|
26th February 1863 Serious Charge By Government Inspector Against the Hematite Iron CompanyMr. Matthias Dunn, Government Inspector of Mines for Durham, Northumberland, and Cumberland, appeared to support a complaint made by him against Mr. Bailes, viewer of the collieries worked by the Whitehaven Haematite Iron Company, alleging a breach of the statute in not having sufficiently provided for the ventilation of one of the pits. Mr. Webster appeared for the complainant, and Mr. W. Lumb, jun, for the defendant. Mr. John Thompson, Mr. John Postlethwaite, Mr. S. Lindow, Mr. R. Barker, and Mr. Jas. Lumb, director or partners of the Haematite Iron Co., were also in attendance. The court was crowded by a large body of colliers. Mr. Webster said he appeared for Mr. Dunn, who laid an information against the defendant under the 10th section of the 24th and 25th Victoria, c 151, the first rule of which provided for the adequate ventilation of mines under ordinary circumstances. So long ago as the 10th February 1862, Mr. Dunn called the attention of the directors of the Whitehaven Iron Company to the state of the pit in question. Shortly after an accident occurred in the very pit respecting which this inquiry was being made, whereby two men were killed. Mr. Dunn then called the attention of the directors to the improper working of their colliery, which was such as to hinder its sufficient ventilation, and to keep it free of gas. On the 11th of February last Mr. Dunn and Mr. Atkinson, a government inspector for the southern division of the county of Durham, who had been sent down to assist Mr. Dunn in his investigation, went down the mine, and found gas. They also found that the working places were not in such a state of repair as to allow of proper ventilation. They went into one man's place, and on applying the lamp it fired, and both gentlemen would prove that if a naked light had been exposed an explosion would have followed. They would also tell the bench that the bratticing was very thin, that Mr. Bailes himself said it was not in a very good state of repair, that the workings of the pit were of an unwarrantable width, and that the stoppings, which ought to have been of stone or brick, were of wood, and likely to leak. Mr. Webster then drew attention to clause 16 of the Act, defining the powers and duties of inspectors. He regretted that the course taken by the directors of this company had prevented Mr. Dunn from carrying out his inspections of the pits in the way he could of wished. He applied to them on the 27th January last that he might be accompanied by Mr. Steel, their former viewer. He believed the directors did not object but, on Mr. Steel and he going to the pit, the director's agent, Mr. Bailes did and consequently Mr. Dunn was obliged to go down the pit himself, and examine it as he liked. On the 2nd February he wrote a letter to Mr. Thompson, the managing director, requesting the company to be most careful in their examination of the tubs and ropes, and the following day, showing that his recommendation should have been attended to, the rope in Hope Pit broke, and caused considerable damage to the brattice down the shafts. In consequence of the conduct of the directors, Mr. Dunn wrote to Sir. G. Grey to have Mr. Atkinson sent down. Mr. Atkinson came, and the result was as he had before stated. The 22nd section of the Act gave the magistrates power to inflict a penalty not exceeding £20 for non-compliance with the requirements of the act. He might add that Mr. Dunn was prepared to lay different information's against this colliery, but he had selected this case, under the first rule. Mr. Dunn was examined by Mr. Webster. He said: I have been Government Inspector of Mines for the Northern part of the kingdom since 1850. I have had experience in working mines for 16 years before that time. In consequence of an accident at the Hope Pit in 1862, which arose from an explosion, and by which two men were killed, I saw Mr. Thompson, one of the company's directors. Having found the ventilation deficient, I recommended that the working, which was very high and wide, should be diminished one half. The width of the coal was four yards; the drift was 8 feet wide, and the full height of the seem. I think I had written a letter to Mr. Ireland, the then viewer of the colliery, upon the subject. — Mr. Lamb: We never received such letter, and know nothing about it. This is our first hearing of it. — Mr. Dunn: In January last I received a letter from one of the workmen. It refers in a degree to Hope Pit, but complains chiefly of the pit he was working in, which is No.2 pit. — Mr. Webster produced the letter in question. It follows:— Whitehaven, 12th January, 1863 Dear Sir, — I take the liberty of writing these few lines to let you know how I am and some others of my fellow workmen treated. We come every other day and cannot get into our workings, she is that full of damp, and the last four days I could not get within 20 yards of my place. I can assure you, sir, this day she would have fired in the lamp at the very flat, and because I said I would let the Government Inspector know about it I got my notice to leave the colliery. If you don't try and make them better ventilate the pit there will surely be one day another slaughter of human beings. She is in a sad state at present, and I informed the other pit is no better. This is at No. 2 Coal Pit, Cleator Moor, Cumberland. William Barratt, Coalminer, Queen St. Robinsin Fold, Whitehaven. From Mr. Mattias Dunn, Government Inspector of Mines. Mr. Dunn: In consequence of that letter I felt it my duty to come to the collieries, and make inquiry. I had an interview on the 21st January with Mr. Thompson, Mr. Postlethwaite, and Mr. Lindow. I entreated them not to allow the man to be discharged till they had ascertained whether his story was true or false. I cautioned them that they were taking a great responsibility on themselves. On the 22nd I had a letter from Mr. Thompson. [Letter produced by Mr. Webster.] It may be necessary for me to state that the first day I went to the colliery I did not find Mr. Bailes, and therefore sent for Mr. Taylor. This was on the 20th, the day before my interview with the directors. I questioned Taylor on the matter, and he said to me that Barratt had been discharged for bad language. Mr. Webster then read Mr. Thompson's letter referred to as follows: Haematite Iron Works, Whitehaven, 22nd Jan, 1863 Matthias Dunn, Esq. Sir, — In consequence of our interview with you yesterday our Directors have held a meeting this day at which Mr. Bailes was requested to attend. The result of an investigation is that the man Barratt was discharged for having used abusive language to Taylor, the overman of the pit, and that Taylor himself informed you of this fact to which you made no allusion yesterday, but which we certainly think you should have named when interceding on behalf of Barratt. We do not wish to enter into a long discussion, but we have to request that you will forthwith come and examine the colliery yourself, and we do no think the mere statement of a discharged workman (a mere trailer) a sufficient ground for the strong opinion you have expressed on the supposed dangerous state of our colliery, to this we have to add that Mr. Foster, we find, did visit the very working complained of. We much regret you did not visit the workings of No. 2 pit, which we learn you could easily have done by means of Whinney Hill pit. Had you done this we feel sure you would have expressed a very different opinion. Our directors are quite resolved on having the colliery thoroughly examined by a Government Inspector, and we have therefore to request that you will, at anytime you think proper, in that capacity make the necessary inspection. For the Whitehaven Iron Company and Self John Thompson Mr. Dunn: I wrote to Mr. Thompson, on the 24th, in reply, as follows:— Newcastle-on-Tyne, 14th, Jan 1863 John Thompson, Esq. Dear Sir, — I have received your letter and had already written to Mr. Bailes to request that his engineer would examine the two shafts preparatory to my coming up, which will be during the ensuing week. I decline entering upon discussion raised by Mr. Bailes. I feel that I dealt with you in the most candid and becoming manner, and will not say more at present. Yours &c., Matts. Dunn Mr. Thompson here observed that he did not get this letter of Mr. Dunn's till the 30th six days after. [The delay is explained by the postmarks on the envelope, which showed it to have travelled about in consequence of a misdirection.] Examination of Mr. Dunn continued: On the 26th or 27th, I returned to Whitehaven and Mr. Steel was with me. I had not seen the directors previously with respect to Mr. Steel. I saw Mr. Thompson and I said to him "I have brought Mr. Steel with me to assist me in my investigation; he is acquainted with the concern, and you and he parted good friends". Mr. Thompson admitted that they had parted good friends, and did not object to his going with me. I went with Mr. Steel to the colliery at Cleator Moor. I saw Mr. Bailes at the office there. Mr. Bailes objected to Mr. Steel going down the pit with me. He also objected to Barratt going down. I thought it was necessary to take them, because the pit was a stranger to me. By the 16th section of the act I have power to go down any coal mine in my district. — Mr. Webster: Do you think you have power to take assistance with you. — Mr. Lamb: I object to this question. The Clerk: it is a question of Law. — Mr. Webster did not repeat the question. — Examination resumed: I was obliged to go down the pit myself. I hesitated to do so because I believed the shaft was in a very dangerous state. When I got down the leading place was foul, and fired at a lamp. — Mr. Lamb: Was this in Hope Pit? — Mr. Dunn: No it was in No. 2 pit. — Mr. Lamb remarked that the present inquiry did not extend to No. 2 pit and the Chairman suggested that Mr. Webster had better confine his attention to the pit under investigation. — Mr. Webster agreed to do so. — Examination resumed: I proceeded down Hope Pit on the 11th February 1863. I had previously written to Sir G. Grey for assistance and, in consequence, Mr. Atkinson accompanied me. Mr. Bailes was with us. I had some conversation with Mr. Bailes, and speaking generally, he admitted that the bratticing in the shaft was deficient. The pit has a single shaft, the bratticing is its only safeguard, and its being deficient would prevent proper ventilation. Mr. Bailes did not say particularly how it was deficient; he spoke generally. In order to do what was necessary to put the shaft into better condition, I suggested to Mr. Bailes that it would be better to stop some of the night shifts to allow of it being done, and he said that it would. The bratticing was 1½ inch thick. It ought to be at least twice as thick. Ordinary bratticing is three inches thick. If an explosion has taken place that morning I don't think any of the people's lives could have been saved. In order to ascertain the amount of ventilation I desired Mr. Atkinson to bring an anemometer. The instrument would not work, in consequence of bad ventilation. I have certificated these special colliery rules as Government Inspector. There are several stoppings in this pit, some of which are of stone. The object of their being of stone instead of wood is to carry the air more effectually. When made of wood, they are not only difficult to keep air tight but they are liable to be blown in. I examined some of the wooden stoppings. To have such stoppings I believe is a violation of one of the special rules of the colliery. I found the air in the main roads very deficient for the purposes of ventilation, and the working were in much the same state as they were the year before. They had been working them too wide for the quantity of air they had to fill them. The consequence was that when the air got into a large space the current was not sufficient to drive out the gas. I have no doubt that that was dangerous to the work people. We went into one of the workings and desired that the man there would put his lamp up to the roof. He did so, and the gas exhibited itself inside the lamp, in other words fired at it. Had the light been naked there would have been an explosion, and the man in all probability burnt. This was a natural result of the bad ventilation, and I was not surprised to see it at all. They had curtains instead of doors at particular parts of the pit. These are not so effectual as doors. If an explosion were to take place ventilation would be destroyed; and the after damp would suffocate the people. There is a cavity sunk about two fathoms at the bottom of the shaft; and I think it desirable to have a road made about it in case of an accident, lest the men running with their lamps out to the eye of the pit should fall in. They have no lamp cabin or lamp locker. I examined many of the men's lamps at the pit top, and found some of them very bad. I am not aware that they keep a person on purpose to look the lamps. Have been informed to the contrary. Cannot exactly say who informed me, but had information from people about the pit. — Cross-examined by Mr. Lumb: I have not seen Barratt here to day; I did not ask him to come. I saw him at the pit on the 19th of January. His letter referred chiefly to No. 2 pit, which I did not go down then, because when I went there I found the engine broken. I went down that pit a week after. I was at Newcastle in the meantime; and I came back to Whitehaven for the purpose of investigating the charge which Barratt made against the pit in his letter. I know Whinneyhill pit. It is close to Hope pit, and communicates with No. 2 pit. The men working in the latter ride up and down Whinneyhill pit, but I did not choose to go down the latter because of the bad reports about it. The people about the pit told me it was not fit for anybody to put his head into it. — When did you get that information? — The day that I was there, and found the engine broken. — Did you never hear it before? — Up to the time I got this letter I had no particular object in going down the pit at all. — But you are an inspector. — But I am not to be presumed to know the precise condition of every pit in my district. — The charge you have brought against us is a very serious one; will you tell us who informed you that this shaft was not fit to go down in? Mr. Webster: — I don't know whether Mr. Dunn should expose the sources of his information. He may please himself, but from the way in which these men are treated I think it is dangerous for him to answer the question. Do you think it is desirable to do so, Mr. Dunn? — Mr. Lumb: He is bound to answer it. — The Chairman (to Mr. Brockbank). Is he legally bound to give the names of his informant? — Mr. Brockbank said there was no doubt that as a general rule a public officer was not bound to state the source of any information given him privately in the exercise of his duty. — Mr. Lumb (to Mr. Dunn): Will you, then ride off on the protection of that or not? — Mr. Dunn: Allow me to say I cannot tell the name of the person. — When you got the information that the pit was in a dangerous state, you did not think it proper to ask the name of your informant. — I did not think of going down. — That is not an answer. Did you ask the name, and make a minute of it? — Whilst we were about the pit waiting for the overman coming, I spoke to one of the engine tenders, and he told me that it was not fit to put anybody's head in it. I came back at the end of the week, and then went down No. 2 pit. I saw Barratt on the 19th, and he told me he had got notice to quit. The notice ran a fortnight, and was then nearly expired, so that the notice must have been given not at the end of December, but early January. Taylor denied that Barratt had been discharged for threatening to write to the proprietor, but said it was for having used bad language. Barratt's statement is that the bad language fell from Taylor. When I went to the directors I told them that I was unwilling to take Taylor's evidence against Barratt in the absence of the latter, and I entreated them to allow Barratt to be brought before them. The directors did not choose to do this. They said they could not gainsay what Mr. Bailes had done. I did not tell the directors what Taylor had told me, for I put no value upon what any person says against another in his absence. Barratt was not a trailer. Mr. Bailes represented him as such, but I made out in the pit that the designation was wrong. — Did you ask whether Barratt had ever been standing here, (pointing to the criminal dock in the court)? — I had nothing to do with his character. — Do you know that such is the fact? — I don't. I know that Barratt contradicted Mr. Bailes about it in my presence. — Do you not know that Barratt was in Carlisle gaol for robbery? — No. I may have been told so, but I don't know of my own knowledge. — Mr. Brockbank: Excuse me, Mr. Lumb, but we are not trying the character of Mr. Barratt, but the character of the pit. — Mr. Lumb: But Barratt is the man who sets the machinery of the Act of Parliament against us, and we want to know his character. — Mr. Brockbank: It does not matter what his character is. The only question is this, when Mr. Dunn; after getting this information went and made inquiry, in what state did he find the pit. — The Chairman: The character of the pit does not depend on the testimony of the person who speaks about it to the inspector. It is tested and spoken to by the inspector himself. — Mr. Lumb: Very well, then, I will not pursue it. — Cross-examination continued: Mr. Thompson made no objections to my taking Mr. Steel with me to the pit. Was told afterwards by Mr. Lindow that he was sorry Mr. Steel did not see it. Did not tell Mr. Bailes that I had permission of the directors to take Mr. Steel down with me. I told him what had taken place with Mr. Thompson, and that I wished Mr, Steel to go down. — Did Mr. Thompson say whether you were to take him down or not? — He said neither one thing nor another. If Mr. Bailes says I said Mr. Thompson said he was to go down, it was false. Mr. Bailes said he could not allow anybody to go down without consent of the directors. — Was not that a very proper answer. — I don't know whether the directors chose to say it was proper or not. Was it not a proper answer to give under the circumstances of the case? — The directors expressed a desire to have a thorough investigation. — Mr. Lumb repeated his question. — Mr. Webster said that, under the 16th section of the act, it was for the magistrates to say whether the former viewer of the colliery should accompany the inspector. — Mr. Lumb: Under that section there is no authority for any one to go down but the inspector himself. — Cross-examination resumed: I had no contradiction from the directors to take anybody down. — No. You tried to throw dirt on Mr. Bailes, and I want to know whether he did right in refusing to let Mr. Steel go down. Now on your oath, did not Mr. Bailes do exactly what you would have done had you been in his place as an agent? — If I had been in the place of the directors. — No as their agent. Did he or did he not act as their agent do his duty when he said, "No Mr. Dunn unless I have the authority of the directors, I shall let nobody go down with you." Well if you think he was right I have no objection. When I examine the pits in my neighbourhood some proprietors might allow me to take one down to assist me, and some might not. My practice is this: When I get information from workmen as to the bad condition of a pit, I fix a day to examine it, and take with me three or four men deputed by the workmen. I never have been refused this on any occasion before. — Did you before Mr. Bailes was appointed, recommend a person as view to the directors? — Well, I named a person for the pit to correspond with. This is the second instance of my bringing gentlemen into court since 1850. — You have had some arbitration though. I don't know what you mean. — Are there not arbitrations where the inspectors' reports are not adopted? — Don't know of any such. This is the second case since 1850. — Was there not an arbitration between the Government and you and some pit in Durham? — O! but that was a different affair altogether.(Laughter.) — Was not that about the management of the pit? and did not the owner call upon the Government to appoint an arbitrator under the act? And he reported against you? — O! no it was a qualified report. — Was the report not against you. — It was not against me. It was qualified partly for me, and partly against me. — Who had the expenses to pay? — We paid them equally. — You had £25 to pay out of your own pocket? — It is a perfect lie! — Did Government pay it? — It was perfectly equal; but how long am I to stand here to answer such questions? — You only summoned one gentleman before this time? — Yes, an I got a conviction too. It was in the neighbourhood of Gateshead, and for want of ventilation. I went to that pit several times. I gave them notice of what I would do, and because they defied that notice I summoned them. — Did you give similar notice here? — I went personally to the directors. — Did you tell them you would summon them? I told them I had complaints against the pits. — The Chairman: Did he give you any written report after examining the pit? — Mr. Lumb: Not the slightest, though we pressed him for it. It was not necessary, I admit, but it appears that he has felt the propriety of such a course in other cases, though not in this. — Mr. Brockbank: He did not say that in the other case he gave written notice, but only that he gave notice. — Cross-examination resumed: I went to the directors in good spirit, and asked them to let the thing be properly examined into. Mr. Postlethwaite harassed me exceedingly on the ground that it was a well ventilated mine. They also harassed me exceedingly about this trailing business. About this brattice. You say, generally speaking, it was inefficient. What do you mean by that? — That it leaked air. Did not examine it myself. I say it leaked air on the authority of common fame. I know it from information, and from what Mr. Bailes admitted. — Mr. Bailes never admitted any such thing; have you seen it with your own eyes? — It would take days to examine it. — No doubt; but you did not examine it? — I saw that air was awanting in the pit. — So you jump to the conclusion that air was awanting because you were told the brattice was defective? — That may be. I did not examine the brattice myself. I had not power to stop the pit to enable me to do so. — You came here to swear to the truth of other people's reports, without knowing whether they are true? — I am not doing so. The brattice being bad it was most natural for the air to escape. — But you don't know whether the brattice was bad or not. Will you swear Mr. Bailes never entrusted you to examine this brattice? — Mr. Bailes never did any such thing. He knew that to examine it in detail would probably require days; but I suggested to him to stop the night shift, and get it properly examined and tightened. I saw one or two stoppings. I don't know how many may be in the pit. — The Chairman: Then because you saw one or two of wood, are we to infer that all the rest were of the same material? — Mr. Lumb: Yes. — Mr. Brockbank: No, he said some. — Mr. Lumb: Have you any idea how many were in the pit. — Complaint: I have not. One or two of them that I saw were nothing but wood. I don't' know that I would swear I saw two such, but if I saw one it would be improper and a breach of the rules. I swear positively I saw one. [Here a large plan of the pit was unrolled, but complainant could not point except generally, to the situation of the stopping in question.] It was a wooden stopping only. If it had been stone behind, unless plastered it would not answer the purpose. It was not plastered, I did not see that (Laughter.) I did not examine it. — The Chairman: These might have been stone or brick at the other side, which you did not observe? — Mr. Dunn: There might, I did not go expressly there to look out for stoppings. And yet you come here to convict us? — To convict you because you have not sufficient ventilation in the pit. — Where was the first gas you found? — The gas Mr. Atkinson and I found was at the end of the level, at the high end of the face, the highest part of the working, which is the natural place for the gas to be found. — Did you measure the quantity of gas? — No, I did not. — Do you mean to say as a practical colliery inspector that that gas could have been by any amount of ventilation? — I mean to say that if there had been an adequate amount of ventilation in that pit there should have been no gas in there at all. — Did you measure the quantity of air passing through the air courses on the 11th? — No, I had no need to measure it. I have published a book, which has had a very good run. Mr. Bailes has circulated a good many copies of it. That is it. — How many cubic feet of air ought the pit to have to be in good working order? — Such a question cannot be answered until all the conditions of the pit be stated, whether it is a fiery pit or not, the mode of working it, &c. — But you don't put it that way in your book? — This colliery is not an extensive one, but it is a very dangerous one, a very fiery one. — Now, on your oath, do you mean to say the pit is a dangerous pit? — Yes, I do mean to say so; and if any explosion were to take place at the pit and the brattice was to be damaged thereby, no one could be saved. — You say in your book there could not be less than 10,000 or 12,000 cubic feet of air per minute? — Yes, but that would be too little for this colliery. As a practical miner, I say that this pit should not have less than 30,000 cubic feet of air per minute to keep it right. — Would any less do? — I cannot tell, because we have got blowers there. If a blower were to come out of that coal and fire, what is to become of the pit? — But I am speaking of ordinary not extraordinary circumstances? — But you want to provide against extraordinary circumstances. — We want to provide for ordinary purposes? — Well, perhaps if you had 20,000 it would do under ordinary circumstances. — Oh, then, you come down 10,000 at a slap. (Laughter.) Now as you have come down from 30,000 to 20,000, will you swear that 10,000 or 15,000 would not be sufficient? — I will not swear 10,000 or 15,000 would be sufficient; you have two seams to ventilate. — Do you know Mr. Foster, the eminent mining engineer of great standing in your neighbourhood? — Yes, I do. Do you know Mr. Maddison? Is he a man of eminence? — Yes, he is pretty well up; but he does not rank so high as Mr. Foster. — Isn't Mr. Foster a great authority? Isn't he the first man in his profession? Well he is a great authority, I grant; but he is not the first. Mr. Wood, perhaps is a greater man than he. — Suppose after Mr. Wood he ranks second? — Well, I don't say he does not; but you don't mean that Mr. Foster is to rule and govern me in facts I see before my face? — Certainly not; I only ask your opinion as to his standing. — Very well; I don't deny it. Suppose there were two thirds of a cubic foot of gas in the pit do you consider that quantity dangerous? — I won't answer that question. I consider it a great risk to have any gas in a pit. I have seen gas under similar circumstances in pits in my own district often. — Then did, you summon the proprietors of those pits for it? — No, because I have generally found them willing to attend to my suggestion. When ever I have made suggestions to colliery proprietors to get gas away generally speaking. I have found they acted upon the suggestion almost without exception. — When they didn't do so did you summons them? — No, it does not follow when they infringe that rule that I should get a summons out against them right off hand. — Did you ask the proprietors of this colliery to make provision to take away this particular gas? — I had not seen this pit then. You saw it on the 11th, and then though you tell us it is your rule to make suggestions, you come to Whitehaven in hot haste, and got a summons off hand without ever seeing one of them? — Because the reception I got from the managers was such as to deter me from doing otherwise. What, sort of reception? — A very thankless reception. — Thankless! You are well paid for your office. Government men are very well paid, and don't expect to be thanked for what they do. Mr. Bailes came in July. Soon after did he not see you at the pit and say, "Mr. Dunn, if you can make any suggestions we shall be glad to follow them?" — It is all very good for Mr. Bailes to say that, but I must say more indomitable gentlemen I never saw in all my life. (Laughter) — What do you mean by "indomitable"? — Why, doing things his own way, and no other. — Did he ask you to make any suggestions? — I don't swear he did. Of all men I ever had anything to do with Mr. Bailes is the most obdurate, the most determined to do his own way. I could give you several instances that have occurred within the last few days. — Mr. Webster: Never mind. Mr. Lumb: Did not Mr. Lindow say to you that your suggestion would be carried out? — Mr. Dunn: He was not anxious to stop me, but the other two gentlemen were not so civil; they would support Mr. Bailes. In return for Mr. Lindow's civility I gave him a copy of my book. (Laughter.) — And took this information against him without saying a word? — I thought I only did my duty. The second quantity of gas we came to was in one of the uphill workings. It fired in the lamp. If there had been an explosion there that day the brattice, perhaps would not have been blown out. The lamps I looked at I did not examine with such nicety as to enable me to say whether the gauzes were good. — Had you them in your hands at all? — I saw them in the men's hands. — Did you meet them in any public house? — Never, if anybody says I did. — Mr. Lumb: Nobody says anything of the kind. — Mr. Webster observed that he was surprised the directors should allow such an insinuation to be thrown out. — Mr. Dunn: I did not ask the men if they had any complaint to make. Was told that a man who makes a complaint is not sure of his employment for a day. Several told me that. I cannot give you names. I have given you Barratt's and you won't have him. I wont, and cannot, give you the name of another. If I could I would not; but I cannot. I recommended that a section should be made between No. 2 pit and Hope Pit. — [Mr. Bailes: It is done.] — Mr. Webster then re-examined Mr. Dunn on a few points, in order to strengthen his testimony. — Mr. Atkinson, Government Inspector of mines was, next called, and said he had inspected Hope Pit in company with Mr. Dunn. He saw the gas at the level end, also that spoken to in the working. There was not a great accumulation of gas in either place, but it would have been dangerous to have been near if either had exploded. These accumulations of gas were brought about by the insufficient ventilation of the mine. He had examined the air on the north side, and found it to be what they called very slack: and there was not sufficient air, on the level. 16,000 cubic feet of air per minute would under ordinary circumstances, be sufficient to ventilate the mine. — Mr. Lumb thought that was sufficient to settle the question. — Mr. Webster begged to differ from him on that point. — Mr. Lumb: Well, you cannot alter such evidence as that. — Witness resumed: Measured the quantity of air going into the pit by means of an anemometer, and found 13,227.8 cubic feet of air per minute. Formed an opinion that air was leaking through the brattice as I found there was nothing like 13.000 feet of air passing through the tube at the outlet. There would not be more than a half or two thirds, say 7,000 or 8,000 feet of pure air passing through the pit. I found gas at the level of the high part, and the lamp fired inside the barrel. He was off the opinion that the gas ought to be removed as the pit made it. The workings were very variable, and in many parts it would be much better if they were not quite so wide. — In reply to Mr. Lumb, witness said he had been a Government Inspector of mines for seven years, and had been connected with collieries for 27 years; he served seven years' apprenticeship as a colliery viewer, and had since been in that line of business. — Mr. Lumb: Did you examine the brattice you have spoken about yourself, or did somebody tell you it was leaky? — Mr. Atkinson: I arrived at that conclusion upon discovering the discrepancy between the supply of fresh air and what was at the outlet. — Mr. Lumb: where did you test the escape? — Mr. Atkinson: I went into the bottom of the air way at the upcast shaft. Witness went on to say that if the gas he saw in the pit had exploded it would not have smashed all the brattice. There might have been some danger of the man's life in the working, but he did not think it would have done any other harm. He considered that the presence of gas in the two places were he saw it was a breach of the act. It would have been the duty of an overman to have stopped a man working in such a place. If the brattice were destroyed the ventilation would be gone altogether. In the north level he found the gas on the face near the roof. He had no idea of the quantity but it was in the corner of the place, which was about 8 feet high, and the gas might be about 6½ feet high. He did not see any naked lights in the pit. If the gas he saw had exploded he would not have liked to have been near it. He considered that if there was sufficient air in the pit it would be presumptive evidence that the brattice was insufficient. — Mr. Webster stated that this was the case. — Mr. Lumb submitted that from the evidence of the Government Inspector, the prosecution had entirely failed to make out a case. He had a number of witnesses to call for the defence, but before he proceeded to call those witnesses, he would leave it to the bench to say whether any case had been made out to call upon them for an answer. He contended that the summons ought to be dismissed on their own showing. — The Chairman: It is the opinion of the bench that evidence should be heard on both sides. — Mr. Lumb then proceeded to address the bench for the defence. He observed that he appeared on behalf of Mr. Bailes, who was agent for the Whitehaven Hematite Colliery Company. In the first place, he submitted that some member of the company, ought to have been summoned to answer that charge instead of the company's agent Mr. Bailes; but Mr. Dunn knew that he had a weak case to bring before the bench, and in order to that only the evidence of Mr. Bailes, for they knew that that gentleman's evidence would be inadmissible in that court, and that he could not be put into the box, as a witness, he had laid the information against that gentlemen instead of laying it against the company. Now when any gentleman came forward to prosecute on the part of the Government, he believed it was a rule in such cases either to summon a company in their corporate capacity, or one of the owners of the colliery to answer such a charge. Had that been done in that case they would then have had the evidence of the agent sitting there: but no, they were to have no evidence except that of the government inspectors, so that the evidence of the agent they wished to call to support their defence might be shut out. He contended that such a proceeding on the part of the prosecution was a great hardship upon the company. It was very hard that a summons should have been taken out by the Government Inspector in such a way as to shut out the principal evidence of the defence. Suppose they were to get a conviction in such a case as that, what moral influence did they think it would have when it was read in public? What would the public think of such an attempt upon the part of the Government officials, or upon that of their advisers, to close the mouth of one of their principal witnesses, and there by prevent them obtaining that evidence which they ought to have under ordinary circumstances? Let the bench put themselves in the same position as those gentlemen against whom that charge had been made. They had heard the charge, which had been made against those gentlemen. The charge was a very serious charge; it was an charge of working their pit whilst that pit was in a improper and inadequate state of ventilation; and in order to support that charge the Government Inspector had condescended to mean trick of shutting out the evidence of their principal witness for the defence by summoning him to answer that charge. — Mr. Webster (interrupting Mr. Lumb): In answer to that remark, I may state that it was under my advice those proceedings were taken. — Mr. Lumb resumed: He was very glad Mr. Webster had released the Government Inspector from the unpleasant position in which he had been placed: for he felt sure that if Sir George Grey heard of the case he would say that it was a very improper proceeding. The charge was a criminal one against Mr. Bailes, and he was afraid that if they offered to tender his evidence it would not be taken, and therefore his mouth was shut as to what took place between him and the Government Inspectors, and he could not be put into that box to contradict them. He would not make a few remarks upon the evidence which had bee taken in that case. What was the charge, which his client had to meet? Why, it was a charge laid under a highly petial section of the Act of Parliament, in which they were incurring a penalty of £20, for doing a certain thing. That Act of Parliament required that there should be an adequate amount of ventilation in all coal pits, so as to dilute and render harmless all noxious gases in such pits, under ordinary circumstances. Now, he would call their attention to the evidence, which had been brought forward to convict them under that Act of Parliament. Mr. Dunn, the government inspector, was the first witness put into the box. Now let them look at his evidence, and see whether it was fairly supported by that of his co-adjurer, Mr. Atkinson. Mr. Dunn's evidence went to show that when he examined the pit on the 11th of February, the brattice of the downcast shaft was not sufficiently thick to ensure a sufficient quantity of air passing down into the pit the pit to ventilate it properly. Now, that was a charge against many gentlemen present, and some who were not present, gentlemen who, he felt sure, were as desirotts of conducting their business is an honourable, manner as any body of gentlemen could possibly be. Now, how had that charge been supported? Why they must all be aware that in the course of Mr. Dunn examination, all he said about the matter, was from the information he had: received and not from his own personal observations. He did not mean to say that Mr. Dunn wished to deceive them when he gave his evidence; but when Mr. Dunn goes into the box, the slip-shod way in which he gave his evidence did appear to him both extraordinary and improper. Commenting upon that part of Mr. Dunn's evidence in reference to the letter of Mr. Barratt, he (Mr. Lumb) observed that he did not see how the company could interfere with their agent for discharging a man for insubordination, to his superior officers. If the company were to interfere in such a way with their agents, such interference should equally destroy all proper working authority in the colliery. Although Barratt had been working about ten years in the pit, yet, he had never written to the Government Inspector, complaining of the pit, until 1863. Although Mr. Dunn might be anxious to do his duty towards the workmen in different collieries, yet he thought he would have maintained his dignity better if he had said to Barratt when he received his letter, "No, this complaint comes too late you should have done this before, if you wished me to take steps in the matter." Now, surely they did not mean to say that those grievances of which Barratt had complained in his letter did not exist before he was discharged from the pit; therefore he ought to have complained to Mr. Dunn before he did. Now, what brought Mr. Dunn to Whitehaven on the 27th of January? Why, it was the letter written by the company themselves on the 22nd, asking Mr. Dunn to come here and inspect their pits. Mr. Dunn came down and went back again without making an inspection, and then the company wrote to him requesting him to come and inspect their pits in order to ascertain whether the charge made by Barratt was true or false. The letter had been read to them, and he need not trouble them with reading any more than a paragraph of it. — [Mr. Lumb here read the latter part of Mr. Thompson's letter, in which that gentleman request Mr. Dunn to come down and examine their colliery.] In consequence of that letter Mr. Dunn came down to inspect the pit on the 27th, and when Mr. Dunn went to Mr. Thompson, along with Mr. Steel, to see whether Mr. Steel could be allowed to go down the pit with him, Mr. Thompson, as an individual director of the company, could give Mr. Dunn authority to take Mr. Steel down the pit with him to examine it, and Mr. Bailes declined to allow Mr. Steel to go down without the authority of the directors. He thought Mr. Bailes was justified in refusing to allow Mr. Steel to go down the pit, seeing that that gentlemen was manager of a rival colliery in the neighbourhood; although, under the circumstances, he was extremely sorry that Mr. Steel had not been allowed to go down the pit. With regard to that part of the evidence where Mr. Dunn refused to go down the pit because he had been told that it was not in a fit state for any one to put their head into, he (Mr. Lumb) remarked that it was an extraordinary thing for a Government Inspector to allow a body of workmen to go down such a pit, and not inspect the pit himself. He thought Mr. Dunn was more ready to act upon the hear say opinion than upon his own personal observation. From the straightforward way in which Mr. Atkinson had given his evidence, he was glad to see that they had such a fair inspector between the colliery owners and the Government. Upon the corroborative evidence, he thought the case would entirely fail. Mr. Dunn had said that the ventilation in the south of the pit was very bad, whereas Mr. Atkinson had said that he considered the ventilation of that particular part of the pit to be in compliance with the requirements of the Act of Parliament. That was the kind of corroborative evidence upon which ten or twelve respectable gentlemen were to be convicted for a disgraceful offence. After a few more comments upon the evidence, Mr. Lumb concluded by observing that he would call Mr. Foster, Mr. Maddison, and Mr. Dixon, who were experienced mining engineers, and he had no doubt that after the bench had heard their evidence, they would come to the conclusion that that was not the case for conviction under the 10th section of the Act of Parliament. — At this stage the proceedings, it being nearly five o'clock, the bench decided to adjourn the case until 10 o'clock next morning. Friday, February 10. (Before the Rev. F. W. Wick (chairman), Rev. Canon Dalton, H. Jefferson, Esq. (Springfield), and Captain Sharpe. The hearing of the above important case was resumed this morning. Mr. Lumb, in opening the proceedings, remarked that before he proceeded to call the witnesses, he would call the attention of the bench to a point of law, and in doing so directed their attention to the 22nd section of the act, and to the information under which the defendant was charged. The information charged their agent with "neglecting one of the general rules duly established, and to be observed in the said colliery." Now, there had been no evidence given on the other side of any neglect on the part of their agent, and therefore he submitted that there was no offence under that act of Parliament. He would go so far as to say that there was no offence under the Act of Parliament. Mr. Webster, in reply, referred the bench to a case of a similar character, which had been decided by Chief Justice Colburn, which was to the effect that a colliery should be kept constantly ventilated, even when the men were not working in it; and therefore he would put in that case to show there had been neglect under that act. — Mr. Lumb said, the case which Mr. Webster had referred to was one in which the ventilation of the pit had been neglected for a day and a half. — The bench having decided that there was an offence under the act, Mr. Lumb called Mr. John Postlethwaite, solicitor who deposed that he was one of the partners in the Hematite Iron Company. There were ten partners in the colliery. They leased the pit from Lord Leconfield, and he was the superior landlord. They were constituted partners under a deed of partnership. He recollected Mr. Dunn calling at the office of the Hematite Iron Company on the 21st Jan last. Mr. Thompson and himself were present at the time; but Mr. Samuel Lindow was not there at the time. Mr. Dunn on that occasion produced a letter from Mr. Barratt, and read it over to Mr. Thompson. Mr. Thompson asked Mr. Dunn to allow him to take a copy of the letter. Mr. Dunn allowed him to have a copy of the letter, and a copy was accordingly taken by the clerk. Mr. Dunn said he had been brought to investigate No. 2 pit. They had never heard anything about Hope Pit until they got the summons from Mr. Dunn. When Mr. Dunn read the letter over to them, they informed him that they had had a report from Mr. Foster that very day, and they read the paragraph in the report to Mr. Dunn in which it was stated that the ventilation in the pit was good. With regard to Barratt, Mr. Dunn said he had encouraged him to write to him, and had understood they had dismissed Barratt for having written the letter, but he thought they ought to intercede with the manager to prevent his discharge. Until they saw the letter they did not know there was such a man as Barratt working at their pit. They inquired into the matter the following day, and they then ascertained the case of Barratt's dismissal. They had asked Mr. Dunn to make any suggestions he thought proper with regard to the pits, and had told him they would be most happy to carry them out in the best manner they could; but they could never get any suggestions from him. On the 29th of January, after Mr. Dunn had been down the pit, he complained of the foul state of No. 2 pit. He said the ventilation was weak and in a bad state and that the pit was dangerous. He said nothing about Hope Pit, that was never mentioned. He asked Mr. Dunn the question. "Is it not a fact that close to the workings in the pit of which you complain your lamp was blown out?" He repeated this question three times before Mr. Dunn gave him an answer. At last Mr. Dunn said, "Yes but it was not blown out by the air." — Mr. Webster: I don't know this had to do with this case. — Mr. Lumb: Well it has this to do with the case. The gentlemen who had the interview with Mr. Dunn have been charged with uncourageous conduct towards him, and therefore I wish to set them right. — The Chairman: But we have nothing to do with the animals in the matter. — Mr. Brockbank "One third of this is not evidence, and in my notes containing this evidence were to go before the judges, and they were to find that a great mass of matter had been imported into the case which was not evidence, they would not blame the directors, but they would blame me. — The Chairman: I think you had better confine yourself to the ventilation of the pit, Mr. Lumb. Examination continued: As one of the directors, I ask you if the directors had been applied to allow Steel to go down the pit, do you think the application would have been granted. — Yes, if application had been made to them, leave would have been given. In my opinion, Mr. Bailes was right in refusing to allow Steel to go down the pit without the authority of the directors. — In reply to Mr. Webster witness said he did not know that it was part of Mr. Dixon's duty to report to the directors upon the state of the pit. He was not aware that after Mr. Dixon or any of the company had decided to go down the pit. Mr. Samuel Lindow explained: I am a partner in the colliery. I attended the meeting of the company at which Mr. Dunn was present on the 27th of January. — Did you or any of your co-directors ask Mr. Dunn to make any suggestions with regard to the working of the mine and did you tell him you would be happy to carry these suggestions out? — Yes we did. — Did Mr. Dunn say anything about Hope Pit? — No he did not. — Was Mr. Postlethwaite courteous towards Mr. Dunn in asking him questions? — Yes, he was; but there was a great deal of fencing on the part of Mr. Dunn in answer to the questions put to him, the same as you saw yesterday. (Laughter) — Cross-examination: I heard the report Mr. Foster read, but I will not swear that he said anything about the brattice of the pit being bad. — Did Mr. Foster make any report as to the stoppage in the pit? — Mr. Lumb: That is not evidence. — We have had no notice to produce this report. — Mr. Webster did not press the question. — Mr. Lumb then called Mr. John Thompson who deposed: I am a partner and a director in this company. I was present at the meeting of the directors in January last. Mr. Dunn was at the meeting. The directors had some conversation with Mr. Dunn. In the course of that conversation Mr. Lindow repeatedly told Mr. Dunn that if he had any suggestions to make respecting the safety of the works we should be happy to carry them out. Mr. Dunn had never made any suggestions with regard to Hope Pit. His conversation referred to No. 2 Pit, and to the man who had been discharged from that pit by our manager. I heard questions put to Mr. Dunn by Mr. Postlethwaite, and I consider Mr. Postlethwaite was perfectly courteous towards Mr. Dunn. He put some of the questions to Mr. Dunn two or three times before he could get an answer, and to some of the questions he put he never got an answer at all. Mr. Dunn never said one word about the Hope Pit. — In cross examination, witness stated the circumstances under which Steel had not been allowed to go down the pit, and said that he told Mr. Steel when he spoke to him about going down the pit with Mr. Dunn that he, as an individual director, could not grant Mr. Steel permission to go down the pit without the consent of Mr. Bailes, and that of the other directors of the company. Mr. Steel left their employ on good terms. He left to better his condition. Mr. Fosters report was a private document for the information of the company. — William Morris examined: I live at Keekle Terrace, and am foreman deputy of Hope Pit. I have been in the pit five months altogether. I came from St. Helens, in Lancashire. I have been connected with collieries for 25 years as pitman, sinker, and in different other capacities. The ventilation of Hope Pit has been good since I was appointed overman in it. In comparison with other pits which I know I consider the ventilation is adequate and sufficient for the proper working of the pit. In my opinion there is no danger to life or property in the pit on account of ventilation. I recollect the 11th February. The ventilation was very good that day. In my opinion there was no danger then. I believe a small quantity of gas was found in the pit that day. It was found in the up-bank, about 200 yards from the shaft. It was right up in the "bearing tops," above the level of the roof. It was found in the hole about twice the size of my hat. The men were standing six feet from it, and it could not be reached without climbing up to it. I could not say how much gas there would be. I examined the working in which the gas was found about half past three o'clock that morning, but I did not see any gas. I did not climb to that hole to look for gas. If I had climbed up and found any, I would not have thought there was any danger from it. I have charge of all the lamps in the pit. I carefully examined the lamps that day. The lamps were in good condition, or else I would not have allowed them to have gone into the pit. There were 40 lamps carried into the pit that day, and I found that they were all right. I examined Mr. Dunn's lamp as well. (Laughter.) That was done at the lamp cabin about 60 yards from the bottom of the shaft. — Oh! then there is a lamp cabin in the pit? — Yes, there is, and I unlocked the door, and went into it to lock the two inspectors' lamps, but Mr. Dunn said he did not think it was necessary to have his lamp locked. — Did you pass Mr. Dunn's lamp without being locked? — Yes, I did. — You thought you could not object to him seeing he was a Government Inspector? — (Laughter.) No I thought it was my duty to allow it to pass. — The Chairman: Perhaps Mr. Dunn did not think there was any danger in going into the pit with his lamp unlocked. — Mr. Lumb: Precisely so. — Examination continued: There has been a lamp locker and a cabin in the pit ever since I went into it. I receive all complaints in the pit, when there is a brattice broken I am told of it. Sometimes the ventilation of the pit has been interfered with by the breaking of the brattice which lead into the workings, but not by the shaft brattice. Sometimes the bratticing in the workings are broken by coals falling upon them, but they are always put right again. Mr. Bailes took the inspectors to both places where they found gas. There was no attempt at concealment of the fact on the part of Mr. Bailes. The inspectors went down the "dibbine" but they found no gas there. At the second place where gas was found, a man held his lamp up to the roof of the working, and the gas fired in the lamp. That was about five or six yards from where the men were working. In my opinion there was no danger from the gas. The gas at that place was about two feet long and about the depth of a lamp. As a practical miner I consider the pit safe under ordinary circumstances, or else I would not be in it. — Cross-examined: Never heard anyone complain of the gas except when the brattice in the workings was broken. He had found gas in the workings on previous occasions, perhaps once a month. He did not consider this a fiery pit. — Witness, recalled by Mr. Lumb: The inspectors did not warn the men against working in the pit when they visited it on the 11th of February. It is customary when find an accumulation of gas in the workings to beat it away with their caps. — Mr. Lumb here tendered Mr. Bailes evidence, but Mr. Brockbank said he could not be called as a witness. — Mr. George Dixon, C.E. said he was surveyor to Lord Leconfield, the lessor of Hope Pit, the whole of which he examined on Wednesday week, in company with Mr. Foster and Mr. Maddison. Under ordinary circumstances the pit was quite safe. At present the ventilation was quite sufficient. — William Morris, re-called, said the ventilation was the same when Mr. Dixon examined it as when Mr. Dunn was down. — Mr. Dixon cross-examined: Had had 25 years experience in collieries. Tested the ventilation by measuring it. There was very little difference, from his observation, between the air at the inlet and the outlet. Everything he examined was quite to his satisfaction. — Re-examined: Took the lamp top off at the outlet, where all the gas would be if there was any in the pit. John Lee, overman, Hope Pit, said all the permanent stoppings were built of brick. Where wood was put up it was because they wished to stop the escape till they got the bricks and mortar in. In his opinion the pit was quite safe. — Cross-examined: They had put in two stoppings since the 11th February, substituting brick for wood. No man had ever complained of the gas in the pit, except when the brattice was broken. — Mr. Henry Mulcaster, colliery viewer for Lord Lonsdale, said he heard all the evidence, and was of opinion that the pit was adequately ventilated. — Cross-examined: Heard Mr. Atkinson's evidence. Also Mr. Dunn's, but did not agree with them. It did not follow that because gas was found the ventilation was bad. The custom in the neighbourhood is to have the brattice about 1½ inches thick. — Mr. Thomas Emmerson Foster, examined I reside at Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, and am a mining engineer. I have had charge of coalmines for 14 years, and during that time I have had extensive practice as a mining engineer. I am viewer of the Seaton Delalval Colliery, which is an extensive colliery in Durham. I am consulting viewer to Lord Lonsdale. On the 18th of December I examined the collieries at Cleator Moor, by the request of the directors of the Hematite Iron Company. I went into every working about the place that day, and I found every place perfectly free from gas. I did not consider Hope Pit a very fiery pit. The brattice of that pit was in a good state, and it was sufficiently ventilated for all ordinary purpose. The absence of gas proved that it was sufficiently ventilated. On Wednesday last, I examined the Hope Pit workings in company with Mr. Maddison and Mr. Dixon. We made a thorough investigation of the pit. We examined the return air way from the bottom of the up-cast shaft. I took the lamp top off, but did not find the slightest indication of gas. I did not see that any extraordinary means of ventilation had been made for my visit. The quantity of air passing into the pit was 18,738 cubic feet per minute. That quantity of air had to ventilate from two or three acres of workings, which I consider was very small extent indeed. I have no hesitation in saying that the quantity of air was sufficient to ventilate that pit for all purposes whatever. We went into the highest working of the pit, which is 100 feet above the level of the shaft, and if there had been any gas in the pit we would have been able to have found it there. In my opinion the gas the inspectors found was not of the slightest consequences whatever. I never saw a colliery more free from gas. There are 68 men and boys and three ponies in the Hope Pit; and in the Seaton Delalval pit there are 420 men and boys and 61 horses and ponies. In that pit there are 53,000 cubic feet of air going through it in a minute; and the pit is fifty times as large as Hope Pit. There is only double the quantity of air circulated in Delalval pit as is circulated in Hope pit. I consider it would be madness to drive the workings any narrower in Hope pit. I consider there is an ample quantity of air accumulated in Hope pit to provide for the respiration of the men, and also for driving off the gas. The quantity of gas I found in the north level in the "nicking" was about a cubic foot and a third. At the place where the gas was found it had been produced by a "dike." The gas was not there under ordinary circumstances; but it could not be prevented in consequence of the "dike." If the gas had exploded it would not have caused the slightest damage. Indeed, I would have set fire to it as the best way of getting rid of it. It was about eight feet high, and out of the way of a man. The pit could have been worked with candles. I would have laughed at the government inspector had I been with them, and they talked of danger. At the place where the second gas was found, the quantity would amount to about two thirds of a cubic foot. In all my experience I never heard of such a prosecution as this. I have made the calculation as to the ventilation with a little gunpowder smoke. I have no doubt the quantity of gas was what I have stated. The brattice was in very good state. — Cross-examined: Made a report about the pit in December, in which he stated that the pit was in a good state of ventilation. The company's agent never complained of the brattice. It would not be desirable to have thicker brattice than the one at present. If there were 15,000 feet of air going into the pit per minute it would be quite safe. It would be about 70 feet from the furnace where he tested it. Examined the stoppings, and found one near the face of the working of wood, but it had brick facing behind it. They always replaced the wooden stoppings by stone ones. Believed Mr. Atkinson was mistaken in saying the men would have been burned if the gas he saw had fired. He (Mr. F.) recommended the pits to be worked as before. The bench here declined to hear any further evidence, and dismissed the case. The following statement of William Maddison of Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, viewer of the Burradon Coxlodge, and Benwell Collieries, &c, would have been made by him had the magistrates required further evidence:— On February 29th 1863, early in the morning, I, in company with the manager and overman, examined the wood brattice, which forms the ventilating medium in the shaft of the Hope Pit, Cleator Moor Colliery, very minutely, and found it to be in very good state, and without any apparent leakage. The brattice I found to be made of one and a half-inch deals, dressed up and very fit for the use to which they are applied. They are feathered and grooved, with slivers at the ends. The buntons holding the brattice are made of strong planks, nine inches by three, and six feet apart. They are also in perfectly good order. The sides of the brattice are thoroughly caulked with oakum, and whatever the sides of the pit seemed to be uneven, filleting has been fitted on, in order to make it perfectly tight. To prove the quantity of leakage in the partition or brattice, I computed the amount of air passing, both at the bottom of the up-cast shaft in the return current from the working, and also at the top of the pit, between the shaft, and the ventilation surface. At the bottom of the shaft I found it to be after the mean of three separate trials 18,197 cubic feet of air per minute passing at the top of the upcast shaft 19,300 cubic feet per minute, showing a loss-by leakage in the brattice of 1,100 cubic feet, which is a very small quantity when the depth of the pit is considered, it being 120 fathoms.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 12 Mar 2023
|
Search |
|
|||