Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

7th November 1863, Page: 5, Column: 2

Weekly Retrospect

The Pitmen's Strike

We are sorry to observe the strike still continues among the colliers in the employ of the Messrs. Strakers and Love, in the Auckland district. We are not friendly to strikes in general. Like war or revolutions, they are evils to be deprecated and avoided by all means possible. But in some instances these evils may be in a measure forced upon men, as the least of two evils. In fact we must deny the right of self-defence, or that there is any virtue in patriotism or in acts of self-devotion and heroic courage, which form the proudest portions of a nation's history and boast of humanity, ere we can condemn indiscriminately the conduct of these pitmen. The right of organization and open meeting in a peaceable and orderly way, for the discussion of political objects or social grievances, is the undoubted right, as we have said before, of every Englishman. The action that may result from such discussion may be wise or unwise, right or wrong, according to circumstances. And those persons certainly should have a clear case to justify themselves to whom war, or civil insurrection, or a strike (which is a form of social war between employers and employed) is undertaken as the only dreadful alternative between them and worse evils. We have thought it due to these colliers in the outset to state clearly this doctrine, upon which the whole of our glorious constitution and the rights of Englishmen are founded, inasmuch as we have observed in some of the correspondence and strictures of the press much ignorant declamation on this subject. There can be no question, then, that the men have a right to combine, and a right which may become a positive duty, to strike under certain given circumstances. But as we have put it, it is necessary to show grounds of justification — that it was in fact the only alternative, and the less of two evils, before such an extreme right should be exercised. Before committing themselves to such a course it, is also necessary to count the cost, to be prepared to make the sacrifices necessary to attain their object. It won't do — it would betray a mean and dastardly spirit for men to provoke an attack from a foe, and instead of bearing his blow and returning it with interest, to meanly skulk and hide themselves, or make rather whining appeals to the pity of the bye-standers. That pity, or sympathy rather, will always be accorded by Englishmen to a gallant though weaker party in a contest, all the more that it is the weaker party. Such is a cause of much of that sympathy that is shown by the English public for the Confederate States of America, though not universally approving the justice of their cause. But if anything is calculated to excite an Englishman's disgust, it is an appeal to public sympathy for the consequences of a man's own deliberate and voluntary acts. We trust the pitmen will not commit this error, but if they will fight, fight it out like men. Let us have no miserable whining, no stupid declaiming on the "cruelty" of the Masters in turning them out of doors. They might have expected this, for the houses were not their own. They had accepted the living in the cottages as part of the condition or hire of their service. The masters had clearly as much right to resume possession of their property as the men to withhold their labour. The men exercised their right — we do not say at present, whether properly or improperly, in suddenly and without notice stopping their work, and certainly they ought to have foreseen and provided for such a contingency as their forcible ejectment from their dwellings. They had clearly no right there a moment longer ; and men of proper spirit would not have remained on sufferance of their musters, or waited for the ignominy and degradation of being turned out of doors. The moral triumph in the eyes of the public would have been complete on the side of the masters, if they had only exercised a little patience and wise forbearance. The pitmen would have soon been sensible that they held an untenable position. In a little time they would either have resumed work, perhaps with a few mutual concessions, or at all events, none could have justly accused the masters of harshness and undue haste, and vindictive feeling, if they had given the men a little time to consider, and reasonable notice to quit, if they could not agree on terms. But the procedure to an eviction on so short a notice, and in very bad weather, we do still think, though strictly just, did wear an appearance of harshness and haste, and was calculated, apart from the merits of the quarrel, to embitter the feeling between masters and men, render more hopeless the chance of compromise, and excite the sympathies of an impartial public. We are glad to see the voice of public opinion, through the Press, has so far had an influence on the masters, if not better feelings of humanity, for which we should have no unwillingness to credit them, that for the present these "evictions" have been stayed. The voice of public opinion must also now be made to bear upon the men. We warn them, having no interest in either party, further than in the interest of justice and humanity — we would warn the pitmen, as their best friends and well-wishers — desirous that they should obtain every just and honourable demand, and with every consideration of their just rights — we solemnly warn them that if they continue on strike, and persist in remaining in possession of their cottages beyond the reasonable time now accorded them by their proprietors, they will forfeit all title to respect or sympathy whatsoever. They will have to endure the indignity of being turned out, and all the lamentable consequences of their own obstinacy and stupidity. This has nothing to do with the question of their right to strike, or whether they had a reasonable and just ground for taking that course. Addressing ourselves to this question, we still think, as we have thought all along, that there were grievances with respect to "forfeitures," which were a sufficient ground for justification of a strike, provided other means had been first tried, and failing these, on a due notice to terminate the contract. We are aware, as the trials at Auckland and Durham proved, that these contracts, terminable at a fortnight's notice on either side, had been so capriciously and uncertainly acted on, as to be of no legal value to the owners. But though they could not be legally enforced, they were certainly morally binding on both men and masters. A man may be legally right, and yet morally wrong, in other words unfair and dishonest. And so we think the conduct of the pitmen in taking advantage of the looseness of the bond in a sudden and unwarranted strike was unfair to the masters, and so far, whatever justice there may be in the complaint, they put themselves out of court, and this foolish and precipitate act is calculated to militate against their obtaining their just rights.

Still, complicated as the controversy is with such matters, and excited as may be the evil passions of the two parties in dispute, if there be any force in public opinion, or any remains of sense or right Christian feeling in either party, we should not despair of seeing this painful matter brought to a satisfactory and amicable conclusion. We see nothing to hinder it. Admitting, with the owners, that it is a mere whim or pretext of the men claiming weight instead of measure in the tubs, their very unwillingness to grant the concession must necessarily imply that it is not after all so much a matter of indifference, and there must be a lurking suspicion that the forfeitures or "set out" tubs are somehow giving an unfair advantage to the owners. If the owners only want what is fair and honest, weight ought certainly to be the standard. It is so in most other collieries. The contrary system they well know to be an infringement of the law. And if Messrs. Strakers and Love choose to act illegally, and are themselves the first authors of this unhappy misunderstanding, we do not see that their quarrel is one which is necessarily identified with that of other coal owners and capitalists. They are neither entitled, nor as yet, so far as we have seen, have they obtained, or are likely to obtain, either sympathy or assistance in this quarter any more than from the general public. Indeed we interpret the act or offer of the Messrs. Pease to grant wood to the families evicted to build huts, as at once a beautiful example of Christian charity and a protest of another large coal owner against the conduct of the Messrs. Strakers and Love.

We must add one word more before we take leave of this painful subject. In justice to themselves let the pitmen unitedly say in some accredited document what are their claims. The masters say it is not the question of weight or measure, but an advance of 25 or 30 per cent — have they made any such demand ? There have been so many statements and counter-statements on this subject, and on the proportion of tubs forfeited — the objects to which their proceeds were applied — and the average rates of remuneration, that the public are more mystified than ever, and there is need for an authoritative statement on these subjects to enable the public to come to a right conclusion respecting them. We should certainly take the word of Mr. Love for what it is worth, that is to say, of no more than equal value, if unsupported, to the word of the united body of the pitmen.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Love, Joseph    Mine Owner  



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
24 Oct 1863  The Agitation In The Colliery Districts (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 Oct 1863  Local And District News (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 Oct 1863  The Pitmen's Strike At Durham (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
07 Nov 1863  Weekly Retrospect, The Pitmen's Strike (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
07 Nov 1863  The Pitmen's Strike, Thursday, The Men Refuse To Accept The Master's Offer (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
21 Nov 1863  The Strike of Colliers in Durham (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
28 Nov 1863  The Colliers' Strike in Durham (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
16 Jan 1864  Committal Of Eight Pitmen For Rioting (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
23 Jan 1864  Pitmen's Soiree (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
06 Feb 1864  The Late Strike (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
13 Feb 1864  Meeting Of Pitmen At Framwellgate Moor (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print