|
13th June 1863, Page: 5, Column: 2 Steam Coal For The Royal NavyWe published last week particulars of another effort that has been made by the coal-owners of the Tyne to induce the Board of Admiralty to use Northumberland steam coal in the Royal Navy and Dockyards. One of the great objections which have ben raised by the authorities to its use is the immense quantities of thick black smoke which it evolves while burning. But the last experiments that were conducted with a view to ascertain the relative value for steam purposes of Welsh and North country coal, established the fact that a mixture of the two varieties yielded no smoke whatever, and was, in many respects, greatly superior to either variety used by itself. These experiments took place under official inspection in Woolwich dockyard, and on board the ships Cumberland and African, in the summer of 1860 ; official reports of the same being in due course presented to both Houses of Parliament. The coal-owners of Northumberland expected that, with these facts before them, the Board of Admiralty would have favoured the northern steam coal field with a share of their orders. The anticipation was not, however, realised, and last summer a memorial from the Tyne was sent to Somerset House, setting forth the results of the inquiry and pointing out the injustice to this district of the unwarrantable partiality shown to the coalowners of Wales. The Duke of Somerset promised, not merely — as had often been done before — that the matter should be attended to, but he undertook to see that the mixture had a fair trial, and bound himself and his colleagues to abide by the result. A year has passed away — the Duke's promise has not been kept, and the principal supplies of coal to the Government are still derived from South Wales. Under these circumstances our local coalowners have again respectfully called the attention of the Admiralty to the matter, reminded the Duke of his promise and engaged to show that if the authorities are really desirous of obtaining the best and most serviceable article for Her Majesty's service, they must adopt the mixture used in 1860 at Woolwich, and favour the north with a large share of Government custom. Mr. Lindsay, one of the members for Sunderland, has also written to the Board, informing them that in his own ships and in the vessels of the Peninsular and Oriental Steam Navigation Company a mixture of Welsh and north country coals has long been in use and is found to have all the economical effect claimed for it by the northern vendors. The result of this latest effort to obtain justice is that the Admiralty have ordered fresh official experiments to be made on board various steam vessels in order to ascertain the real value of the combination, and although they say nothing about the course they will adopt if the result should be as favourable to the coal of this district as our neighbours assert it will be, we think they cannot for very shame refuse to give northern coal a greater prominence on their lists than it has hitherto received. Apart from local considerations this question of the relative superiority of Welsh and Northumberland steam coal is of great importance. It is not a mere squabble between rival tradesmen, it is a question seriously affecting the interests of the country at large. Immense quantities of coal are purchased annually for the use of the royal navy, and it is in the highest degree necessary that it should be obtained of the best quality and on the most favourable terms. If the preference for the Welsh steam coal to the exclusion of all others which has prevailed at the Admiralty be founded upon erroneous data a serious national loss is every year sustained — a loss of money, time, and efficiency. That that preference is erroneously founded has been shown over and over again. The Admiralty transferred their orders to Wales upon the strength of a report presented to Parliament by Dr. Lyon Playfair and the late Sir Henry de la Beche. Those gentlemen asserted as the result of careful trials that the steam coal of South Wales was within a fraction of three per cent. better than the steam coal of Northumberland, and the Admiralty believed them. North country coal owners were certain that Dr. Playfair and Sir H. de la Beche had made a mistake and they told the Admiralty so, but the authorities were not to be reasoned out of the opinion they had formed. However, in 1858, Mr., now Sir William G. Armstrong, Mr. Longridge, C.E. and Dr. Richardson, while testing various plans sent in competition for a prize of £500 offered by the Northumberland Steam Collieries Association to the inventor of the best apparatus for consuming smoke, were able to show that the geologist and the philosopher had been quite at sea in their calculations — that their figures were inaccurate, their formulas wrong and their conclusions, consequently, misleading. Dr. Playfair, indeed, admitted the incorrectness of his experiments and alleged the unsuitability of the apparatus which was used by his colleague and himself as a reason for the discrepancies which Messrs. Armstrong, Longridge, and Richardson had pointed out. Every subsequent experiment has confirmed the facts which the prize trials established, namely, that wherever the merits of the two varieties of coal have been put to the test, fairly and conscientiously, the north country mineral has proved to be the better, and that a mixture of the two in equal proportions is superior to either when consumed alone. All these facts have been insufficient to induce the Admiralty to use our coal. They will not be convinced, and they manage to procrastinate and evade a thorough and honest inquiry with as much ingenuity as though each member owned a Welsh royalty and half his revenues depended upon the maintenance of the monopoly. The result of the inquiry promised in the letter which we published last week will depend very much upon the manner in which the northern coal owners look after their own interests. If they allow the experiments to be made in a private sort of way by naval officers and servants of the Admiralty they may confidently expect an unfavourable issue. Nearly all these subordinate officials have a strong bias in favour of the Welsh coal, and they will conduct the trials in a perfunctory manner and with a foregone conclusion. This disposition was plainly manifested in the very last competitive experiments that the Admiralty caused to be made. The Welsh coal used was that of Ebbu Vale — a bituminous mineral like our own, instead of a true specimen of the ordinary coal which bears the name of the Principailty, while the trials were made with a Cornish land boiler — a form of construction peculiarly adapted to show off the advantages of Welsh coal — instead of the multitubular boiler attached to marine engines. It is plain, therefore, that the officials of the Admiralty are not to be trusted alone with important experiments of this nature. The trials should be made in the presence of inspectors appointed by both the competing parties, who should see that the machinery employed is not of a special or peculiar class, but the ordinary apparatus used in the service, and that the mineral consumed is a pure and perfect specimen of the produce of the locality from which it professes to come — such in fact as would be supplied if the Government purchased it from the pit's mouth. We advise the northern coalowners to look to this matter. Our steam collieries are languishing for want of employment, and the interests at stake are of sufficient importance to warrant special and extraordinary exertions. If the coalowners of Northumberland choose to bestir themselves they can this time secure an impartial and reliable inquiry, and we are confident that the result of such an inquiry will be favourable to their claims. Should these claims afterwards remain unrecognised other steps can be taken, for there is sufficient parliamentary interest in this wealthy and intelligent district to influence even an obstinate and self-willed Board of Admiralty. But the coalowners must not be idle.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||