three hours afterwards, when the debris had been removed, he was found quite dead. Deceased was 74 years of age. There were five young women severely injured. Their names are as follows: Elizabeth Joyce (married); Sarah Conner; Alice Blaney; Mary Ann Kenny and Teresa Dockarty. They were all removed to their homes and have been attended by a medical gentleman.

The damage done to the mill through the accident is very great. In the second floor three arches have fallen and one spinning frame which was not working. In the third floor, three arches have fallen. How the accident occurred has not been ascertained, but it is thought that the machinery had been put in the rooms before the mortar was completely dry.

On Saturday morning, an inquest upon the view of the body of the deceased, William Banks, was held in the Schoolroom, Cleator, before H. Bell, Esq., the coroner for the lordship of Egremont and a respectable jury. T. Ainsworth, Esq., attended the inquest.

The following evidence was adduced: — John Oliphant said: I am a joiner and worked at the mill on Friday morning. I was standing at No. 4 arch near the deceased and some other men when we heard a crack and directly the arch fell in carrying down with it others that were below. I was gathering wedges up at the time. We had just time to get on the next arch when the crash happened. The deceased was about the middle of the arch at the time and being unable to get off in time, he went down with it. Deceased was levelling the floor with mortar and broken stones. The arch that gave way first had been made last week but one; it has hardly been made a fortnight — perhaps 10 or 12 days. Since it was made a set and a half of arches have been finished.

By the Coroner: The arch that fell was of a longer span than the rest, but it was of the same bend or curve. The arches were of different span, but the crowns had to be kept one height so that the floors might be level. The bricks lie on a flange on the girders; the flanges would extend over about half a brick.

Mr. Ainsworth said the architect was not present; had written to him and probably he would arrive that night.

The Coroner: This man can scarcely tell us if the arch was sufficiently curved to make it safe.

Mr. Ainsworth: You will get that from the brick-setter.

The Coroner: It is plain a man falling the distance that deceased did must be killed: as to that there is no question. The question is as to the cause of his falling. The jury will have to see whether any blame attaches to anyone — I do not say or think there does — but it is for you to investigate that.

Witness continued: Deceased had two labourers with him. There had been more people on the arch than at the time it fell. Deceased was buried amongst the bricks and rubbish and it was about half past twelve before he was got out. He was quite dead then. The women who are hurt were working in the two lower rooms.

Mr. Ainsworth, in answer to the coroner, said that there were five women hurt — some seriously. One had her leg broken, another her jaw fractured and the others had scalp wounds. They were not under the arches that fell or they must have been killed; he supposed they had been injured by portions of the falling arches. Seven arches fell. The mill had been built at twice, and a gable end had apparently been taken away, and the building lengthened. This accounted for the longer span of the arch, which fell.

The Coroner: Do you suppose the alterations in the weather would have any effect in causing the arch to fall?

Mr. Ainsworth said he kept a register of the weather. It appeared that the arch which first fell was finished on the 5th February. There had been frost during the time it was being constructed.

The Coroner: When the thaw happened, what would be the effect?

Mr. Ainsworth: The mortar was made by a mill and was not frozen; steam was constantly on in the rooms so that I do not see that the weather could have much effect on the work.

The Coroner said he put these questions, as it would be in their minds that last winter some serious accidents had occurred from the breaking of railway carriage wheels — the breakage being attributed to the effects of frost.

Isaac Sparks deposed: I am head joiner at this work. The arch that first fell was finished last week. I took out the wooden centres after one course of arches had been finished and another begun. I was always very particular in taking out the centres. I did not notice anything particular when I struck the centres from the arch. I have been in the habit of putting up centres and I have put a wider span than this with a less curve. The crowns of the arches were single brick, but the abutments were more.

The Coroner instanced a case, which occurred on the Cockermouth railway in which on removing the centres from some arches in frosty weather, the whole fell in — the centres having evidently been taken away too soon.

A Juryman: In this case the centres were not removed all at once; they were eased by the wedges being drawn a little, and if the arch had given, it would have been seen. It is usual for arches to settle down a little after the centres are drawn.

John Haslam said: I am a bricklayer and was brought from Lancashire to do this job. I have been a builder at this kind of work, off and on, fourteen years. I have had a good deal of experience in fireproofing buildings on the plan, which was being acted upon here. The arches in this case were if anything a little more bay than they make them in Lancashire. The centres are not struck from one range until one has been finished first, and another begun. The only thing I can see is that the rods gave way; the arch could not get down unless the tie rods had first given way. The rods were of iron and were one inch square. They are of the same strength as I have always seen used in such work. If one of the tie rods was imperfect it might give and then the others would give too, and the arch would fall in. I cannot say that one of the rods was bad; of course I am not a judge of ironwork. I do not see the least necessity of having arches of such a span as this of a higher curve. The mortar was made every morning, and was never frozen; the bricks were carried into the building overnight, and as there was steam they did not get frozen through, though if they had it would not have altered their substance. They were good substantial bricks.

By Mr. Ainsworth: They were of the same size — perhaps a little thinner than the last I used in a job of this kind. There would be no difference in their strength, though I should say they were made of better material than the last I used. The last I built were 12 feet 6 inch rise. At the last job I used old bricks, which of course would not work so closely; here we had new bricks. I never saw any arches give way before.

The Coroner: He tells you that the arches were built in the ordinary way and with ordinary materials and his opinion is that the accident has been caused by the breaking of one of the tie rods. It is a fact that this poor man has lost his life, and we should all, no doubt be glad if we could discover by what means. The last witness has given you his opinion, and it seems to be a very sound and practical one; still it would perhaps be desirable to have the evidence of some architect upon the matter. The last witness has had fourteen years experience, and no doubt is able to form a very correct judgement; still if you wish it I will adjourn the inquiry so that you may have the testimony of an architect.

A Juryman: I feel perfectly satisfied with the opinion given by the last witness.

John Haslam continued: I do not think the centres were taken away too quickly. The mortar would be two or three days before it hardened; it had plenty of time in this instance to set.

The Coroner again offered to adjourn the inquiry, but the jury did not seem to think it at all necessary.

John Robinson was called, but his evidence was not of importance. He deposed that deceased had said the mortar brought him for levelling the floors was not moist enough.

The Coroner said the jury could now consider their verdict. If the evidence of John Haslam was not sufficient he would willingly adjourn the inquiry, though he himself scarcely thought it necessary. It appeared to him to be one of those accidents, which would take place even when the greatest care was exercised. Mr. Ainsworth, no doubt, was extremely sorry, as they all must be, that this accident had happened and would be glad if anything could be done to clear up the matter.

The Jury, without retiring, returned a verdict that deceased had been killed by a fall, caused by the accidental giving way of an arch upon which he had been working.

Mr. Ainsworth said that since the accident it had been his earnest desire to find out the cause. Whether the tie rods had given way or not he could not say, but with the coroner, he could have wished to have the opinion of an architect upon the subject. However, he could only come to the same verdict as the jury had done. He wished to say that the tie rods were brought from Manchester, and he felt perfectly satisfied that Messrs. Fairbairn, the makers, would never send them out without duly testing them.

The Coroner observed that if an architect came, he was sure he might say, for the satisfaction of the jury, that any suggestion he might make would be carefully attended to by Mr. Ainsworth.

The inquiry then terminated.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ainsworth, T.    Mill Owner  
Banks, William   74 Mason  
Bell, Henry    Coroner  
Blaney, Alice      
Conner, Sarah      
Dockarty, Teresa      
Fairburn, —    Civil Engineer  
Haslam, John    Bricklayer  
Joyce, Elizabeth      
Kenny, Mary Ann      
Oliphant, John    Joiner  
Robinson, John      
Sparks, Isaac    Head Joiner  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print