9th November 1863, Page: 2, Column: 3
The Strike Continued
Notwithstanding the "safety" with which the
Times of Saturday was able to "pronounce the strike
to be at an end," the strike still continues; and,
from present appearances, and from all we can learn
in private, is not likely, we deeply regret to say, to
be at an end for many a day. It will be remembered
that there was, on Friday last, some prospect of an
arrangement being amicably come to on the day following,
between the masters and men of the collieries
where the dispute has existed with the greatest virulence.
We refer, of course, to the collieries of
Messrs. Strakers and Love. On that day, an interview
took place between the managing partner of the
collieries and a deputation from the workmen ; and
it was stated that the only point now in difference
was the capacity of the tubs ; and it was agreed to
take measures for ascertaining it, so that a proper
standard measure might be adopted for the future.
The men, as it then appeared, had abandoned their
demand for twenty-five per cent. additional wages, in
the firm belief — it may, surely, be supposed with
safety — that it was too monstrous to be maintained,
and had confined themselves to asking that an agreement
should be come to with respect to what really
were the contents of the tubs they were to be paid for
filling. It might reasonably have been expected that
a merely technical point such as this would at once
have been settled With practical men at work on
both sides, it was certainly to be presumed that a
mere matter of detail such as this could present no
difficulty to either party. Such, however, we deeply
regret to find, has not been the case ; but a whole
day — a day, too, in a most important crisis of the
dispute — has been allowed to pass without seeing a
settlement of this very simple matter of detail. We do
not care to inquire minutely into the details of Saturday's
proceedings in reference to this squabble about
ascertaining the capacity of the tubs, with the object
of seeing on which side lies the balance of not having
come to an agreement about it. It is apparent that
both sides are much to blame; because, if either of them
had been thoroughly in earnest in their desire to set
aside this one remaining bone of contention, it might
easily have been consigned to the tomb of all the
Capulets ; and the public might this morning have
been congratulated that the strike had really terminated.
As it is, the public has reason to complain
that, apparently on a trilling matter of detail, the
quarrel is kept up ; and that another week begins
with wrangling about a mere technicality, instead of
with a renewal of work and of confidence between
masters and men. At any rate, the tub dispute should
have ended with the week ; so that, if the strike did
not end with it also, it might be seen that it was continued,
not on the score of grievances, but of wages.
We fear, from what we have been able to learn,
that the men, notwithstanding their apparent readiness
at the close of the week to abandon their preposterous
demand in respect to wages, have really no intention
of resuming work at present prices. Throughout the
Durham and Northumberland district, wherever the
pitmen's Union has been at work, the fire of discontent
is smouldering, and ready to break out into flame in
the event of the Union succeeding in its plans at
Messrs. Strikers and Love's collieries. On the face of
it, this general feeling of discontent would lead to the
supposition that the men feel that, either in respect
to the circumstances of the coal trade, or of the wages
of other descriptions of labour, they are underpaid.
But when we remember that the discontent is "got
up" by the well-understood machinery of a trades'
union, and that, by the same machinery, the pitmen
have been led into grievous errors, and have brought
upon themselves much suffering in times gone by, we
must be careful not to conclude that, because there is
wide-spread discontent, there is real cause for it. The
pitmen may depend upon this — that if there were
operating in their favour those circumstances which in
their case, as in that of every class of workmen, raise
the rate of wages, the masters could not, and, indeed,
would not, attempt to withhold from their men the
higher rate of wages which the ordinary laws decreed
were due to them. But that there are not these circumstances
operating in their favour is the testimony
which we hear on all hands ; and, in their
absence, the Miners' Union attempts to create an
artificial state of things which shall supply their place.
To that Union is to be attributed all the trouble
which has arisen between Messrs. Strakers and their
workmen, with no circumstances to justify it ; and,
should it succeed in causing a general strike, at its door
will lie all the evil which the strike will bring upon
the pitmen, and all the inconvenience it will bring
upon the public. To such a strike things are at present
tending ; though that is not the purpose of the
Union. Their present purpose is to take each colliery
in detail ; and they have begun with Messrs. Strakers'
first, because these owners are under contracts containing
heavy damages for non-fulfilment; so that
they dare not allow their collieries to stand idle ;
and, secondly, because their works are so extensive
that if the Unionists can manoeuvre so as to get higher
prices there, they can succeed, in like manner, at
every other colliery in the district. There is, therefore,
a kind of duel being fought between Messrs.
Strakers and their workmen, and if it were to be
decisive of a quarrel in which two large parties are
contending, it might be viewed with complacency,
in consideration that though it might bring suffering
and loss to the parties engaged in it, it would
prevent infinitely greater suffering and loss to a
much larger number of persons at present in comfort
and peace. But that, unfortunately, is not
the case. On the contrary, the pitmen's Union
has planned a great battle, which is to be fought
piecemeal — the war being waged at one colliery as
soon as it is ended at another. One result, therefore,
if the Union should succeed in gaining a victory
over Messrs. Strakers and Love, would be that it
would be the commencement of a state of chronic
warfare between the masters and men in the whole of
the pit districts. Every person, out of the committee
of the Miners' Union, must deprecate the
design of bringing about such a deplorable state of
relations between masters and workmen. It would be
disastrous to all immediately concerned ; and the
general public of the whole North of England would
be injuriously affected by it. In resisting its introduction,
Messrs. Strakers are doing a public service ;
and every person interested in the welfare of this
district must wish them success.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Love, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Strakers, — | | Mine Owner | |