|
18th June 1863 The Late Catastrophe at Cleator Moor(From The Mining Journal.)The inquest upon the bodies of the four persons who lost their lives by suffocation through want of ventilation in the Whitehaven Hematite Iron Company's No. 2 Pit, at Cleator Moor, as resulted in an announcement by the foreman of the jurors (after an enquiry whether they could return an immediate verdict between accidental death and manslaughter) that they had found a verdict of "Accidental Death,' but would recommend the coal proprietors to keep a more efficient staff of overmen to carry out the colliery rules properly;" but as the coroner, Mr. Wm. Lumb, jun., refused to embody the recommendation, on the ground that it was no part of the duty of the jurors to make any recommendation, the verdict stands on record as one of "Accidental Death" only, which, may we add, was received with hisses by as crowded court. It is impossible to read the evidence taken without feeling intense dissatisfaction at the result; and we have no hesitation in saying that had the coroner been ready to enlighten the jurors, as coroners usually are, it is probable that a very different verdict would have been recorded. We maintain that the coroner's reply to the foreman upon his statement, "there are some gentlemen of the jury who wish to know whether we can return an immediate verdict — that is, a verdict between accidental death and man slaughter," was undoubtedly evasive, and calculated to lead the jurors to infer, to say the least, that such a course was impossible. The enquiry was one which would very probably suggest itself to a jury empanelled to give a verdict in a case like the present, where there was no question that the ventilation was insufficient, but where at the same time, the immediate cause of the deaths concerning which the inquest was held had probably resulted rather from the general laxity of the system than from individual culpability in the precise case in question. In reply to the enquiry, the coroner observed — "The verdict is your own. You must arrive at such a verdict as the evidence brought before you warrants. No one has a right to interfere with you, nor have I any right to dictate to you what your verdict should be. I explained the law to you as well as I could, but if you want any further explanation I shall be very glad to give it. I cannot say a word to you as to what your verdict should be. That is your own particular province, and should be given according to the evidence." Now we believe that under ordinary circumstances such evasive replies would have been replaced by the information we asked for. If the jurors felt that the deaths were not purely the result of accident, but that there was not sufficient evidence to justify the conviction of any individual of manslaughter, there are various ways in which that verdict could be recorded, and we opine that not one coroner in a dozen could be found who would object to give the jurors the benefit of his knowledge, so as to enable them to word their verdict to agree with their opinion. We the more regret that with regard to the framing of the verdict Mr. Lumb should have been so particularly reserved and evasive, because from the impartial manner in which he conducted the inquiry generally, even his opponents could not have complained that the verdict was likely to be affected by his ruling; but from the discussion which took place after the summing up there seems great reason to fear that the verdict recorded conveys but very inadequately the views of which the jury entertained respecting the extent to which the accident was attributable to culpability in connection wit the management of the pit. Cleator Moor — The Late Verdict. (To The Editor Of The Mining Journal.) Sir, — The tenor of the evidence seemed to hold that the drift prosecuting between No. 2 Pit and Hope Pit was ventilated in so very novel and impractical a manner that it was insufficient to carry off the gas produced by the coal, and in consequence of the poor men being allowed to enter they lost their lives. Now although by the indifference of the overman and deputise the colliery rules were broken, yet the grand question appertained to the plan and principle upon which the drift was conducted, under the guidance of Mr. Forster and Mr. Bailes, for it has been expressively stated by the directors that the former was the manager and guider of the whole system; and now that the system has broken down we learn that all must stand still till' some extensive changes are made. If a verdict of manslaughter had been persisted in, who could it have been laid upon but the above parties? Querist.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||