|
24th February 1863 Government Inspection Of MinesThe frequency and the terrible character of accidents in coal mines in this country in late years have induced great interest on the subject of ventilation, among the public, and more earnest attention on the part of our legislators and the Government. In and out of Parliament the principle had been laid down that those who engage in mining undertakings ought and must make due provision for the safety of the lives of the people whom they employ. They are very few, we apprehend, who would gain say the propriety of this requirement, or who would withhold their approval of proceedings properly taken to enforce the requirement where disinclination to fulfil it had been evinced. On the other hand we have had a case investigated before the magistrate at Whitehaven a few days ago that has had results which it is to be hoped will prove a useful lesson to those whose business it is, when occasion arises. To set the lave in motion. We feel quite sure that if Mr. Inspector Dunn had been in a position to establish his charge against the Whitehaven Hematite Iron Company, of having failed to make provisions for the sufficient ventilation of one of their pits — of having, in fact, wilfully jeopardised the lives of their miners, the public sympathy with this useful class of men would have been as fully expressed as the magistrate would have been found ready to convict the defendants and to mulct them in the penalty prescribed by the law bearing upon this subject. The Government Inspector, however, has utterly failed in this proceeding, evidence of the most conclusive and irresistible character having been adduced on the part of the Hematite Company to show that the pit in question is not dangerous either to life or property, the ventilation being sufficient for every possible purpose pertaining to mining operations. The magistrate therefore dismissed the information of the Government Inspector, and we find that be doing so they have given great satisfaction to the public, who feel that, independent of the evidence with which the Company was enabled to refute the charge of insufficient ventilation, that charge was originated in a manner most reprehensible under circumstances such as those which were disclosed in the course of this inquiry. The due responsibilities of mining companies are heavy — perhaps not too heavy as compared with the value of human life, — but certainly heavy enough without the liability of being dragged before the justices at any moment to answer complaints founded, at all events impart, upon the representations of a discarded servant, and prosecuted with the precaution of shutting the mouth of the very man who could have the best of all evidence upon the subject. It was hardly to be expected, in the case of an information so conducted, that the usual preliminary notice to the directors of the Company would precede the taking out of the summons; but it was quite of course that Mr. Dunn's witness, another Government Inspector, should be asked whether he would have prosecuted a Company in such a manner; and, as was remarked by defendants' advocate, the fact of the witness having desired that the question might not be pressed, spoke volumes. Whether Mr. Dunn will consider it desirable to take any further proceedings we are ot aware; but if he should, they must be differently conducted, or he need not look either for the judgement of the Bench in his favour, or for the endorsement of concurrence on the part of the public. Whatever may be Mr. Dunn's intentions, the Hematite Company, we are credibly informed, have determined that the matter shall not end with the very proper dismissal of the Inspector's charge against them, but that the Secretary of State shall be communicated with, with a view to an investigation by the House of Commons as to the mode in which the duties of Government Inspectors of mines are, or ought to be preformed.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||