|
7th May 1863 Claim For WagesAnother Case From Hope PitJohn Currie, formerly a workman in Hope Pit, Cleator Moor, the property of the Hematite Iron Company, sued Mr. Bailes, the overman, for £1 10s 6d, wages alleged to be due. Mr. Webster appeared for the complainant, and Mr. Paitson for the defendant. Mr. Webster, in stating the case, said he appeared on behalf of the complainant, who had worked in Hope Pit, which belonged to the Hematite Iron Company, from the month of January last until the 10th of April, and during that time he had frequently occasion to find fault with the ventilation of the pit. Mr. Paitson: I object to the subject of ventilation being gone into. The charge is a claim for wages, and not for bad ventilation. The Clerk: Suppose it turns out that the defendant left his work without giving notice, then, if it can be made out that the pit was in such a dangerous state that he was afraid to work in it, that would relieve him from giving the proper notice. Of course, I am only assuming that to be the case. Mr. Webster continued: He should be able to prove that up to the 6th of April complainant had often complained of the bad ventilation of the pit and of the accumulation of gas in it. On the 6th of April he went down the shaft with Lee, the deputy overman, who went as far as the lock cabin with him. Complainant asked another deputy, named Dawson, if the place where he worked was fit to go into. He said he did not know, but that a man who had gone in would be able to tell him. Fortunately, complainant went into the working very carefully, but if he had not done so, the probability was that there would have been an explosion, there being such a large accumulation of gas. Complainant would tell them that the accumulation of gas extended ten yards from the face of the coal, and that there was about 120 cubic feet of it. Mr. Paitson: I must again object to Mr. Webster being allowed to go into that subject. It has nothing whatever to do with the case. It is altogether irrelevant; and I will appeal to Mr. Brockbank whether it is so or not. The Clerk: Well, I cannot tell whether it is irrelevant or not: but I quite agree with Mr. Paitson that it has nothing to do with the case: but it is impossible for the bench to say whether it is irrelevant or not. Mr. Webster said it was a very material point in the case, and insisted on conducting it as he thought proper. Mr. Paitson: Well I have often been told by the bench to confine myself to the point; but if Mr. Webster is to be allowed to go on like this, I shall consider it a precedent in future cases. The Clerk: But it does not follow that you should take this as a precedent in conducting other cases. Mr. Webster resumed: After the complainant discovered the gas in his working, he drew the wick of his lamp down, and came out of the working and reported the matter to the deputy-overman. A danger signal was then put up, and when Mr. Bailes and Mr. Forster went down the day after they found the signal up. The complainant did not work on that day nor the following; and in the meantime he saw Mr. Dunne the government inspector, and reported the dangerous state of the pit to him. Mr. Paitson said he had already listened to a great deal of nonsense from Mr. Webster, and he must again object to his going any further. Mr. Webster continued: Some bratticing was then put up, and on the Friday following Mr. Bailes went to the complainant in his working and asked him if he was one of the men who had reported that state of the pit to Mr. Dunne. Complainant replied that he had so: and then Mr. Bailes dismissed him, and ordered him to leave the colliery. Some discussion then took place between Mr. Bailes and Lee and Morris, the deputies, as to who had examined the complainant's working that morning it was found so full of gas. Mr. Bailes asked Lee if he had examined it, and he said he had not, and that he knew nothing about it. And upon Morris being asked the same question he replied that he had not examined it, and said that it ought to have been examined by another man named Wilson. That showed the irregularity with which the pit had been worked. Complainant then left the pit, and although Mr. Bailes and his overmen asked him to continue to work in it, he refused to do so, as he considered his life would be in danger. The wages he claimed were for yard money, gearing, and for tubs of coals worked. He had demanded his wages, but was refused them. Complainant was then called and deposed: I was in the employ of the Cleator Hematite Company from the 19th of January last until the 10th of April. The wages I now claim is for yard money, gear money, and coal money. The yard and gear money amount to 16s, and the rest is for coals. Mr. Paitson objected to the claim made for yard money. Examination continued: I have always been paid yard money. I charge for five pair of gears at 9d per pair. I have been paid yard money by Mr. Bailes, as well as being paid for the coals. I have frequently been prevented from working in the pit in consequence of the accumulation of gas. Mr. Paitson: What has that to do with the case? Mr. Webster: To show the reason why he left the pit. Mr. Paitson: He didn't leave; he was dismissed. Mr. Webster: Did you demand your wages? Complainant: Yes, I did; and they refused to give me them. The yard money was for work done between February and March, but I have not been paid for it. Mr. Bailes always promised to put it in; but he never did so. I have been paid for similar work before. Cross-examined: I got my notice of discharge on Friday the 10th of April. I occupied a home belonging to the company, and I left that house yesterday. I don't know that there is a rule which gives the company power to retain workmen's wages who are discharged until they give up the key of the house in which they live. Have you not been told that that was the case by Mr. Armstrong? — I think there's a little bit of a catch in that, Mr. Paitson. (Laughter) But has Mr. Armstrong never told you that the rule was that your wages would be retained until you gave up the key of the house? — I cannot recollect it. Mr. Paitson (producing a notice which stated that if a workman didn't leave his house in a fortnight after his discharge, they reserved the right of stopping his wages until the key was given up) Did you ever see a notice similar to this stuck up anywhere about the pit? — In which particular place? (Laughter) Well, have you ever seen one in the store house? — I may have seen one there, but I'm not sure. Have you ever been in the pay office? — Yes. Did you ever see a notice there? — I never took particular notice. The Clerk here observed that if Mr. Paitson could prove that defendant knew of that notice there was an end of the case, as the complainant had been premature in his application. Mr. Paitson said he would be able to prove it. Mr. Bailes was then called by Mr. Paitson and stated that the complainant had been in the employ of the Hematite Iron Company, and had been working in the Hope Pit. The conditions of his engagement were that if he was discharged fourteen days notice would be given him, and that if he left fourteen days notice would be taken. Complainant asked if he could have a house, and he told him he could have one on the usual terms by applying for it at the colliery office. He was told that if he didn't deliver up the key of the house a fortnight after he was discharged, his money would be retained. A copy of a notice to that effect was posted up in the store house, in the lobby leading to the offices, and also in other places where the workmen could not fail to see it. The wages due to the complainant amounted to 6s 6d, and they were ready for him as soon as he gave up the key to the house. There was no gas in the working where the complainant was when he was dismissed. Since that time 200 workmen had signed a memorial to Sir George Grey to say that the pit was quite safe. In reply to Mr. Webster, defendant said complainant had never complained to him about the money owing. He recollected the complainant coming to him about a house, but he could not recollect where it was, what day it was, or what time of day. Very few workmen came to him about the houses. They generally applied for the houses at the colliery office. In reply to the Chairman, Mr. Bailes said the reason complainant was dismissed was because he (Mr. Bailes) had been told that the complainant thought the pit was unsafe, and therefore had a decided objection to allow him to work in it, if he considered it was not safe. Mr. Webster said that the complainant was prepared to contradict what Mr. Bailes had said about the notice, and accordingly, on again being put in the box, he said Mr. Bailes never mentioned anything about the notice to him. Mr. Armstrong having given similar evidence to Mr. Bailes respecting the conditions, upon which the houses were let to the workmen of the pit, the bench, after a brief deliberation, dismissed the case.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||