|
30th May 1863, Page: 5, Column: 5 Northumberland And District BankMeeting Of CreditorsOn Thursday, a public meeting of the creditors of the District Bank was held in the Long Room of the Queen's Head, Newcastle, "in order to consider the course to be adopted with reference to the proposed sale of the Derwent Iron Works, and other properties, and on other business." C. F. Hamond, Esq., chairman of the Creditors' Committee — who was accompanied by Mr. Hodge, the creditors solicitor — presided. The Chairman said he had called that meeting as chairman of the Creditors Committee, on account of an application made in Chancery, with the view of advertising the Derwent Iron Company's Works for sale. Perhaps Mr. Hodge had better read the notice which had been served upon the committee with reference to the application. Then he would explain to the meeting how the Derwent Works had progressed since the failure of thy Bank, and then propose a resolution which the committee had authorised him to propose. Mr. Hodge — An application was made about a fortnight ago by persons who had an interest in the works, for an order for the sale of the works from the Vice-Chancellor. We thought it was premature to agree to a sale without more consideration. The gentlemen employed to value the works — namely, William Armstrong and John Mackenzie — some months ago delivered to the liquidators their report. It was not till two or three weeks ago that a copy of that valuation was submitted to me as representing the creditors. I communicated with the committee, and gave them a copy. It was deemed right that an application should be made that further proceedings should be delayed. It stood over till to-morrow, when the application will be renewed by the liquidators and trustees acting for the settlement of the limited company — when, unless some proceeding is taken by the creditors as the result of this meeting, undoubtedly an order will be made for a sale of the works. It was thought that the creditors should have an opportunity of expressing their sentiments on the whole question — whether this is a desirable time for selling the works, and whether it is desirable to act on the valuation given of these works. These were the circumstances which induced the committee to think it desirable that the creditors should have the opportunity of expressing their opinion — feeling that the property now sought to be sold is almost the only remaining asset of the bank, and that it depended very much on the manner in which the works and property should be sold whether the creditors would get 20s. in the pound. This induced Mr. Hamond and the committee, for whom I act, to convene this meeting. (Applause). The Chairman — I shall place before your notice three distinct subjects. The first is the Derwent Iron Company ; next the position of Mr. Jonathan Richardson ; and, next, the position of E. O. Tregellis and Co., the gentlemen represented now by Jonathan Richardson and Sons. I shall commence from the failure of the bank, show the position of the Derwent Works at that time, and trace it up to the present time. I must tell you that whatever information I give you on the matter is not hearsay; it is information which I have myself obtained by the files of the Vice-Chancellor's Court — information sworn to on oath by the liquidators that have had the management of our property. Therefore there cannot be a question of its accuracy. However startling it may appear, still it is the naked truth. Therefore you will be able to judge for yourselves when I tell you what the result will be if your property is advertised for sale. The last meeting of the bank directors was held in December, 1857, of which George Ridley was chairman. I mean the last meeting when the directors of the bank met the shareholders, Mr. Ridley among other things made use of these works, "We are now able to announce that after an allowance is made for the high rate of interest charged Mr. Jonathan Richardson has guaranteed the payment of nearly the whole of the debt (i.e. the Derwent Iron Company's debt), and considering the respectability and resources of the persons whose liability thereto remains unquestioned, the shareholders may reasonably consider the account as satisfactorily arranged. The re-payments, from the magnitude of the engagements, will extend over a lengthened period, but the amount will bear interest at 5 per cent. per annum. It is considered that this settlement has materially improved the position of the bank, and by giving this guarantee Mr. Richardson has shown in the strongest manner his conviction of the debt having throughout been ultimately secured. I may tell you that Mr. Richardson's guarantee was in effect an assignment of all his property to the bank on the 2nd of Dec., 1859, to secure the ultimate payment of his debt. I will tell you what is the debt. I am speaking of the old iron company. The amount was £753,166. That there may be no doubt I may tell you that this is a report signed by J. E. Coleman, and dated April 13, 1858. It is addressed to the liquidators, who were then voluntary liquidators. The liabilities on bills discounted, which were to rank on the estate, amounted to £194,756; so that when Mr. Ridley informed the shareholders that the debt might be considered as being satisfactorily arranged, the iron company owed the bank £947,922. But out of this sum £147,000 were due to Messrs. Mounsey, Ianson, and Co., on accommodation bills, for which they had a lien on all the manufactured stock as security for the ultimate payment of those bills — the old company having agreed to pay them off in three years, the liquidators paying dividends to the holders of these bills, between the above date of April 13, 1858, and April 27, of the same year, a dispute arose between some of the shareholders and the liquidators, which was referred to the Lord Justices, and they sent down Mr. Coleman to make an investigation. He made a report on the 27th Feb., in which he confirms the statement that the old company are able to pay £50,000 a year and upwards in payment of their debt. That is a copy of the report supplied to me from the Vice-Chancellor's Court. It is a deposition dated the 27th April — the deposition of James E. Coleman, the accountant employed by the voluntary liquidators. Therefore, whatever I say under this head cannot be disputed, because it is information supplied to me by Mr. Coleman himself on oath. He tells you that the company are well able to pay £50,000. In fact he says — "They have agreed to pay £1,000 weekly, if necessary, but I think we ought to have much more;" and he thinks that the present arrangement as entered into between the directors and the old company is favourable for the shareholders, and ought not to be disturbed. He goes on further to say that he has investigated and examined into the entire affairs of Mr. Jonathan Richardson. He says — "I have seen a statement of Mr. Richardson's property, and I believe Mr. Richardson to be worth a very large sum of money, which will be available to them in some form or other, and I deem it exceedingly impolitic to disturb the arrangement." Now, mark what follows. Shortly afterwards, Mr. Coleman gets himself appointed a liquidator, and then he joins his co-liquidators in a proposal to the Court of Chancery. Here is the proposal. It is dated 31st of July, 1858, and it is confirmed by the Court on 14th of August, 1858. It is signed by Mr. Coleman and his three colleagues — Mr. Bainbridge, Mr. Elliott, and Mr. Fairs. In it they don't allow the favourable arrangement which only in the month of April Mr. Coleman said ought not to be disturbed, but they propose to take from the old Derwent Iron Company their whole property : and then they propose to transfer it to 43 shareholders of the bank, who have to pay £575,000 for the purchase of the works — £150,000 to be paid in cash. I will not allude to the bargain about acquitting those shareholders from their liabilities, because I wish to confine myself to the points in question. They have to pay £575,000 for the purchase of the works, £75,000 of which was the amount which Mr. Coleman thought proper to charge on account of these acceptances of Mounsey, Ianson, and Co. The Stockton and Darlington and North Eastern Railway Companies had to give the limited iron company credit for five years, to the amount of £200,000, in this way :— suppose the leading of the ironstone belonging to the iron company was to amount to so much per year, and in five years it reached £400,000, the two railway companies were to give them credit to the amount of one-half the dues, in order that £200,000 might be paid to the creditors of the bank. This arrangement was sanctioned by the Court, and an agreement was ordered to be brought in in accordance therewith. But they don't bring in an agreement founded on the contract. They were to receive in cash £150,000, which left £425,000, and, as a security for the payment of the sum, the limited company had to transfer the works and property as a mortgage security to the liquidators ; they having the five years to pay the sum of £425,000, and no interest being paid on that sum. Then, instead of bringing in a contract or an agreement founded on it, another most remarkable contract is introduced, dated 22nd November, and signed by J. F. Elliott, Wm. Bainbridge, and J. E. Coleman. Here they propose another alteration, and you will see how it works in your favour. The £425,000 mortgage is no longer to be a mortgage ; but there are certain gentlemen who appear for the first time, and who are called the Darlington creditors. It appears that when the bank stopped payment, Messrs. Pease, who supplied the old Derwent Iron Company with ironstone, and were making a profit of £10,000, had owing to them a balance of £4,620; and the Stockton and Darlington Railway Company, who were making £100,000 a-year, had a balance due to them of £32,975. Then there was a third party, the Messrs. Backhouse, who at the time of the failure wanted £18,000 — making in round numbers about £55,000. But these parties held no security, and a pretty arrangement was come to with them, the effect of which was that instead of your having a mortgage for £425,000 on the works, the property was first of all handed over to the Derwent Iron Company limited. All leasehold property that could be changed into freehold was so changed, and after this change was effected, which would have been favourable to you had you continued sole mortgagee — the liquidators allow these unsecured creditors to become co-mortgagees with yourselves, but be it observed in the proportion of £55,000 to £425,000. They knock off £95,000 from your £425,000, and then they are made equal mortgagees with you in the proportion of £55,000 to £330,000, putting £95,000 as a second mortgage, which you will never be able to get until the Darlington creditors get their £55,000. In addition to this, it was proposed that the Stockton and Darlington Railway Company should pay us £50,000, for three years, out of their leading, so that at the end of three years we should have received £150,300 from that company, and the liquidators had to give them bonds for the amount, as it might be paid, the payments being at the rate of about £4,000 per month. Then, also under this deed they allow Mr. Jonathan Richardson a release from his liabilities for the sum of £100,000 — they release him from that guarantee which Mr. Coleman said was worth a large sum of money. But they also make him a very nice present. On the failure of the bank in November, 1857, and December, 1859, when the limited company took the position of Mr. Jonathan Richardson, they put that gentleman in as manager of the Derwent Iron Works for those two years ; and Mr. Jonathan Richardson draws the sum of £94,979 out of the Derwent Iron Works, and with this he walks off. Under this new proposal of 1859 the liquidators make him a present of this sum — they ask him not to account for it. So that, first of all, you want £753,000 from the Derwent Iron Company ; then Mr. Coleman destroys the arrangement with the liquidators, and they sell the works for £575,000, thus incurring a loss of near £200,000. And the second deed still further destroys that arrangement by taking off £95,000, and only leaving you the chance of getting £330,000. But they go further. An application was made by Mr. C. Allhusen, as chairman of the limited company, telling the liquidators that the company had no capital, and asking to be allowed to have the iron which they had released from Messrs. Mounsey and Co. The liquidators acceded to the application. The iron was handed over to the limited company without any additional security being given or demanded, and without a farthing being paid for it. There it remains in the general stock. I will now show you what money you have received from the liquidators. Up to the present time the Stockton and Darlington Railway Company have paid £64,000 on account of the £150,000 which it was arranged they should pay, and which, failing such payment, was secured by the covenant of Messrs. Pease. This is the only payment you have received from the Derwent Iron Company since November, 1849, and deducting the amount, you have £361,000 still due; to which must be added the further sum of £200,000, as before stated, making a total of £561,000. Then there is a further account with the Derwent Iron Company. Mr. Richardson has handed over to the liquidators his Bradley estate and iron furnaces, which were valued at £60,000. The liquidators handed this over to the limited company, who had nothing, they giving their acceptances for the amount, which are now lying dishonoured, further on we have some shareholders who wished to be released from their liabilities. They had to pay £104,000, the liquidators taking 864 cottages and some collieries for £61,000. These also were handed over to the limited iron company, and these acceptances are still dishonoured. This sum must be added to the debt; so that altogether the limited company owe you £680,000. This is a statement of facts as they appear in these reports, supplied to us by the Court of Chancery themselves. They are now making from £30,000 to £40,000 a year. The liquidators seem to think that we are all millionaires, and that Messrs Pease and Backhouse are the poor people, for they have not asked them for any money. The works are now under the management of a person who has his own way in what he does, and this will be for the ultimate stability and advantage of the works. I allude to Mr. Jonathan Priestman, jun. I believe it is mainly through his management that even in this depressed state of the iron trade the works yield the amount of profit which I have stated. These works have been kept in repair, out of our money, and they now ask us to sell these works on a valuation which I dare not tell you — it is of so extraordinary a character. A Creditor — Let us have it; out with it. The Chairman — I don't think, under present circumstances that I, at least as chairman of the committee, should divulge it. I only state in general terms that the committee are startled at the valuation and the mode of the valuation. I don't want to attribute motives to any one, but the works appear to have been valued all in one way and for one purpose. I can tell you it is a valuation that will not bring you much in the pound. A Creditor — State the amount of money. The Chairman — I don't think I should. If I were to divulge it, the liquidators would go to the Vice-Chancellor and say that I had jeopardized the sale of the works; that I had done my best to injure the works and that nobody would bid for them. Again in the valuation the properties are so mixed up that you would not know which was your own and which was the property of the Darlington creditors. These creditors have nothing to do with Bradley estate nor with the cottages. We have always maintained that these should be valued separately; but they are all jumbled together, and the cottages are put out of sight, though they yield some £4,000 a-year rental. Now, I will turn a little to Mr. Jonathan Richardson. If we were to allow the authors of all this misery to escape I think we shall not be doing our duty. I have told you that the bank directors had procured a guarantee of all his property, and in November, 1859, Mr. Coleman and his co-liquidators proposed that this man should be let off on payment of £100,000, taking a mortgage on the Bradley estate, and at the same time making him a present of £94,000. Mr. Jonathan Richardson has paid us £26,000 out of this £100,000. Five years have elapsed and we have got no more. Therefore Jonathan Richardson owes us £74,000; and it is my intention to propose a resolution in regard to this which I hope you will carry unanimously, and which I hope will be the means of compelling the payment of the sum which he now owes (applause). He is now rusticating somewhere, but whether with a quiet mind or not shall not presume to say. Then with regard to E. O. Tregelles and Co. This was a firm started by Mr. Jonathan Richardson. They were relations of his, and they were now represented by his two sons. At the failure of the bank, they owed £10,787. You have probably heard that they have never paid this money, and they have failed with debts amounting to from £70,000 to £90,000. Why have the liquidators never demanded this money! The only reason I can think of is that they are the sons of Jonathan Richardson — that there is something concealed, and that the liquidators dare not demand it. I want to bring this to an issue. I will now allude to another circumstance, that of an application made in June, 1861, for an extension of the time of payment for three years; and Mr. Coleman has stated that if that extension had been granted, the creditors would have received 3s in the pound more than they have received. The application for this extension of time was founded on the affidavit of Mr. David Dale. I must explain one thing. When the Darlington creditors were admitted co-mortgagees, the liquidators admitted two trustees, on account of these creditors, in case of the Derwent Iron Company not meeting their engagements, and works having to be sold. It is these gentlemen who are now applying for a sale of the works. One is Mr. J. Whitwell Pease, and the other is his factotum, Mr. David Dale. Mr. Dale gave his reasons for asking an extension of time. He said — "I am strongly of opinion that the desired extension should be granted, and I believe that no impartial man of business having a knowledge of the iron trade will dissent from the policy of such extension, having regard to the enormous sacrifice that would arise if the works were sold at a period of depression, and to the fluctuations of the trade which justify expectations of prosperity ensuing." (Hear, hear.) Again, he says — "I have recently had an interview with the North-Eastern Railway directors, who informed me that they were prepared concurrently with an extension of three years to give the iron company certain credit on the dues to the extent of £50,000." The creditors committee have no wish to sell the works, and they offered to assent to an extension of time for three years, provided the Stockton and Darlington Railway Company kept up their payments and the iron company consented to pay to the bank creditors any profits they might make. The North Eastern Railway Company behaved like gentlemen. There was one gentleman whose name I was not at liberty to divulge at the time, but I have now his permission to do so, — who took an active part in the negotiation — Mr. R. P. Philipson. (Applause.) The North Eastern Company would have made their payments, but Messrs. Pease and Dale would not allow the Stockton and Darlington Company to pay one penny more unless they had a preferential security over the North Eastern. How, then, can Mr. Coleman have the impertinence to state that we should have got 3s. in the pound more if this extension of time had been granted. He must either have spoken what he knew to be an untruth, or else he must have been totally ignorant of what he was talking about. Well, gentlemen, are you prepared to assent to these works being advertised for sale ? If you are, I shall be glad to be relieved from the anxiety and exertion which my duties as chairman of your committee impose on me. But whilst thanking you for your courtesy and the confidence reposed in me, I shall regret that you have taken a course which will put it in the power of man to put his hand on your property and take it. We know that the works are in a sound condition, that they are under prudent management, and that they are bringing in nearly £40,000 a-year. If we should happily see an end of this war that is going on in America that £40,000 would soon become £120,000. My advice is that, if you do consent to a sale, the valuation should be submitted to competent authority. Yesterday important negotiations were commenced with regard to those works, which I hope will lead to such a conclusion as will obviate the necessity of their being sold at all. There are gentlemen in this town — I am not at liberty to mention their names — who are taking the matter up with earnestness and zeal, and I believe their efforts will be crowned with success. But if not, then will be the time to consent to some arrangement for the works, after we have seen that the arrangement is just to ourselves, and especially that the different properties are not mixed up with each other. This, gentlemen, is the resolution which I am authorised on the part of the committee to submit to your approval :— "That considering the extraordinary and unsatisfactory nature of the valuation of the Consett Iron Works, and other properties included therein, this meeting is desirous that the Vice-Chancellor should suspend all further proceedings with a view to a sale of the works, until the 7th day of August next, in order to give the creditors an opportunity of testing the correctness of the said valuation, and to enable the committee of creditors to carry out certain negotiations now pending, whereby the necessity for the sale of the Iron works would be avoided, and the creditors receive their debts in full. That the liquidators be instructed to request that the profits already made by the limited company be paid into the hands of the trustees. The meeting is surprised that the official liquidators have not hitherto taken any coercive measure against Jonathan Richardson for the recovery of the large balance now due from him to the liquidators; and resolves that the creditors committee be authorised to make an application to the Vice-Chancellor to order proceedings in Bankruptcy against him forthwith." If you carry this resolution. I believe you will get all your money from Mr. Jonathan Richardson, and you will get, if not the whole at all events a large portion of it, from the Derwent Iron Company. I believe that if the liquidators had taken proceedings long ago against Mr. Jonathan Richardson. I should not now have had the pain of addressing you. (Applause). Mr. Hopper seconded the resolution, which, on being put from the chair, was carried unanimously. The Chairman — Gentlemen, — The proceedings before the Vice-Chancellor take place tomorrow, at three o'clock. It will be necessary to enforce this resolution by the affidavit of the chairman. Is it your will and pleasure that I shall go there tonight? (Cheers). If it is your will and pleasure Mr. Hodge and I am quite willing to go up tonight and advocate it before the Vice-Chancellor. (Applause). Mr. Ferguson, of Sunderland, said they could not do better than leave the matter in the hands of Mr. Hamond and Mr. Hodge, and he begged to move a vote of thanks to the chairman for the very able and lucid manner in which he had laid the matter before the meeting. Another Creditor from Sunderland seconded the motion, which was carried by general acclamation. Mr. Hamond, in responding, said he had only one wish in the affair, that was that the creditors should now get their money, and that the guilty man who had caused its loss should be properly punished. As long as the creditors were pleased to honour him with their confidence he would continue to advocate their interests. (Applause.) The meeting then separated.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||